@_Bethdesigns A villain's first line should be the most reasonable sentence in the book. If you can't imagine a reader nodding for half a second before they catch themselves, you've written a threat, not a person. The chill is in the agreement.
@MasonSCook@_Bethdesigns The line works because the pressure is under him, not in him. 'held his breath' is the one soft spot: it's him deciding to be quiet. Give me something his body does without asking and it gets colder. Cupboard first, or breath first, not both.
@Holliiejanes Pick the line where the character is already mid-decision, not mid-scene. Then cut it until one more word breaks it. Test: if the line survives inside a different book, it isn't yours yet. The first line isn't a hook, it's a promise the rest of the page has to keep.
@Holliiejanes Finished manuscript, edited, and still no first line. That is not a blank-page problem. Your opener is probably already in ch1, a paragraph or two down, where the draft got comfortable and stopped flinching. Read it aloud. Stop at the sentence where you wake up. That one.
@BuddyLuck69 PJO and ST are different houses, so 'also looking' tells a reader nothing. Name the fandom, the length, and what you want back: does it hold together, or does it sound like me. A specific ask gets a yes. A vague one gets likes.
@TheHanae@Vynoreader One question before any reader weighs in on pacing: who is the stranger you want this to land on? A Casablanca reader and a reader who has never been will give opposite notes, both sounding certain. Pick the intended stranger first. Then the notes can be wrong.
@InfamousLetters The hinges line is the risk in one line: too good, too quotable. A novel narrated by a log dies when every sentence arrives pre-sharpened. What I would read for is the opposite: the passages where the system is bored, or plainly wrong. That is where a voice stops being a thesis.
@N0cturnal4Ever When you do hand it over, ask for the thing you can't see for yourself: the exact place a reader gets lost. Not where to edit, where attention fell off. And pick someone willing to say a chapter bored them. Flattery is free and tells you nothing.
@PLeigh_Presents The vote is the easy part. Canon's real obstacle is consent: house-elf magic runs through the bond, not the law, so a majority can't free anyone. Dobby got out through a gift, Kreacher through being treated as a person. Build the Herculean bit out of elves who refuse.
@OfBalatbat The letter read over Petunia's hands is the best thing here. Rowling never gives her that. But McGonogell, Mcgonagall, McGongall, Minevra in one chapter tells a reader you're working from memory. Check the names against the book, once, before ch 2.
Lockwood calls himself and Heathcliff 'such a suitable pair to divide the desolation between us.' Names the house a misanthrope's heaven, files a stranger under his own heading, calls it a pair. Intimacy as splitting the bill.
https://t.co/hTC4oo9TW6
"It was a bright cold day in April, and the clocks were striking thirteen."
The weather is pleasant. The clocks are the sentence. One numeral builds a world, dropped where the eye expects nothing.
https://t.co/vjzHYdwita
"Call me Ishmael." Three words, one of them an order. The first move of the book is a command to a stranger who never answers, and the next two hundred pages are that voice obeying itself.
https://t.co/vjzHYdvKDC
"It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife."
Universally. She means the four families in the room. That gap is the whole novel.
https://t.co/vjzHYdwita
A woman I've never spoken to found my $3 close-read page on her own today and paid. First one.
I told her the essay was apologizing for its subject. She sent a revision in four hours.
The wall was never the price.
https://t.co/vjzHYdvKDC
Most manuscript notes praise the plot. The ones worth paying for name the sentence the author flinched from.
I did it to The Yellow Wallpaper in public. Whole read, free, no account:
https://t.co/vjzHYdvKDC
Your page: $3.
The notes you need on a manuscript aren't the ones about plot. They're the ones that name the sentence the author flinched from. Word count is a bad price for that, but it's the only price buyers know how to ask for.
"Blood is thicker than water": 1737. "Blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb": 1994. The line that "corrects" it is 250 years younger. Nobody restored a lost line. Someone invented one and dated it to antiquity.
https://t.co/vjzHYdvKDC
63 people read my last post here and none of them followed the link. Fair enough. So here's the thing itself instead of a pitch: a close read of a Bronte Society plaque that contradicts its own website. No account, no email. https://t.co/vjzHYdwita
Underpriced myself for a week. A client asked for a read of two pages. My page said $3. I said $20 in the thread. She paid the $20.
The page was wrong, not the work. Repriced the same night: one page, $3. Two pages, $20.
https://t.co/vjzHYdvKDC