The question is whether it makes sense to treat college sports as a 500,000 athlete monolith, with the same governance for football as for swimming & golf.
In practice, college sports has developed into two versions: revenue-generating and not.
Why not treat non-revenue differently, and truly tied to the educational experience? While big-time college sports (an amazing tradition) carries on with a revenue-based model.
We wrote more about the legal benefits of this model here:
https://t.co/2xRq65mLT2
Sen. Maria Cantwell on the SEC and Big Ten opposition: "What we did today is say we’re not going to let the most powerful and richest conferences dictate to the rest of America what’s going to happen to 500,000 athletes."
Godfrey- who initially won then lost his extra season in Georgia- then went to Arizona court, continues his effort to play this season.
Not a surprising move here, because the order he obtained in Arizona court only required the school to certify him as eligible and not the NCAA.
Now NCAA added to the lawsuit and we’ll see if the court grants an injunction requiring the NCAA to deem him eligible and not punish Arizona (under the “Rule of Restitution”) if they play him.
Good breakdown from Sam, and the NCAA’s effort to get the Georgia court to enjoin the Arizona lawsuit was just denied per the athlete’s counsel.
Complex legal maneuvering that is usually reserved for academic exercises, which were actually seeing play out in real life as a result of the class of 2022 dispute.
So perhaps under the radar given the RJ Luis drama yesterday... what on earth is going on with the other basketball playing RJ, RJ Godfrey?
A quick (coming back after and ok, not so quick) breakdown of this confusing and crazy legal drama. 🧵 https://t.co/9xe8lJXjZ5
LSU’s general counsel sent this letter to the SEC’s general counsel, describing the school as in an “untenable situation” where it sees “no viable alternative” but to comply with the court order and roster RJ Luis.
Interesting response from the SEC, suggesting that it disagrees with LSU’s belief that the court’s order *requires* the school to place Luis on its roster.
RJ Luis is officially added to the LSU roster.
The SEC's federal lawsuit against the school - partially over the participation of pro players - remains active in Alabama.
This changes things significantly in the SEC’s lawsuit.
One of the questions when they first filed involved “standing,” in other words did the SEC even have grounds for filing suit when LSU at that time had not yet rostered any players who would be ineligible under the new SEC “no former pros” rule.
But now that they’ve rostered Luis, that question is answered in the SEC’s favor.
There are lots of other important questions and it’s unclear how the suit might turn out. But this was one big step.
Another high profile test case in the nationwide question of just how much control that NIL contracts can give schools over athlete transfers.
Darian Mensah’s contract dispute with Duke over his Miami transfer ended with a settlement and Heisman campaign in Miami. Demond Williams contract dispute with Washington ended with him staying put.
Brendan Sorsby-Cincinnati is another significant pending example and there will be others.
Solving the issue of when and how college athletes can transfer and retain eligibility will continue to be done in courts, unless one of the other 3 C’s (Congress or collective bargaining) steps in. Neither look likely anytime soon.
LSU DE Princewill Umanmielen's legal team has responded to Ole Miss.
He asserts his contract with Ole Miss is not valid, saying he "only signed the 2026 Revenue Sharing Agreement under undue pressure from the University (Ole Miss), including its coaching staff."
(Story below)
Significant that the SEC bylaws don’t contain their own “rule of restitution.”
The NCAA bylaws do, which purports to allow the NCAA to punish schools who roster/play athletes who gain eligibility due to a court injunction, if that injunction is later overturned.
In other words, if an appellate court tosses one of these athlete injunctions, technically the NCAA rules allow it to vacate wins earned when the player was on the field/court.
The NCAA has asserted in some filings in some cases that it may do so, although we haven’t seen it happen yet.
"The SEC will abide by the terms of the preliminary injunction while it remains in place and will not impose penalties or fines on LSU if it place Mr. Luis on its men’s basketball roster."
We're now awaiting acknowledgement from LSU.
The court order from Judge William Jorden signed Friday ordering LSU to roster RJ Luis. The order specifically mentions the SEC’s “Professionalism Rules.”
I’m told LSU leadership is meeting this morning to decide how to proceed.
@1045espn@LASportsDotNet
House plaintiff attorney Jeffrey Kessler's reaction to the SEC's proposed cap policy, which comes a couple weeks after the Big Ten created its own cap rules: "If either one of them goes through with this, we will see them in court."
I think the SEC’s counter-argument to Mit’s point here might be that it is not raising the House cap- it is actually penalizing schools who exceed that cap.
The counter-argument to the SEC could be that the penalty is nominal: 1-3% up to about $70M. And therefore the cap is de facto raised to $70M.
Will be interesting to see if this sees the inside of a courtroom.
The SEC’s rule would be unilaterally raising the rev sharing cap, which it can’t do under the House settlement.
Will other conferences and the NCAA agree to the cap going up?
We’ll see.
Great question. The short answer is that yes conference rules *generally* could and have been challenged through a contract claim.
But I’m not sure there would be a strong argument to challenge conference *compensation* rules specifically, with a contract claim.
The successful contract claims prove that the governing body breached a contractual duty created by its rules for the athletes benefit.
Oftentimes this is shown when a conference treats athletes inconsistently under the rules. Think NCAA medical waiver cases, where one athlete is given the waiver and another isn’t under arguably similar circumstances.
It’s hard to see an athlete making that case if a conference simply applies compensation rules as stated and consistently to all schools.
Hairston v. PAC-10 is an exemplar case, but the athletes lost that one when the court found they didn’t qualify as beneficiaries of the contract (conference rules).
@WinterSportsLaw Good stuff Mit. Will the schools challenge the new SEC rule as circumventing/raising the Hoise cap? Will be interesting to wait and see
The provisions regarding third-party NIL and the CSC are really significant. Noteworthy that this conference rule would essentially cut out a big chunk of CSC oversight, by simply counting some of the money that has been caught up in arguments over what counts as an “associated entity”.
Think the Nebraska-CSC arbitration. Similar deal in the SEC would now simply count towards the new cap rules and avoid that legal entanglement.
Great question. The short answer is that yes conference rules *generally* could and have been challenged through a contract claim.
But I’m not sure there would be a strong argument to challenge conference *compensation* rules specifically, with a contract claim.
The successful contract claims prove that the governing body breached a contractual duty created by its rules for the athletes benefit.
Oftentimes this is shown when a conference treats athletes inconsistently under the rules. Think NCAA medical waiver cases, where one athlete is given the waiver and another isn’t under arguably similar circumstances.
It’s hard to see an athlete making that case if a conference simply applies compensation rules as stated and consistently to all schools.
Hairston v. PAC-10 is an exemplar case, but the athletes lost that one when the court found they didn’t qualify as beneficiaries of the contract (conference rules).
Another potentially landmark moment in college sports as its governance shifts in part from the NCAA- which dominated rules enforcement for 75 years- toward conferences.
Antitrust questions may be raised, but conference-level compensation rules will have a much stronger defense than NCAA rules. The ultimate answer will come down to the definition of the relevant market.
If athletes object to the SEC’s cap, but a court finds that they can simply play elsewhere as a reasonable substitute, it’s unlikely a court would find that the SEC’s cap is an antitrust violation.
Details of the SEC’s proposed cap policy are emerging: The league would penalize schools in a tiered fine system reaching $10M+ in fines for those spending $70.5M+ on rosters, sources tell @YahooSports.
Said one AD: “The new cap would basically be $70M.”
https://t.co/zeNuP1SZH9