@charlesnow97812@shanejoll You’re missing the point. I never said you should be able to do better. I’m asking what evidence proves they’ve done a bad job. Pointing to one draft isn’t much of an argument. And again, it’s a 5-person selection committee making these decisions—not one bloke.
@shanejoll I am 100% passionate like you Shane. He does not make the final decision. But yes I agree he is the head of that department. Let' see how he goes this draft period that might change your opinion. I think it will.
@charlesnow97812@shanejoll OK. Give me some. Educate me. I am defending him but I am stating easy for people just to throw that out when they have NO idea. Could you recruit a AFL legend with every selection. NO !
@shanejoll Never said Brady’s done a good job. I said it’s easy for people with no idea what goes on internally to have a crack. BTW, list decisions are made by a 5-person committee, not Brady alone. Could you pick an AFL legend with every draft pick? I don’t think so, mate.
@shanejoll Not defending but also I cant kick him either. Impossible to pick winners all the time. Half the league are in the same boat when selecting.
@Bombers_Boss Horse will have a challenge to turn VFL players into AFL players. Can't see it happening. Came for a good old pay check like Ben McKay !!!! HA HA HA HA
@charlesnow97812@shanejoll You know he does not make the decisions. You know it is a group of 5 people. You know he cannot make the final decision. Easy for people to scream and shout without knowing the actual facts. When you ask somebody what did he do wrong they are unable to answer.
@timbo_755@shanejoll Yep, all by himself he destroyed the club. Please.
North’s list decisions are made by a List Management Committee — recruiting, drafting and trading are collective decisions, not one person acting alone.
Understand how it actually works before making silly comments.
@DryburghTom Burn the memberships. Never watch footy again. It’s the end of the world! 😂
C’mon people. Both clubs are at completely different stages of their rebuilds.
And last time I checked, Simmo played for the Kangas too.
We’ll survive.