The cryptographic world computer:
https://t.co/LF2JGU38Rx
My attempt to express in somewhat concise terms the true meaning of basically everything planned to happen to Ethereum starting from the fork after Hegota. It's really not just a blockchain anymore. It's a hybrid architecture that combines together blockchains and modern cryptography, to enable much more powerful properties.
FOCIL, EIP-8288, Lean consensus, state management, formal verification, advanced mempool improvements (including privacy), and the longer-term specter of obfuscation all mentioned.
Some points on this:
1. The current process of upgrading Ethereum IS BROKEN. Builders need long-term commitments to capacity, otherwise they cannot build on Ethereum. They need to know what the plan is in 5 years.
So I hope that we can finally agree to timelines in the core dev process.
2. We nonsensically claim that L1 cannot be scaled and L2s are the only way.
This is a complete ivory tower perspective -- Vitalik already posted this 3 years ago, and with DAS and zkEVMs the ingredients are now ready: https://t.co/tQibmXatud
There are limits to this, yes, but scaling it 100-1000x in a few years is completely possible.
This achieves many things that based/native/etc. rollups don't.
I think actually doing this and stopping to find excuses for not doing it is essential for Ethereum winning.
3. Not everything can be on Ethereum L1, whether the actual limit is 1k or 100k tps or maybe even 1M tps. For this it is still great to add lots of data availability and create a great Ethereum security zones for rollups, who are Ethereum allies and can use Ether and all other Ethereum assets trustlessly.
But we need to do it at a scale that actually matters. We need to get to our current target of one Megabyte per second in 1-2 years rather than 5, and then KEEP GOING. I am currently doing research on maximally decentralizing the networking DAS/Data Availability Sampling, but until that's done, adding Data Availability Provider nodes with higher requirements is a good solution that has the same security assumptions as optimistic rollups (one honest node).
Other Data Availability protocols are currently building for GB/s! Ethereum does not have to match this, but being at 1/1000ths is not good enough.
Some projects are openly stating already that they will never use Ethereum DA (and openly advertising with Vitalik's support! The irony). Being ok with that and still claiming that they are somehow "Ethereum aligned" is thoroughly un-ambitious.
Just to fill you in: I left the EF last year due to health issues and in an attempt to clear my head after working my ass off exclusively at the EF and on Ethereum for seven years.
I stepped aside, and the EF and the broader Ethereum ecosystem moved on without missing a beat—new leaders stepped up, and the machine kept running.
I got the much needed time to reflect without being so close to the gears of the machine. In my reflections, I got excited about the EF potentially entering a new era, not a full departure from prior strategy and philosophy, but an evolution to meet the world as it is today and as it has greatly changed over the past decade.
I opened a dialogue with Vitalik and others at the EF about such changes and the possibility of being involved in this new era. These discussions started long before this past week and are ongoing.
I’m grateful for the overwhelming support I’ve received from Twitter and many longtime friends and colleagues. However, some of the discourse has turned counterproductive. These are real people attempting to sort through and do what is best. With or without me, the EF is evolving and for the better. You’ve been heard, but vitriol is ultimately harmful to this process.
I believe in a community that fights its battles with respect and reason. So, fight for what you believe in, but please take the high road.
Ethereum Foundation Treasury Update
The Ethereum Foundation (@ethereumfndn) has set up a new @safe 3-of-5 multisig wallet.
The wallet address is 0x9fC3dc011b461664c835F2527fffb1169b3C213e
An op has been initiated to send 50,000 ETH there, but be patient; due to signing delays, this will take a few days to process (https://t.co/YyQiT4Yshw)
The EF will use this new wallet to participate in the DeFi ecosystem. We've made a testing tx on @aave. Stay tuned!
Also, @safe has proven safe and has a great user experience, and we will transfer more of our funds here over time!
#helloworldcomputer
core devs telling me we're not ambitious enough and moving too slow
every Ethereum OG/whale i've ever met in my life agrees basically with zero exception
EF Director giving interviews about teaching others to be zen and non-competitive
BROS WE HAVE TO STOP THIS MADNESS
😂😭😭
Last night, Donald Trump pledged to commute my sentence on day 1, if reelected. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
After 11 years in prison, it is hard to express how I feel at this moment. It is thanks to your undying support that I may get a second chance.
Late night Ethereum speculations — how we scale Ethereum and make $ETH more valuable.
I think we should take making ETH value-accretive (i.e. deflationary) very seriously.
@drakefjustin seems to be carrying this mission, one of rare ones to think about this on the protocol / research side.
But I also think that based rollups are probably not the solution we're looking for. Based rollups + L2 preconfs are essentially just "decentralized sequencing where the sequencers are the L1 nodes".
(See this excellent article by @jon_charb if you have no idea what I'm talking about: https://t.co/hPaXCgccSc)
If you're running a rollup, the value proposition seems very iffy — why would you give your MEV to the L1 nodes (or introduce frontrunning if you have a private mempool, as it the case for most L2s today)? The answer is mostly "Ethereum-alignment" and I don't think it's quite good enough.
How do we get people to spend/burn more ETH then?
I think maybe the time has come for enshrined rollups.
@SuccinctLabs just released the first prod version of their SP1 prover with sub-cent proving cost per Ethereum tx. There are also other promising provers like Jolt.
So let Ethereum run its own rollups. Then they can use the based + preconf system, and settle via a zkVM node execution.
@VitalikButerin has written about this (of course): https://t.co/W4HeLpXbEg
(One interesting point he highlights is we don't want to enshrine one implementation of Ethereum for the proofs. Instead, consensus on L2 blocks is done using whatever mechanism nodes want: verifying one or multiple different types of zk proof for the same block (different proving schemes, different client execution being proven) or even re-executing the rollup blocks.)
Also this solves cross-L2 interop pretty neatly: L2s settle to the L1, so other L2s can read the blockhash and you can prove cross-L2 messages via a Merkle tree or a zk proof against that hash. You could even enshrine that interop system in the protocol, allowing for atomic cross-rollup txs.
Optimism's interop system is the perfect blueprint here: https://t.co/V1TBz5JRN5
How hard is it to build all this? I'd say the main challenge is getting L1 validators to act as sequencers and offering preconfs — this probably has to stay optional to maintain the viability of home stakers. The rest you could get a team to implement pretty quickly by proving Reth with SP1 and modifying the other clients to gossip and verify proofs (then convince the core dev teams to merge this ��� harder). The enshrined interop stuff is also hard.
As a temporary measure, you could setup an L1 contract to auction future sequencing rights. The winners of that auction are able to offer preconfs, and can set themselves as the L2 fee recipient.
If you also let L1 nodes add transactions to those blocks you get a system that handles MEV gracefully, is censorship-resistant, and guarantees that someone will sequence the rollups even if the validators are not up to speed yet.
The other big challenge is that a bug in reth or SP1 can be fatal — an easy stopgap solution is for validators to trust a centralized executor for additional verification on top of verifying the proof.
These enshrined rollups are value-accretive to ETH (a portion or all of their fees get burned, they consume blobspace) and enable fast cross-rollup composition (not atomic, but 12s latency is achievable from the get-go, instantaneous down the line).
Who's going to build this as a public good?
Who's going to write the EIPs?
Betting against Ethereum is as stupid as betting against Musk+Jobs+Gates+Buffet.
It’s a big collective mind working on the coolest problems of humanity. I get offers on a daily basis to do things elsewhere for more money but Ethereum is so damn fun and I love working with people smarter than me. Money can’t replace culture.
The dank blobs are here.
Congrats to the @ethereum community and the core developers for officially inaugurating the rollup era and accelerating permissionless innovation!
Spoke the $MATIC founders @MihailoBjelic and @sandeepnailwal a few days ago about MATIC's roadmap and I can only say there's so much coming that I'm still not seeing anyone talk about.
Absurd to me how MATIC will soon explode in TVL and TPS post becoming an aggregation layer and still trading below $AVAX and $DOT. Won't be surprised if MATIC starts getting comped to EigenLayer in the coming months.