I loved Peter Drury the most when he dropped this lines:
Pep Guadiola substitutes Gabriel Jesus for David Silver
"Jesus for Silver, a move Judas Iscariot will be proud of "
Gabriel Jesus of Manchester City scores from a cross
"And Jesus heads home from the cross"
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 Did they contradict each other? No. One gave a landmark (red car), one gave a direction (from the East). Both are true at the same time.
If they contradict, why did you quote the "Aisha's house" one as proof? If Bukhari contradicts himself, your proof is worthless
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 Because that's how every historical event works. It's not a contradiction, it's complementation.
Think about it:
If 2 people watch a car crash, one will say:
"The red car hit the wall"
Another will say:
"The car coming from the East hit the wall"
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 Same hadith, same khutbah:
1-Bukhari 3104:
He pointed towards Aisha's house
2-Bukhari 7092:
He pointed towards the East
3-Muslim 2905:
Fitna is from the East, from Najd
4-From Iraq
So we don't have to guess his body position like a crime scene. Sahaba who were there said: East.
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 That's not a mystery. Every narration says:
قام النبي ﷺ خطيباً
The Prophet stood up to deliver a sermon
He wasn't standing in the desert guessing directions. He was on the minbar.
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 Other narrations:
من نجد
"From Najd"which is East of Madinah…
Lemme make you look stupid!
We all know where the prophet stood!
He was delivering a khutbah.
Where does the Prophet give khutbah? On the minbar in Masjid al-Nabawi.
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 She made a fatwa from her ijtihad and she was wrong in applying it generallybut she didn't invent it.
She had the template from the Prophet (SAW) himself, only that template was a special case, not a general rule.
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 Allah elevated her since she was a kid, The only woman Allah made Barā-ah for himself by revelation!
I don’t really think you know what Aisha is to the prophet…
Just do Shi’ism and get out, if I start with you, you’ll block me!
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 From the East / Iraq came:
-The Khawarij
-The killing of Uthman (RA) and Ali (RA)
-Karbala
- The fitna of the false prophets
To crown it all of you think she was an affliction the prophet won’t have divorced her.
Better try not to regret your actions like your forefathers did
@Haiderqvmf@EbnHussein1424 Let’s me debunk you so you don’t fell special:
Same hadith, other chains, Bukhari makes it explicit:
"Affliction is here, from the East, from where the horn of Satan emerges."
Bukhari 7092. And the east was Najd/Iraq
Why? Because from Medina, East = Najd / Iraq.
@hamiehhy@fatimanourredin This whole write-up and narrative reeks of Shi'ism, from the narrators down to the matn of the sayings. They were all Rafidha.
May Allah guide you to the light before it's too late.
@o1Mesruk@ogrensonrakonus Why can't you just delete it?
Knowledge has categories: some are meant for those who will ask for it because they are not privileged to see beyond, while the other category is for those who seek knowledge through books, who have the cognition and reason to understand the meaning