@CharlesN83072@Fx1Jonny There is, my friend: the context of war, persecution, and being driven out of your homes.
Islam is just, but it is not weak.
Justice does not mean passivity in the face of aggression.
Have a good night.
@CharlesN83072@Fx1Jonny The Quran is freely available online for anyone willing to read it. You’re wasting your time copying and pasting fragments of passages while deliberately stripping them of their context.
I’ve already answered you my friend. There’s no point repeating the same arguments while ignoring the historical, political and military context of these texts. 🤔
I’ve given you Quranic verses that directly address your accusations. If you refuse to consider them, this discussion is going nowhere.
Let’s move on.
Les données biographiques de Asma la sœur aînée de l’épouse du prophète, affirment qu’elle avait dix ans de plus qu’elle, qu’elle avait environ 27 ans à l’Hégire et qu’elle est décédée en 73 AH à l’âge de 100 ans.
Le calcul est pourtant simple : l’épouse de notre prophète avait 17 ans à l’Hégire, puis environ 19 ans au moment de la consommation de son mariage, en 2 AH.
On ne peut pas écarter des données historiques simplement parce qu’elles dérangent le récit des non-croyants.
What you are presenting as “religious bigotry” is a deliberate interpretation of the Quran, isolating three verses from the rest of the text to make it say something it does not.
Let’s start with a fundamental principle: Islam does not give anyone the right to kill another person simply because they do not share their faith.
The Quran is very explicit on this matter:
(2:190): “Fight in the cause of Allah those who fight you, but do not transgress. Indeed, Allah does not love transgressors.”
(60:8): Allah does not forbid you from showing kindness and acting justly towards those who do not fight you because of your religion or drive you out of your homes. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly.
(8:61): “And if they incline towards peace, then you too should incline towards it.”
(2:256): “There is no compulsion in religion.”
These are not modern interpretations invented to make Islam more flexible. They are part of the Quran, just as much as the verses you are quoting !
As for verse 9:29, it does address fighting, Jizya and the political status of the People of the Book in a specific historical context. It does not command Muslims to kill Jews and Christians simply because they are Jews and Christians, nor does it instruct them to forcefully convert them. The Jizya was precisely the tax associated with their being allowed to retain their religious identity under Muslim political authority.
There is a fundamental difference between a text regulating political and military relations between communities in a particular historical context and a supposed divine command to massacre people who do not share one’s beliefs.
You are free to disagree with Islamic theology, but portraying the Quran as a book that commands the indiscriminate killing of non-believers demonstrates a huge lack of understanding of its actual content.
Before lecturing others about religious tolerance and morality, perhaps you should start by reading and understanding the entire text.
Moi aussi, je comprends que tu te sois limité à quelques moitiés de hadiths, non attribuées à la parole directe du Prophète. Maintenant, je te suggère de lire le reste de Sahih al-Bukhari pour découvrir que d’autres hadiths contredisent celui sur lequel tu t’es basé et que l’âge de l’épouse du Prophète est finalement estimé à 19 ans.
Assez de vos bêtises, c’est vous qui faites honte à l’humanité entière.
@AFpost When Lindsay Clancy strangled her 3 babies to death, no one said “Catholic Killer.”
Allah does not speak to us directly in this way.
This N is schizo.
Your verse does not say that Muslims must kill Christians for being Christians. It addresses polytheists in a specific historical context, involving conflicts and treaties concluded with certain Arab tribes.
The surrounding verses completely change the way this passage should be understood:
Quran 9:4: Polytheists who had entered into treaties with the Muslims and honoured their agreements were not to be fought. Muslims were commanded to respect those treaties until their expiration.
Quran 9:5: The verse you quoted.
Quran 9:6: If any of those polytheists sought protection from the Muslims, they were to be granted protection, allowed to hear the message of God, and then escorted to a place of safety.
This is how haters promote Islam: by distorting reality, taking verses out of context, and deliberately concealing the passages that contradict their narrative.
Let’s wake up everybody 🙏🏻
Vous répondre sur l’origine de vos souffrances ? J’ai déjà avancé une explication : le vide existentiel et le nihilisme. Croire que tout relève du hasard, que la vie n’a aucune finalité et que la mort marque le néant définitif, ce ne doit pas être particulièrement facile à vivre. C’est une vision du monde que je trouve profondément difficile à porter.
En pratique, vous ne croyez pas au Coran et le considérez comme une fiction. Qu’il vous annonce un châtiment dans l’au-delà ne devrait donc aucunement vous angoisser !
Dans ce même Coran, Dieu nous dit : « Allah ne vous défend pas d’être bienfaisants et équitables envers ceux qui ne vous ont pas combattus pour la religion et ne vous ont pas chassés de vos demeures. » (60:8).
Nous avons donc parfaitement les fondements nécessaires pour cohabiter en paix, même sans partager les mêmes croyances !