@_Baka420 Personally, I think people value Thorfinn's change more because of the seriousness with which his past is treated and how it affects the present (traumas, psychological and physical damage, etc.).
@_Baka420 I think Thorfinn's actions should have had more external than internal consequences, especially towards the end of the manga, because thanks to his anti-weapons ideology, many civilians died, including Einar. And he never faced those consequences because the manga ends.
@_Baka420 Can you explain the Thorfinn thing? I never thought it was a fair comparison. Rudeus and Thorfinn don't have the same goal; they're such different characters that's why I say it's a false equivalence.
@_Baka420@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 You started with the age thing, you called me a larp and you said it wrong, I'm not going to explain the joke and why it's wrong but don't get the idea that "it comes out of nowhere" when the author has already written similar or worse things
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 Lets leave it here neither of us is going to change the others mind. I dont hate mushoku tensei ,magonote has undeniable talent for world building, magic systems, and dramatic tension. I just hate how he constantly sabotages his own great work with this stuff.
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 Did you read the farm arc? Just reading that you say it's "off-screen" gives me the impression that you didn't. Thorfinn suffered physical, social, psychological, and relational consequences, but it simply seems you didn't read the material. It's pointless for me
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 If something is your "starting point," you're supposed to leave it behind as the story progresses. "And their gradual change throughout the story is part of their character development." You have to keep in mind that the screenshots are from the later volumes of the novel
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 "off screen" you say...This seems more like rage bait than analysis. Do you think I'm twisted enough to make up a joke about his daughter when the author previously wrote that he masturbated to his niece's material? Who set the standards in the first place?
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 Straw hat fallacy, saying you explained something when you only did mental gymnastics, you're the god of rage bait and you're trying to make me look like I'm the retarded one. Keep trying
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 You keep trying to hide behind "that's just how Rudeus is," which erases the author's responsibility for choosing to use those kinds of situations as comedic punchlines. I hate that the Mushoku fandom is so desensitized that they defend those tropes as "high literary coherence."
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 apart from the fact that I see you dont know grammar, you dont know how to read either.Stop making the false equivalence between Thorfinn and Rudeus.Yukimura will never use a murder joke for comedic effect and that affects how the protagonis changes and how the change takes place
@MoviesWorl94967@Kasane_Teto_509@BAn_N101 "That doesnt mean eris originally intended anything sexual toward lucie"You don't explain anything grammatically, you don't argue anything, yet you still think you're right. I'm telling you, understand the fucking grammar if you think it was all my "projection."