π Daughter & Heir to the King
πΊπ² Proud Heritage American πΊπ²
Native American πΊπ²
I β€οΈ President Trump & Melania
πΊπ² 1776-2026 America's 250th
I love how these guys just make up history based on vibes.
But then, they kinda have to, because the entire CivNat philosophy is destroyed by reading the first sentence of the constitution.
CivNats claim that a piece of paper, granted by the federal government, defines an American. And claim that there is no such thing as a "Heritage American".
But on what does the authority of the federal government rest?
The Constitution.
And on what does the authority of the Constitution rest?
Well, the Constitution itself tells you. In the first sentence.
"We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
That authority derives from "We, the People of the United States".
Who were β not ARE, but WERE β the people of the United States, when this document was written? They had to exist at that time, because the constitution could not be approved by people who didn't exist yet.
Therefore, they had to be the People of the United States of America at the time the Constitution was written.
Therefore the definition of an American preexists the Constitution. As it must, because they very claim that the Constitution makes to this authority rests on that definition.
If there were no "we, the people" until the federal government defined them, then the constitution, and thus the federal government, has no authority to do anything.
That means that Paperwork Americans could only ever exist if Heritage Americans not only existed, but had the authority to frame laws, and define what their nation was to be.
And for what purpose did they establish the Constitution?
To secure a list of benefits for themselves (Heritage Americans) and their posterity.
Well, who is their posterity?
Well, words mean things. And words meant things at the time. We don't get to redefine the individual words of their Constitution, that they wrote, because if we did that, they it, and any other document, could mean literally anything. We must read the words as they wrote them, without redefinition.
Posterity obviously includes their direct biological descendants, because that's what the fucking word means.
And here's the important bit: if you wish to claim and word "posterity" included anyone or anything else, in addition to their direct biological fucking descendants, then the burden of evidence is on you.
And that evidence must come from contemporary sources. Not definition-changing shit someone came up with later to put words in their mouths.
Have you any contemporary evidence?
I think you haven't bothered to look.
@ElJackOff@contramordor π€£ππ€£ I want you to say that to the Sentinelese. They are free to exist fully as their own people, without ANY foreigners.
Bjarki, I appreciate you loving America and being a proud American. You would have to check your ancestry deeper. Heritage Americans means Old Stock/Founding Stock...like 1776 Revolutionary War or before (think colonial America and wild frontier). Have you deeply checked your family tree before? Perhaps your family married others who married lines who had colonial American ancestry. One line arriving in the 1930s is not the whole story unless you know many more lines. I would recommend looking into it further! We have like infinity great grandparents. Highly recommend checking & doing genealogy if you haven't done so.
Prime example. His first reaction is to assume I was talking about race. Also, all these over reactions seem to miss the key points. Based on his response it seems we are on the same page on almost every issue he brings up.
Sounds like he was an 18B, so in real life, he and I would probably get along very well and have many mutual friends. But instead of reading what I actually said, he adopts the leftwing attack of "it must be racism."
What a time to be alive.
You're not a real American, Ted Lieu. You were born in Taiwan & you're Taiwanese. Respectfully, thank you for your service. But you're a foreigner hiding behind a military outfit & serving in our military does NOT magically make you an American. No different than if an American went to Taiwan and served in the military there it does NOT make the American magically Taiwanese. You're NOT an American.
Dear @bofrench: I love your lineage and history. I read about it in history class in high school.
I hope you love mine.
At the end of the day, we are all Americans.
You're not a real American, Ted Lieu. You were born in Taiwan & you're Taiwanese. Respectfully, thank you for your service. But you're a foreigner hiding behind a military outfit & serving in our military does NOT magically make you an American. No different than if an American went to Taiwan and served in the military there it does NOT make the American magically Taiwanese. You're not an American.
@RoyUnitas Have an amazing vacation. When you come back, be sure to also check out my wall to see all the chaos you missed. π Harmeet went on a blocking rampage. Nick Fuentes. Raja. English DNA stuff. And more.
@JimHansonDC Your entire post shows you haven't read what I actually said. You are putting the same words in my mouth as the commies. Seems like we agree on almost everything. Do better.
King Charles basically bows to Islam. At least Queen Elizabeth II was more devoted to her Christian faith. So don't even try to start an argument with me. White men and White women must work together. Still Built, calling everyone names....you are literally being a leftist who can't debate at all so you just deflect to name calling.
Anglo is correct. Still Built, crack open a history book for once. You're British, learn your history. You have had many successful female monarchs, FFS. Don't act like you didn't cry or get deeply sad when Queen Elizabeth died. They want you to be brainwashed against White women and for White men and White women to be divided. Don't you get it? Resist the brainwashing.