@smallyt_tools Neither alone. I swap when views flatten but impressions keep coming, and CTR sits below the channel's usual average for that source. That's when people are seeing it and saying no.
Same viewer. Same thumbnail. Same no. YouTube can show your video to the same person more than once. If they skipped it on Monday, the same thumbnail won't change their mind on Friday. A new one might.
Your thumbnail might only be on screen for a second.
On the YouTube mobile feed, videos start playing muted as soon as people stop scrolling.
Which means your first 3 seconds are your second thumbnail.
Don't waste them on an intro.
Your thumbnail doesn't just get clicks.
It chooses your audience.
The people who click teach YouTube who your video is for. Wrong clicks = wrong viewers = wrong recommendations.