Whatever the outcome of the ICJ judgment, we, the Rohingya people, express our deepest gratitude to the Republic of The Gambia (@Gambia_MOJ) for taking our pursuit of justice to the world’s highest court.
Your courage and commitment will never be forgotten.1/2
Just to confirm, yes, I have heard it correctly!!
This is a very good first step in terms of the interpretation and application of the phrase 'intent to destroy', but there is still a long way to go before we get full conceptual clarity and accuracy on this matter (though I have seen good things in the opinions in this regard).
On relevant problems, much of which remain, see, e.g.,
https://t.co/LCbEPFBs0S
(publication forthcoming in AUILR (2027)).
In short, here I explained in detail why destruction of the group as a social unit is particularly relevant in relation to the groups protected by the Genocide Convention,
- that the travaux does not support the requirement of intent to destroy the group physically or biologically (this is something the ICJ fortunately did not claim now)
- that the ILC's statement on cultural destruction & genocide has been misread as pertaining to the dolus specialis while it in fact concerns the actus reus (again, not invoked this time, and see Judge Cleveland),
- that the Krstic (ICTY) Trial Chamber attributed undue weight to (its interpretation of the ILC's interpretation of) the Convention's travaux (Krstic is not invoked in today's judgment for this position, but is still bound to underly the instance at the opening of the discussion on 'physical-biologial'),
- that the ICJ in Bosnia v. Serbia did not address the nature of destruction required in the context of the dolus specialis but in any event, if interpreted as having done so, its position is insufficiently substantiated and suffers from additional flaws (Bosnia now not cited for this position!), and
- that the ICJ position in Croatia v. Serbia lacks fitting substantiation and suffers from the same additional flaw (this criticism remains valid, and I still have not seen a good explanation for the opening requirement of 'physical-biological').
For shorter, more readily digestable pieces with a slightly different focus, see also
https://t.co/4IPeoKNa9m
https://t.co/uinaK4vHSG
https://t.co/JPlT8S4zWQ
and
https://t.co/JlpFJxhTzY
Have I heard it correctly? Did the ICJ just acknowledge that intent to destroy the group does not need to mean destruction in a strictly physical-biological sense? Did they just emphasize destruction of the group as such? Did they just follow at the very least Blagojevic and Jokic? And that, deviating from Croatia v Bosnia (ICJ) and Krstic (ICTY), the finally stopped mistakenly invoking the travaux to read ‘physical’ into the chapeau? I cannot wait to read it to confirm!
7 years ago,after the #ICJ hearing,I broke down holding my Rohingya sisters.For the first time, our name #ROHINGYA was spoken in the world’s court after decades of erasure in Myanmar.
Today,the verdict arrives.Thinking of 1M refugees, &my families in Arakan.
Justice will prevail.
Last year President Trump "disappeared" a group of immigrants to South Sudan, prompting a Supreme Court case. The deportees then vanished for more than a year. I found them, locked up, held incommunicado, and famished--and I hope the Justices take note. https://t.co/VabKeRfiCW
Israel just bulldozed one of the most prosperous Palestinian farms near the Jordan Valley area
This farm feeds 10,000s of people, and is a prominent source of food in the area
Did you know that new literature laureate Anne Carson said she owes her “whole career and happiness” to her high school Latin teacher? Her Nobel Prize-awarded work is often inspired by Greek literature, while her translations often give a contemporary twist to ancient works.
I was a young reporter during the first Intifada and I've covered Israel/Palestine for thirty years as a journalist. I know the history. I have spent many months on the West Bank and reported for all that time on the humiliation and horrors of the occupation. I know how the IDF and the Settlers operate, the massive injustices, apartheid and ethnic cleansing they oversee. I've written an award-winning book on the Palestinian Christians and made BAFTA-winning documentaries. I haven't lost anything. I'm bearing witness to injustices and horrors I've seen and can never unsee. Frankly I would be failing in my duty as a writer if I did otherwise.
1/2 As noted by Christine Van den Wyngaert in the opinion piece below, “[o]nce appointed, an ad hoc judge has the same duty of independence and impartiality as every other member of the court."
This is why I have high expectations of Judge ad hoc Claus Kreß (appointed by Myanmar) in relation to social genocide.
See excerpts from his chapter in Münchener Kommentar zum StGB, Vol. 9, VStGB Section 6, ¶ 72 (4th ed. 2022) pp. 1342-1343 below.
https://t.co/qRzjDQRJXy
The son of Dr Hussam Abu Safiya, who is being held hostage by Israel, explains how his father is being starved, abused, tortured & denied medical treatment.
A reminder that Israel is NOT being asked to provide aid to Gaza
It’s been asked to STOP BLOCKING aid provided by OTHER countries that is ALREADY THERE waiting at the border