I pre-recorded my ETS talk to practice for time. If you missed it, you can check it out here: https://t.co/InaFx9y8Xp
Empathy & the Imago Dei:Resisting AI-Curated Desire and Delegated Violence
@etsjets#AI#empathy#imagoDei
When a system decides what is a threat, who has looked at the face?
Targeting systems now produce lists faster than anyone can read them. Police departments buy software that predicts who will offend. Benefits offices let an algorithm flag the file before a person opens it. In each case a judgment falls on a human being, and the one who signs it may never have seen the person it concerns.
Scripture has seen this before. David wrote a letter ordering Uriah's death and sent it to Joab by Uriah's own hand. The king kept his distance, and the order did the rest. “The thing that David had done was evil in the eyes of the LORD” (2 Sam 11:27), and God sent a prophet to tell a story until the king could see what he had done.
At the ETS Annual Conference on Tuesday, I'll argue that empathy, rightly understood, is the disciplined perception of the neighbor, and that this perception belongs to the office the image of God confers. A machine can sort a population. Someone in the chain still has to answer for the person at the end of it.
Empathy & the Imago Dei: Resisting AI-Curated Desire and Delegated Violence
ETS 2026 · Tue, Nov 17 · 1:30 PM MT
Grand Ballroom I, Tower Building, Sheraton Denver Downtown
#ETS2026 #ImagoDei #AIethics #TheologicalAnthropology
Different perspective… the chart is a bit misleading. The NRSV/NRSVue is used as the closest translation in biblical scholarship; it’s grounded in textual criticism and manuscript evidence. The issue is conflating word-for-word translation with textual accuracy. Literal English doesn’t necessarily preserve the meaning of ancient Hebrew, Aramaic, or Greek. KJV placement ahead of the NRSV is super questionable given its limited manuscript base.
@BobTheBaptist In the words of our Savior, “And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by others. Truly I tell you, they have received their reward in full.” Mat 6:5
@farmingandJesus In the words of our Savior, “And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by others. Truly I tell you, they have received their reward in full.” Mat 6:5
Last week, I gave the keynote at the 2026 JIS Symposium, “The Future of Democracy: Renewing Ordered Liberty.” The recording is now up. It's 40m or 20 at 2x...and, it's for anyone who carries a phone.
https://t.co/7CveAqL5OW
__________________
Democracy After Datafication: Personhood and the Renewal of Ordered Liberty
The talk begins with a transaction. Private companies collect the record of a person’s body, movements, and habits, and they sell it. Agencies of the United States buy it, and in buying it they acquire what the Fourth Amendment would forbid them to seize. The person in the middle is never consulted and is, in the end, the thing sold.
I argue that the founders already had a word for what cannot be sold, that Christian anthropology explains why, and that Congress needs to write the word back into law.
Along the way... Larry Ellison’s “five billion,” Weigel on culture and cult, the cargo list of Revelation 18, the Babylonian mouth-opening rite and Genesis 2, Carpenter and the “privacies of life,” and a proposed statute that would stop the state from buying what it could not lawfully seize.
The person was never raw material. The image God gave at creation was never ours to sell, and it was never theirs to buy.
#OrderedLiberty #ImagoDei #Datafication #FourthAmendment #AIEthics #ArtificialIntelligence #SuperIntelligence #Oracle #Palantir #OpenAI #Grok
I appreciate the clarification. I don’t have to inhabit your experience to take it seriously (ref: Edith Stein, phenomenology)…but, you’re moving from “men may experience this differently” to “women’s moral objections arise from their inability to understand men.” That conclusion doesn’t follow. A woman can understand what you’re expressing and still have sound reasons to question it.
The question isn’t whether the satisfaction feels real. It’s whether that satisfaction, and its outward expression, should be affirmed. Neither testosterone nor a reward response settles that. Christian discipleship calls all of us to examine what we find satisfying. Being natural to us doesn’t make something faithful to Jesus.
No one is arguing that Jesus ignored her sin. He called her to leave it. The point is that he didn’t require her execution to take her sin seriously. Saying he bore her sin at the cross doesn’t undo that distinction.
Matthew 5:17–19 affirms the Law and the Prophets and their fulfillment in Jesus. It doesn’t establish that every civil penalty in Israel’s covenant law remains binding on contemporary governments. That’s an additional claim you still have to defend. If you’re invoking this passage to require those penalties today, does that include executing adulterers and Sabbath breakers? On what textual basis do you retain some penalties and exclude others?
Read the rest of the sermon, too. The Jesus who speaks of fulfillment goes on to command love for enemies and prayer for persecutors (Matt. 5:43–48). Those teachings belong in the interpretation of his opening statement.
As for “the wages of sin is…” finish the sentence: “but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Rom. 6:23). Paul is explaining sin’s dominion and God’s gift of life, not giving governments a sentencing guideline. If the first clause establishes a civil obligation to execute sinners, the scope extends to every one of us.
God’s justice and love aren’t competing attributes. Nor does mercy mean that evil doesn’t matter. The God of the OT explicitly declares that he takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked and desires repentance and life (Ezek. 33:11). That’s part of the OT you’re asking me to take seriously. I do. I’m an OT professor.
This isn’t about what I’m personally owed. When you invoke God’s authority to justify taking a human life, you assume responsibility for defending that claim. That’s a burden of argument, not a demand for personal accommodation.
Your reading of John 8 also adds something the text doesn’t say. The passage never identifies the accusers as guilty of adultery. You’ve supplied that premise, then used it to conclude that anyone who hasn’t committed the offender’s particular crime is qualified to cast the first stone. That conclusion isn’t in the text either.
Jesus does tell her to leave her sin. He also declines to condemn her. Her guilt is acknowledged, and her life is spared. Recognizing sin and extending mercy coexist in his response.
I haven’t disputed the horror of this man’s crime or the necessity of accountability. I’m questioning the claim that faithfulness to God requires his execution. Arguing that a Christian may carry out a death sentence doesn’t establish that God requires it. Those are different claims.
The offender’s guilt hasn’t erased God’s image. Ezek. 33:11 and Jesus’ commands concerning enemy-love and mercy still require engagement. Your willingness to cast the stone doesn’t answer the question of whether Christ calls you to do so.
Rejecting your interpretation isn’t rejecting God. You don’t get to equate the two and then call everyone else disingenuous.
You said the state prevents husbands from enforcing consequences. What consequences? Name the specific actions you believe a husband should be permitted to take against his wife. That’s a reasonable question arising directly from your words.
The existence of marital responsibilities doesn’t establish a husband’s authority to punish. That’s the premise you keep asserting without demonstrating from Scripture. Even within a complementarian reading, Ephesians 5 commands husbands to love, nourish, cherish, and give themselves up for their wives. It doesn’t commission husbands to enforce obedience through punishment.
If you’re appealing to Mosaic penalties, be explicit about that too. Those included stoning for certain offenses, not a general license to punish a wife for failing to meet her husband’s expectations.
A wife remains God’s image-bearer and a coheir of the grace of life (1 Pet. 3:7). Her husband’s interpretation of his authority doesn’t erase her moral agency.
You’ve accused your critics of rejecting God before establishing that the authority you’re defending comes from God. Calling your position “Christian” doesn’t supply the missing argument.
Calling opposition to public execution isn’t “resisting justice” … nor does it establish its righteousness. The victim still bears God’s image, & the offender hasn’t ceased to bear it. Biblical justice has to balance both. You can’t simply equate justice with your preferred punishment and then accuse everyone who questions it of complicity in murder.
Very well. The strongest version of your argument is that satisfaction in deserved punishment isn’t necessarily bloodlust. You’re arguing that men may experience that satisfaction in a particular visceral way, & that a woman who doesn’t share the experience may mistake a legitimate desire for justice for something vicious.
I understand that distinction. Satisfaction in justice and pleasure in cruelty aren’t identical. Your post, however, goes considerably further.
You wrote that a woman “physically cannot understand” the male perspective, that “she must assume” the response is dysfunctional or evil, and that she has “no way to discern” bloodlust from a hunger for justice. You concluded that the possibility of this yearning being godly is “incomprehensible to her.”
Those are the words I’m addressing. My reading doesn’t depend on an isolated “this.”
If “an inability to understand justice” was too broad a formulation, I can make it more precise… you attributed to women an inability to distinguish bloodlust from what you regard as a potentially godly desire for retributive justice. That’s a narrower claim, but it’s still a claim about women’s capacity for moral discernment, not JUST a difference in emotional experience.
Not sharing an emotion doesn’t make someone incapable of understanding or evaluating it… nor, does disagreeing with your evaluation demonstrate that incapacity. Otherwise, your argument becomes self-sealing (a circular loop as they say) a woman’s objection becomes evidence that a woman cannot possibly understand.
The theological question remains valid. A visceral response doesn’t establish its own godliness. Even granting a difference between male and female responses, the movement from “men may feel this” to “this yearning may be godly” requires an independent moral & theological argument.
I’m happy to represent your position accurately. I’m asking you to defend the claims you actually made about women’s inability to discern, & the basis for identifying the desire you describe as potentially godly. Hopefully, that answers your question, respectfully, sir.
@WCCollier1 I started to screenshot your own post, then thought… “no, he knows what he wrote.” Still, feel free to clarify any points I misinterpreted.
What concerns me in this conversation is how readily Christian voices are treating the public display of death as a demonstration of faithfulness to God.
What the murderer did was horrific. The victims’ lives were sacred. Their families deserve care & love, and justice matters immensely. None of that requires us to declare that the offender’s humanity has expired. The imago Dei isn’t a reward for good behavior. A person can commit unspeakable evil and still bear the image of God. That’s precisely why Christian moral reasoning is demanding…accountability and human dignity remain obligations at the same time.
Gen. 9:6 grounds its sanction against murder in that image. Israel’s law includes communal executions and a deterrent purpose. I know those texts by heart. The question is how Christians interpret and apply them within the whole canon, in light of Jesus Christ. Citing a biblical penalty doesn’t complete the argument for broadcasting an execution.
God takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but desires repentance and life (Ezek. 33:11). Jesus commands us to love our enemies, pray for our persecutors, and practice mercy because our Father is merciful (Matt. 5:44; Luke 6:35–36). Those commands have to shape our response to the guilty, including people whose actions horrify us.
Romans 13 does give the state a responsibility to administer justice. It doesn’t relieve the church of its responsibility to bear faithful witness to Jesus. Christians can disagree about capital punishment while still asking whether turning an execution into a public spectacle forms people in mercy, sober judgment, and reverence for human life.
Wrapping it in an American flag or putting a sermon on it doesn’t answer that question, and invoking Jesus’ name carries a responsibility to represent his character faithfully.
Our faith centers on a crucified and risen Savior. His innocence distinguishes his death from the punishment of a murderer. His command to love our enemies, nevertheless, reaches the guilty. As long as a person lives, repentance remains possible.
I’m most concerned about what we’re teaching people to love, what we’re teaching people to applaud, and whose character the watching world sees when we call it Christian.