@wandydoodles that defeated the knight is "impossible". it's a fight made to be lost, of course, but you can beat without the mantle cmon now. they may have an "average player" expectations, and those who beat the knight are out of the common stadistic, thus the "surprise".)
@wandydoodles it could be that the knight handed the shadow crystal before doing the fountain or even before. Just as the knight has proved to be able to damage items directly inside the dw, the reverse could be true)
(Also the gaster contradiction—i dont think that gaster *truly* believes
@shellyous tbf the most lazy version of the theory that was crafted with such a few bits of evidence died. and thats good, it only made the theory look bad. people that still believe the theory are just more quiet
@2006_wii_remote im sorry to tell but this whole new dialogue was so kriselle knight that its insane
kriselle knight and the fuckton of evil cats that noelle created in cat petterz... after all Friend literally comes from there.
@kaprettino Consider too: amalgaknight could be a foil of the player. An "Angel" and a "Cage" having a dark world they use as their base (the shelter), seeing this world as fiction and knowing Gaster
@jmoriboy So the knight is someone who can perfectly match Kris' timing, no matter what?
I do wonder if there's someone who can match their timing no matter if it's fast or slow, which was showed this exact chapter, and has antlers...
@Chidubemm0@Stafki_GTN The theme and such is mostly the most important part of the theory?? If it was jusg "lol the knight is similar to kris" then ofc it would be a very shitty theory. amalgaknight is more like "noelle knight and kris is there to fill plotholes I guess"
@viderchia That's how theorizing works?? You take something and try to explain how it makes sense, which in turn leads to more new hints and narrative paralells
@_gurusandhu_ That implies Dess was suicidal, just like Noelle. Why would Dess be suicidal? She's had a decent family except of her mother, love, considering how she and Asriel won Queen and King surely appreciated in town too. Noelle had been dissociating because Dess vanished— so why Dess?
@Ragenade_ idealization and nostalgia.
They have heard about Gerson by their siblings, surely heard all their life how Gerson was this amazing teacher, this great writer.
After all, this Gerson first thing he does is convey his feelings to his son—did real Gerson did that?