All Things Engineering. Electrical, Mechanical, Software, Firmware, AI, Security and everything in between. Specialize in custom HW/FW/SW for motor control
Never seen a more despicable company with a more obnoxiously good product.
Can't bring myself to invest over their op against Jensen, as well as the governance giving Dario an unimpeachable CEO share.
He could literally just decide he wanted to liquidate Antrhopic on Friday and there is nothing the board or shareholders could do about it.
Delaware, we have a problem.
All ten NVIDIA directors who decided Jensen Huang’s fate are defendants in a lawsuit over how they handled him, and keeping him out helps them defend it, whether or not it is best for the company and its shareholders for him to be exiled. That is what we call a conflict of interest. Directors with a personal stake in the answer should not be the ones deciding it. The answer these directors have already given, full exile for Jensen, therefore deserves no deference.
The board must immediately call a special shareholder meeting, create new seats, and let shareholders nominate and elect independent directors to fill them, as NVIDIA’s charter and bylaws allow. Acting as a special committee with counsel of their own choosing, the new directors should receive the findings of the board’s investigation and decide afresh whether Jensen should return, in what role, and under what safeguards.
On November 11, a lawsuit named all of the outside directors as defendants, faulting the board, among other things, for keeping Jensen in charge while it investigated him. By the end of that day, Jensen was out.
As Reuters noted, Jensen’s removal stands to help the directors’ defense “by showing directors took action.” It answers the complaint’s charge that the board overly “deferred to Mr. Huang”: it creates evidence that they can say no to Jensen. Allowing Jensen to return, even in a safeguarded or circumscribed way, would undercut both personal benefits, even though it may be what is best for the company and its shareholders.
Any director deciding whether Jensen should return must ask what a return would mean for the company and its shareholders. These directors, however, must also ask what it would mean for them personally as defendants. Shareholders deserve a decision made by directors who have only the first question to answer. There is no shame in feeling the force of both questions; the directors are only human. The shame would lie in thinking they are above the law and refusing to step aside when they have such an obvious conflict.
Neither indemnification nor insurance removes the conflict. A declaration that the directors breached their duties to NVIDIA is among the relief the complaint seeks. An insurer can pay a judgment; it cannot erase that finding. As then–Vice Chancellor Strine put it: “No judgment in a fraud or other reputation-implicating case is cost-free.”
Delaware courts have accordingly refused to defer to directors whose decisions stand to shield them from adverse judgment for their own earlier conduct, and the case for recusal here is at least as strong. In Fitbit, the Court of Chancery explained that a director could not impartially consider whether the company should pursue claims against others when the company’s positions “would likely compromise his defenses” in a pending suit against him. The same is true here: reinstating Jensen is a position the company would take, and it would detract from these directors’ defenses.
In AmTrust, three directors facing a pending shareholder suit approved a buyout that would effectively end the claims against them. They had bargained for seven weeks and won the approval of two-thirds of the public shareholders. Yet the court still concluded that shareholders a material personal interest in the decision, that precludes deference. Here, far from taking their time and consulting shareholders, NVIDIA’s directors acted the same day they were sued and despite overwhelming evidence of shareholder disapproval.
Finally, in Revlon, the Delaware Supreme Court faulted a board for a decision that it said had, as a side effect, “to protect the directors against a perceived threat of personal liability” for their earlier choices. Revlon’s directors faced only a threat of suit. NVIDIA’s have already been sued. Thus, concerns of partiality are all the more salient here.
The directors may be right about Jensen. They may be wrong. What they cannot be is impartial. A decision this important deserves a process no one has reason to doubt. The board has failed to provide that. Jensen is not above the law. But neither is the board. The fix is simple: a special meeting, new independent directors chosen by the shareholders, and a fresh decision on Jensen from people who can make that decision without having to weigh both how it will affect the company and them personally.
@thepowerfulHRV The worst part is that if the board had announced a $100B partnership with SpaceXAI, shareholders would have been ecstatic compared with using for buybacks
@jimprosser You are missing the scenario where high-talent employees start leaving/retiring en-mass (which they will).
Also, as long as there is even a small possibility, qualified candidates will stay out of the running.
Shareholders don't have to vote, they can also sell (which they are)
@robbuildsstuff This is why Tesla is adding massive storage, solar and turbines to their project in Cochise county.
They also just announced solid state transformers, so they are literally the full stack
@TruthCaviar@MarkHalperin@JensenHuang Anyone who is talking about this and doesn't even know what CUDA is should just be ignored. This is just embarrassing for these guys
@TucsonTomorrow I certainly wouldn't be giving anything to Tucson with the current city council.
They literally turned down $1B in tax revenue from project blue for virtue signaling, knowing full well it will be built anyway.
In 10 years we will look back at the p(doom) and safety cartel and laugh at them just as much as we now laugh at the economists that predicted earth's over population.
@grok, remind me in 10 years to review
Completely unenforceable on top of bad policy.
1. Download Chinese AI model
2. Change one weight value
3. Cool, not a Chinese model anymore
The China hawks are going to push us into a dystopian censorship state if they get their way, do not fall for it. OPEN MODELS = GOOD
SITUATION DETECTED: The White House and Treasury are discussing a proposal that would require US companies to publicly disclose the use of Chinese open-weight AI models on their websites, aiming to discourage their use through public pressure, per Reuters.
My theory is that they cave on Friday and reinstate Jensen.
Friday is conveniently right after the Ant IPO, which was the motivation of this entire saga
JUST IN: Nvidia ($NVDA) interim CEO Colette Kress promises company-wide pay raises and additional equity grants months ahead of schedule as the chipmaker scrambles to retain employees following Jensen Huang’s departure, according to WIRED.
@stevenfiorillo You are dramatically underestimating how much people know his value. It is not unreasonable that BlackRock, State Street and Vanguard support bringing him back, especially if Trump or Musk get involved more heavily.
I think the board will be swayed in other ways though.
The demand for NVIDIA chips is absolutely real, and will continue.
People still underestimate how gigantic NVIDIAs tech lead is, they are years ahead of all the others and accelerating. Catching them would be like launching a probe to catch Voyager.
The AMD deal is a bailout, OpenAI is hoping in a few years they won't have to pay NVIDIA margins for inference chips.
GPUs may depreciate, but the rest of the infra being built is much longer lived. (Power, racks, network, buildings, etc) Even if some of the AI labs go under (and some will), their compute clusters are assets, just like a building.
Any way you look at it, the world needs 1000x more compute capacity, and that capacity will be worth an ever increasing amount as AI models continue to improve.
Selling Oculus to Facebook in 2014 gave me money for helicopter flight lessons and developing a seastead called SLAB with a 1,000 year design life.
The goal was to be cheaper than land and absent state/local laws that cripple critical American industries like metal processing, medical research/treatment, desalination, oil refining, chemical engineering, and more. Me and a few close friends cashed it up at a $1B valuation back in 2017, and while it still has a long way to go, there has been significant progress towards my goal of reviving manifest destiny and westward expansion. At a time when most of the seasteading community wanted to escape the US and smoke pot, this was the one project explicitly designed to make America stronger, a relief valve for ill considered or outdated rules and regulations.
I am only talking about it now because a few media outlets got wind of me and some friends topping up the coffers and plan on calling SLAB my new floating AI datacenter project. It is way cooler than that, way older than that, and I hate looking like a hype-chasing consensus loser, so now you have to read this tweet.