@arealmofwonder Thank you for your lovely and inspiring feed. It has meant a lot. You will be missed and will be in my thoughts. Sending love from Canada.π¨π¦
A Jewish Holocaust Scholar Called Gaza a Genocide. He Lost His University Job Offer. Now the University Has Paid Him $250,000.
Raz Segal is an Israeli-American Jewish historian.
He is also the grandson of four Holocaust survivors.
He has devoted his academic career to studying the Holocaust, antisemitism, mass violence and genocide.
He teaches Holocaust and genocide studies at Stockton University in New Jersey.
He has written extensively about the persecution and mass murder of Jews in Europe, including a book examining the destruction of Jewish communities in the Carpathian region during the Second World War.
In other words, genocide is not a subject he discovered when Israel began bombing Gaza.
It is his life's work.
On October 13, 2023, just six days after the Hamas attacks on Israel, Segal published an article in Jewish Currents.
Its title was direct.
A Textbook Case of Genocide.
He argued that Israel's assault on Gaza was already displaying the characteristics of genocide.
His argument rested on the 1948 Genocide Convention, the siege imposed on Gaza, attacks on civilians and statements by senior Israeli officials.
He pointed particularly to Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant's announcement of a complete siege, cutting off food, electricity and fuel, and his description of the enemy as "human animals."
Segal argued that such declarations were evidence of genocidal intent.
This was October 2023.
He was making that argument before much of the subsequent destruction, displacement and mass death in Gaza.
His conclusion was controversial, even among fellow Holocaust scholars.
But it was a professional assessment grounded in the field to which he had dedicated his life.
Eight months later, Segal was offered one of the most prestigious positions of his career.
The University of Minnesota selected him to become director of its Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies.
The appointment also included a tenured position in the university's history department.
The selection followed a rigorous academic search and a near-unanimous recommendation by the hiring committee.
Then the objections began.
Two members of the center's advisory board resigned in protest.
Jewish community organizations mobilized against his appointment.
The Jewish Community Relations Council of Minnesota and the Dakotas argued that his position on Israel made him unsuitable to lead a Holocaust studies center.
The university reversed course.
On June 10, 2024, just five days after selecting him, it withdrew the offer.
The man it had chosen to lead its Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies had become unacceptable after publicly identifying what he considered another genocide.
Segal did not quietly accept the decision.
Represented by the Center for Constitutional Rights, he challenged the university's actions and sought access to internal records.
The controversy raised a question far larger than his individual career.
What happens to academic freedom when a scholar's professional conclusions offend politically influential donors and organizations?
And what is the purpose of genocide studies if scholars risk losing their jobs for applying their knowledge to events unfolding in the present?
The university's critics of Segal maintained that his characterization of Israel's actions was premature, politically extreme and incompatible with the leadership of a Holocaust studies center.
Segal and his supporters argued that a university committed to academic freedom had punished a qualified scholar for expressing a legitimate professional judgment.
Then, in August 2026, came an extraordinary development.
The University of Minnesota agreed to pay Raz Segal $250,000 in a settlement over the withdrawn appointment.
Internal university records obtained by the Center for Constitutional Rights revealed pressure from donors and outside organizations opposed to Segal's criticism of Israel.
The payment did not give him the job back.
Nor did it amount to a court ruling that the university had violated his constitutional rights.
But it represented a significant outcome for a scholar who had challenged the consequences of speaking out.
There is something particularly revealing about this case.
Segal is Jewish.
He is Israeli.
All four of his grandparents survived the Holocaust.
He has spent his professional life researching the destruction of European Jewish communities.
He was qualified enough to be selected to lead a university center devoted to studying genocide.
Yet his assessment of Israel's conduct toward Palestinians helped cost him that very position.
He was not dismissed for denying the Holocaust.
He was not accused of falsifying historical evidence.
His appointment was withdrawn after he applied his understanding of genocide to the actions of the Israeli state.
And when the university finally paid him $250,000 in 2026, it did not reverse the appointment.
It paid to settle the dispute.
Raz Segal's case exposes a troubling contradiction.
Universities encourage scholars to study the historical warning signs of genocide.
But what happens when those scholars recognize such warning signs in an ally of their own government?
For Raz Segal, the answer was the loss of a prestigious job offer.
And, two years later, a $250,000 settlement.
CANCEL CULTURE
I was scheduled to teach my signature course, The Laws of War, at Brooklyn College in the upcoming Spring semester. The class was the first in the Political Science department to be closed out (fully enrolled). Last week I was informed that Dean Philip Napoli abruptly cancelled the course. If you wish to register your opinion of his action, you can reach him and Brooklyn Collegeβs president here:
Dean Philip Napoli
[email protected]
718.951.3136
President Michele Anderson
[email protected]
718.951.5671
@Pontifex Prayers and patience are great but . . . Those who are evilβthose who seek to destroy a peopleβ must be held accountable. There must be a commitment to humanity and justice and there must be consequential action. It is not happening.
@Jagnostic623@HaithamElmasri1 My, what an ignorant and inhumane post. You paint all Palestinians with the same stereotypical brush. This is an utterly shameful post. God help you if you ever find yourself submitted to anything like the three years of brutality they have endured.
@dawnhaiileyyz I have no idea why you should be following me. I have absolutely no interest in people who post provocative or suggestive images of themselves. We have nothing in common. Look elsewhere.
Hussam Abu Safieh is one of the Palestinian doctors (among 95 other doctors) that will be killed by the βIsraeli death penalty for hostages.β
Do not let them murder him. Repost this.
@MidwesternDoc I never hear how it is used, delivered. An acquaintance tried a topical formulation of it for severe autoimmune joint pain and had no response. It removed varnish from a table top. Was told to never use it internally. How is it used?