@srfgiants Schmitt has 4 years of control where as Webb only has 2. I’m not opposed to trading anyone as long as they get the value they should get and it’s for players that actually make sense. Ideally it would be much better to move Chapman if they could get him to waive his NTC.
At some point the front office should be having honest conversations with Webb about how they view their timeline and whether he wants to go elsewhere to contend. He’s a competitor and one would think he wants to play in October sooner than later.
One thing that gets lost in the “Giants should trade Casey Schmitt for a pitcher!” discussion is: Casey was one of the 2 best hitters on the roster (along with Eldridge) vs LHP. For a team that has been truly atrocious vs lefties, not sure moving him makes much sense.
Would it shock me if MIL fixes Walker and makes the optics look bad next season? No. But logically the Giants have exhausted all the time they should at this point in trying to fix him and it clearly isn’t happening here. He’s also arbitration eligible. This was a no brainer.
Trade news: The Milwaukee Brewers acquired right-handed reliever Ryan Walker from San Francisco for a pair of minor leaguers: right-handed reliever Blake Holub and right-handed started Gavin Perry.
Remembered for not playing during covid? You mean after he and his wife had just adopted twins that were born prematurely and he was unwilling to put them at risk?
Kindly go pound sand pal.
Buster Posey is definitely NOT a first-ballot Hall of Famer.
Posey will be more remembered for being one of the worst GMs in baseball, refusing to play during COVID, not supporting teammates in on-field brawls, and getting demolished trying to block home plate.
Thurman Munson finished with a higher WAR than Posey in essentially the same number of games, was a 7-time All-Star like Posey, won Rookie of the Year, multiple rings, and an MVP like Posey, and Munson never even made the Hall of Fame.
Joe Mauer was a deserving first-ballot guy; Posey isn't close to the same caliber of player.
Buster Posey is the perfect example of a flash in the pan. He should still be playing today. At worst, should've retired after this season.
For me:
Andy Pettitte
Felix Hernandez
Mark Buehrle
Chase Utley
Bobby Abreu
Bert was asked a couple of questions about the Giants, including this one. The last part is encouraging in case anyone wants to grab onto something positive.
Marjama is a guy that received massive praise this last year. Former Red Sox hitting coach (during their 2018 WS) Andy Barkett said this after seeing Mike work with his son and others in SJ last season. Would love to see him get an opportunity.
Mike Marjama (San Jose) and Tommy Everidge (Richmond) feel like logical candidates as well. Baggs mentioned Mike McCormack might be considered before the Rowson hire.
This is just speculation, but Rudy Hernández served as an assistant hitting coach when James Rowson was the hitting coach for the Twins. Hernández also worked with Jayce Tingler on that coaching staff. Might be a candidate for the Giants' hitting coach vacancy.
@ConnGiantsFan Personally I think hitting coaches get way too much credit for the success/failures of the players. No clue if he’ll be successful in SF, but we’ve watched 3 straight coaches with different philosophies “fail” the last 3 years.
Sources: The San Francisco Giants are in talks to hire James Rowson to the major-league coaching staff. Rowson has been the New York Yankees’ hitting coach since Nov. 2023. https://t.co/f8zCDuOEey
There are only a few teams with hitting coach vacancies. The Giants happen to be one of those teams, and the only one with a head hitting coach position available besides the Yankees (Rowson's former team) and Angels (no manager).
Posey has talked about the Giants needing to improve their stuff with pitchers in the system…Marquez and Cayama are a couple young arms to keep an eye on going forward.