@Searcherseek Yeah I hear that. It’s hard to reconcile who he was and his theology with those books tbh. He was put through the wringer and I think he was forced to publish certain things certain ways and we know Mesilas Yisharim was not originally gonna be in the format we have it now.
@Searcherseek I read Ramchal cuz I knew him from yeshiva and was curious about the controversy. And I was like “wow”. This fella is not who they said he was. lol. I love the non dual theology underlying it all.
Yeah, it’s a bit of a pain to read cuz he’s so fuckin technical for a mystic. But he was so smart. If he lived pre-Shabsai Tzvi, he could have done a lot more good than he did. He writes like an annoying physicist, but with Kabbalah. I actually wrote summaries of it in English a while back. I can send them to you in a bit if you want. Didn’t translate verbatim, but summarized it so it’s not his exact words.
@Searcherseek True. But he gets pretty far out into metaphysics in Klach. and Machon Ramchal put out a sod hayichud recently where he goes pretty wild too. Just he’s very technical. He was trying to work it out as a science of reality and took himself very seriously
It’s actually an amazingly coherent theology imho. It’s also really hard to get from there to anything resembling Orthodox Judaism. Shabsai Tzvi really fucked Judaism by ruining a theology that could have produced amazing innovation by deciding he had to be moshiach and being a total fruitcake psycho. He could have even been a fruit cake and it would have been fine. He went full retard tho and screwed everything up. Oh well.
Yeah. The Ramchal has some crazy stuff too. But they both use a lot more words. And are way more poetic. Nefesh Hachaim is just like “It’s all one. There’s no good and bad really, cuz there’s really nothing else but one reality. This is what the Arizal was saying. now don’t think about this or act like this ever.”
@Searcherseek It’s like, the most subversive theology ever put the most plainly I’ve seen it put in any non eastern text and by the GOAT of livaks. Who woulda thunk it
I’ve actually wondered about this/found it funny for a long time.
I think it was something like “from what I have seen and experienced this is definitely true. The Vilna Gaon felt the same way. I’m not gonna be able to convince anyone who believes otherwise it’s not actually true, so fuck it. I’ll just say it’s true but you can’t ever act like it is.”
@NhavsMaimonides …according to the faction who won. Sounds more noble then “Pick me cuz I want power more than the other guy.” Like politicians who are fighting to “protect freedom” from their competition, who will supposedly “turn America communist, or facist”
@NhavsMaimonides I know the story as we have it. History is, as they say, written by the winners. E”Y was “Hellenized” already. It had already been for a while. My point is that both sides were Hellenized. One side, the side Antiochus bet on and supported, lost. The Hasmoneans were hellenized too