You can think what you like, but it’s literally stuff you can research yourself.
I’m neither, just not a fan of people using false information to push narratives. If you want to use the actual evidence then go ahead. But using this as an admission of guilt when it really isn’t just isn’t helping your cause.
Thanks for your time too sir. Have a good evening ☺️
Yes, if you research lawyer proceedings you would literally see that it’s their job, they can no longer try to plead innocence, they can only accept the jury’s findings.
Okay, let’s propose the alternative…lawyer stands there and says nah f**k you all, you’re all lying, my client didn’t do it. Doesn’t take that much thought to realise the judge would throw the entire book at him.
By saying it was a momentary failure, is a weird way of saying “my client is a good character, and this one incident was a lack of judgement and a mistake”, therefore likely to lessen a sentence, by making it sound like a mistake rather than deliberate.
And no an admission would likely jeopardise the case as a whole, as it would call the lawyers motives into question by admitting guilt of a client that maintains their innocence. 🤷🏻♂️
Because despite the words being facts, the narrative you are all using them to push is false.
This isn’t an admission of guilt. This was said at sentencing after the jury already decided he was guilty. At that point the the barrister can no longer try and say it didn’t happen. Their job then becomes to get their client the shortest time in prison by saying/doing whatever is required.
The entire trial would be called into disrepute and likely have to be done all over again if a barrister suggested/admitted their client was guilty whilst the client still maintained innocence.
This really isn’t the admission of guilt you think it is.
It was said at sentencing after the jury had already decided he was guilty. Lawyers are no longer allowed claim innocence at this point and must say/do whatever is needed to get the shortest sentence possible, as is standard practice.
The entire trial would be called into disrepute if his own lawyer admitted/suggested his guilt whilst Brand still claims innocence.
@TheRealJamieKay Understanding that the right hand side of escalators is for standing, the left is for walking up or down……if you break this rule…..DEPORT, no first warnings, no slap on the wrist, first sub £100 flight out the country.
Or you could and hear me out on this one……have a civilised conversation like 2 normal people who despite having differing opinions end the conversation respectfully like we did.
By muting people you end up in an echo chamber thinking you are 100% right. Open dialogue is the way forward good sir. I’ve never said I’m not open to having my opinion changed, but no one has offered me a reason I see good enough to change that opinion.
But you do you sir. Have a good evening. ☺️
We really are going round in circles, so I’ll do my position once more and then I think we should probably call it a day. 🤣
I personally do not believe that testimony alone, especially ones that weren’t direct eye witness to the incident, should be enough to convict someone.
If you want to carry on implying what I mean by that, go ahead and be like well are you suggesting this, be my guest. But it isn’t gonna change my opinion that I don’t think words alone should be able to convict. 🤷🏻♂️
But really nice chat, been fun even if we have differing opinions.
@JamesMilne_@stesmithy48@jasonjamesbnn That isn’t certainty!!! That’s 12 people believe it to have happened based on the information presented. That doesn’t mean it DEFINITELY happened. The only people who know what actually happened are Brand and woman 5.
You cannot say 12 people wouldn’t have ruled differently!
It just isn’t though is it……in most rape cases that go to trial testimony is used along side other evidence such as the ones I mentioned. Hence why so few rape cases actually go to court because there is rarely other evidence than testimony.
And I don’t recall saying that, so you’re just putting words in my mouth. I’ve simply said I would prefer certainty in any situation, whether they’re guilty or falsely accused and also acknowledged that isn’t possible the way it currently is. Who knows maybe we will have Minority Reports-esque crime fighting one day. 🤣
We are just gonna keep going around in circles here. 🤣 I’ve said my point that I don’t think someone’s word as evidence should be enough in ANY crime and that for me is the flaw in this case. I know it is in the eyes of the law. But I don’t like that nor will I pretend it’s going to change.
And it’s the unfortunate reason sooooo many non consent cases don’t even make it to trial, pretty sure it’s like 1-5%. Because even the system knows that majority of non consent cases are just both parties word against each other and without other form of evidence such as actual text messages or video/audio recordings or someone else actually witnessing the incident, conviction is highly unlikely, so they can’t pursue it. Again, not saying that’s right, but it’s just how it is.
And I believe if this had been some Joe Bloggs instead of Russell Brand, the system wouldn’t have even bothered pursuing it.
I genuinely wish there was a better (for lack of better wording) system that could definitively determine if there was consent or not, to ensure victims do get the justice they deserve. But unless we are going to start having sexual checklists we hand to each other before hand, I don’t think that will happen.
I don’t know why you’re resulting to name calling. I’m literally just explaining my opinion. You might not like it, but I’ve been pretty respectful this whole time.
I understand everything you just said. However; how many people do you think have ever lied on the stand…..we don’t know, we will never know, because the ones that do it well, get away with it. Hence my reserved judgement on accepting testimony alone enough for conviction. I know it is and will always be the law, just doesn’t sit right with me.
I’ve said it somewhere else in this chain I think……I can’t remember. But I’ll shorten it again here.
No I don’t have the resolution, and no I can’t think of a fairer way to do it than 12 people deciding who they believe more based on testimonies. But my opinion is that convicting people based on testimony doesn’t sit right with me…….for any crime. 🤷🏻♂️
You know this was said after the judgement was already made. And is the standard practice for any lawyer to accept their findings and then submit to the judge why the sentence should be lowered. This literally isn’t an admission of guilt, this is….the jury has decided, what can I say as a lawyer to ensure my client gets the least time possible. Because I don’t think going “we have nothing to say because you’re all wrong” would go down too well with the judge.
Do you know how ludicrous it would be for him to admit that his client was guilty whilst still technically being employed by him, that would literally cause even more problems, because Brand would immediate say the lawyer compromised the sentencing.
It’s looking at the evidence provided and deciding that I still have reasonable doubt…..and if I can have reasonable doubt then I’m sure many other people also could, which means it then becomes luck of the draw of the 12 people on the jury. And if that’s the case that means that another 12 people may have ruled the other way, which really doesn’t seem like a good way to convict people.
You can keep saying it. But its still her word against his. Just because she said it happened and told people it happened. Doesnt mean it happened.
Are you suggesting that men should ensure to tell all their friends and family every time they have consensual sex, just so if she does accuse him of rape after he has a bunch of people that can get on a stand and testify “well hang on, my friend told me that he had consensual sex with her”
Because you can label it as evidence, her being an eyewitness to her own incident, hearsay, testimony, he said she said……but at the end of the day, it is literally her words she has told to people against his word which he hasn’t told people.
So I think we will have to just agree to disagree. But I know for a fact, if you or any other man was accused of a rape they didn’t commit, you would much rather have someone like me on the jury that will demand more than testimony ALONE, than someone that says yeah well she was cross examined and doesn’t seem like she’s lying.
I never said it ceases to be evidence. I’m well aware that it is evidence. But ultimately if you look at what it is, it’s one person saying something happened or didn’t happen.
And I’ve also never said this is a brand new finding I’ve had due to this case, I’ve always known testimonies are allowed as evidence by law.
I simply do not believe people should be convicted on testimonies alone without other evidence to support it….unless they are a direct eyewitness of the incident. Testimonies that are simply saying “yes, that’s what the person the crime happened to told me happened” for me is weak.
Actually I think you’ll find it’s the system that stops women because very few no consent cases even make it to trial due to lack of evidence, that it does unfortunately make it kind of pointless to pursue.
Don’t get me wrong, it’s a difficult situation. Can I think of a better way to resolve non consent/rape cases than 12 people deciding what they think is true and dishonest……no I can’t.
However, I also think convicting on testimonies which ultimately are he said she said, without any hard evidence is also a dangerous precedent to set.
He didn’t agree at any point though, I think you need to do some more research.
He did what any basic lawyer would do after their client is found guilty. Accept the findings of the jury and then do damage limitation to get as little time possible because the verdict isn’t going to change. No admission of guilt, just getting them a shorter sentence.
So the nurse repeated what she said…that’s still doesn’t mean it’s true.
And if you’d like some “reasonable doubt”, I reckon there is a fair few more women then you would think, that if their anal play fun with a celebrity left some bleeding and they then had to explain to their current boyfriend (which she had btw) why their ass was bleeding, they would say they were forced, rather than admitting they were a cheater who had their tongue up a celebs asshole 10 minutes after meeting them and then met them on a separate occasion for sex.
And I never said anything about “years after”….i said they changed their mind a few days after…..so the point still stands. You would have zero evidence that at the time of the act, it was consensual…..and based on this cases precedent, you could go to jail for 10 years simply because she told her friends and family and a doctor that it wasn’t consensual and they said that’s what she said to them at the time.