🚨NEW VIDEO🚨
At the end of a long night on the planet Darillium, time-travelling archaeologist River Song sits down with her husband and reads him a story… their story… from HER point of view.
The Diary of River Song
https://t.co/t6bmEik9B1
#DoctorWho
@beeeeeeaan A lot of the people who seem to have disliked it are major Green Lantern comic fans. I know nothing about Green lantern lore and I loved the show, which seems to be where the divide is for the most part.
@beeeeeeaan Agreed. I don’t mind TTC, but I’ll never understand why the show would ever need to ‘decanonize’ it. When the whole half-human thing from the TV Movie annoyed fans, they just never mentioned it again. Bringing it up again just to rewrite it in a new era would be so tacky.
‘About 15’ is the easiest way to say it, & then you can explain the specifics if someone questions ‘about’.
This is the annoying part of Tennant being in there twice. They should have given him a non-numbered official title so we don’t have to always put 14 in the main line-up.
@_cosmicangst I just say, ‘There’s about 15.’ And if they question ‘about’ then I can explain in detail that there’s also War and Fugitive, but otherwise wouldn’t bother 😅
I enjoy Flux too but there’s some weird writing moments that make no sense at all. Another confusing one is how Tecteun says ‘Don’t come looking for this.’ And when the Doctor arrives she’s like, ‘I told you not come looking.’ But, she didn’t?? You literally brought her here?
@miadoctorwho Yeah I was initially annoyed by this too. Although, having listened to that box set, it’s a one-off unsustainable event done against her will, & then she’s returned to the library. The follow-up box sets are just set at various points in her life, not post-library.
@josh_snares So Josh, what are your thoughts on the 13th Doctor, ‘I’m a bit socially awkward’ scene in Can You Hear Me? I’ve never heard anyone discuss it before.
@TharriesYT I think she’s definitely pre-Hartnell and that’s the intention, however it’s pretty clear that Chris has deliberately left some wiggle room for people to interpret it differently if they like.
@jae_writes_ Chris has never stated definitively that she’s pre-Hartnell. In The Timeless Children, 13 literally asks Fugitive how she fits & Fugitive’s answer is, ‘I don’t have all these answers, & if I did, would they even help?’. Chris did not go back on anything. It’s vague on purpose.
Seems like the ‘Boss’ line in TRW was part of reshoots, so I’m curious why it was included when the future was so unsure. Without it, the Boss was mentioned only twice, & it’s debatable if the Rogue one even counts as a reference. Now it’s a major loose end they could’ve avoided.
@Dani_WSDK I think the only way to do it with a fresh start is to go down the RTD1 route of having a s1 that’s free from continuity & then introduce her in s2 in a similar fashion to Sarah Jane in s2. Introduce her in a way that serves the story being told & doesn’t require past knowledge.
@josh_snares Exactly, RTD1 had the right idea at the beginning. ‘Dalek’, not ‘Daleks’.
And what about just 1 character, not characters. Less actors to pay. It was ‘Rose’ not ‘Roses’ after all.
I’d go as far as to say this is the best final line. Even the great ones, ‘I’ll always remember when the Dr was me’ or ‘Moment has been prepared’ are good, but it feels like any Doctor could say them.
‘Tag you’re it’ feels like only Jodie’s Doctor could say it. Just perfect!
'The Power of the Doctor' is the 2nd best regeneration story of the revival ('Parting of the Ways' is, of course, the best).
But "Doctor Whoever-I'm-About-To-Be....Tag, you're it!" is such an all-timer final line. Brilliant closing moment, ironically changed during the edit.
@nah_nahsel@Tales_TimeLord He had no idea the Time Lords were behind it at that time. And if you’re suggesting his ‘Who else?’ line was referring to the Silence (in which their connection to the cracks was not understood yet) then he would’ve seen the Silence behind the door, not a crack in the wall.
@nah_nahsel@Tales_TimeLord When the Doctor opened the door in The God Complex, he said, ‘Who else?’ Makes absolutely no sense for it to be the crack in the wall.
@TNTree2 Yeah that crossed my mind too. I think there’s also a way to throw in a reference to how sometimes the clothes can change too (like with 13 to 14). Maybe regen energy causes ripples in time/space that can create all sorts of anomalies. There’s always fun ways to retcon it!
Ignore it. Start afresh with a new ‘16th’ Doctor. Then later on, throw in a line like -
‘The regeneration process is a bit messy. Sometimes I get sick or lose my memory. Once I turned into an old friend of mine for a few minutes before settling on my final form.’
Done.