@marioreji2 Cihan, yüzüğü Mirza'nın yüzüne fırlatıp kendisine bir sorun daha yaratacak kadar aptal değil. Tıpkı velayet davasında yaptığı gibi doğru zamanı bekliyor. Boran'ı alt edip velayeti alabileceği anı beklemişti.
@elzgr1 to give it to Kaya and has been treating him badly since she knew about she is not Cihan mother, that sense of obligation will disappear. When he eventually returns as the leader, knowing that Sadakat has disowned him, he will no longer feel indebted to her.
@elzgr1 Because Cihan can't bring himself to do that. He had confronted Sadakat many times, but he still can't bring himself to kick her out of the house because, in his eyes, he owes everything he has to her. However, if he finds out that Sadakat has taken the leadership away from him +
@wolfthelife@nuraalbora Bunun, Cihan'ın Alya'dan ayrılmak zorunda kalacağı süreçle paralel ilerleyeceğini de düşünüyorum. Ama gitmeden önce Alya'ya duygularını itiraf edecek. Yine de böyle bir senaryonun yaşanmasını hiç istemiyorum.
@elzgr1 And now Sadakat is plotting behind Cihan's back to make Kaya the new leader. Once the truth about Azem comes out, I think Cihan will strip her of her Hanimaga status.
@elzgr1 I'm waiting for Sadakat to get her karma when she discovers that Azem had another woman in his life and that Cihan is actually Azem son, whom Sadakat was forced to raise as the leader of the tribe. This revelation would absolutely crush her. +++
@elzgr1 Yes, if that's the case, you're right. I'm not looking at him solely from a CihAl perspective; I'm judging him as an independent character in his own right.
@elzgr1 Sadakat is 100% evil in my eyes, but being a narcissistic parent doesn't make her the only villain. Kartal is no innocent man either. He can kill innocent people and smuggle heavy weapons to support terrorists. How can someone like that be considered less evil?
@elzgr1 Cihan had been living a happy life, do you really think Kartal wouldn't have started a war against Cihan after discovering that Alya was his daughter? Just look at his character. You say he's not as bad as Sadakat, but I disagree. +++
@elzgr1 just as he said in the trailer. And considering his need for the land to carry out smuggling, I think he's going to turn out to be 2nd Sadakat.
@elzgr1 Only for now, But in the future, the line between them may disappear completely. Ok he don't know Cihan but Kartal can see that Alya cares for Cihan and that Cihan was willing to walk into the fire to save her. Yet, he will try to ruin Cihan's life, +++
@elzgr1 I don't think Alya will be happy about Kartal after everything he's been doing, like killing Enver and plotting behind her back. She might accept him before learning the truth, but once she finds out what he's done, she will hate him.
@cilekliimonataa Alya, Kartal'a karşı yumuşasa bile bunun nedeni Cihan olacak, tıpkı Fikriye olayında olduğu gibi. Çünkü Kartal'ın Alya'nın babası olduğunu ilk keşfeden kişinin Cihan olabileceğini düşünüyorum.
Is Hasan telling the truth? I believe he is. But I also think there's much more to Cihan's story than Hasan himself knows.
Remember, Hasan was just a child back then. He didn't witness the conversation between the two women. He only heard it, which is what Sadakat implied as well.
He knows his sister gave birth to a stillborn girl, and he was the one who buried the child and concealed what happened. He also implies that Azem knew nothing.
So do I believe Hasan? Yes. That's his side of the story, and more importantly, that's what HE believes happened.
But there's one question I cannot get out of my head.
Why did Makbule, on her deathbed, confess that she had wronged Cihan Albora?
According to Hasan, Makbule knew exactly who the Alboras were. She knew how powerful they were and was terrified of telling them their baby had died.
So she gave them another newborn, whose mother had supposedly died and who had no family.
But was that really such a terrible thing to do TO Cihan?
Of course, we know what Cihan's life became. How much he suffered because of that family, how much responsibility was forced onto his shoulders and how he became their sacrificial lamb.
But could Makbule have known any of that? I seriously doubt it.
From an outsider's perspective, the Alboras were a wealthy, respected family. They had every means to provide a child with a comfortable life and a secure future.
If Cihan really was an orphan with nobody, Makbule essentially gave him a chance at a life he otherwise might never have had.
So why would she need Cihan's forgiveness?
Yes, she deceived Sadakat and Azem. Yes, she concealed the death of their biological child. But her confession was specifically about wronging CIHAN.
And that's where Hasan's story stops making sense.
There are too many missing pieces, and I don't think Hasan is hiding them. I think he genuinely doesn't KNOW them.
Which brings me to my theory.
I still believe Cihan is an Albora. I believe Azem is his biological father. And I have this strange feeling that his mother might still be alive.
And if she is, I wouldn't be surprised if she turned out to be someone significant. Perhaps even a powerful hanımağa from another clan.
I can't explain what happened that night, and I don't think anyone can yet. But I doubt Hasan is the only living person who knows something about Cihan's origins.
My biggest suspicion? Muzaffer.
Remember what Hasan told us. Azem and Sadakat were attending a wedding that night.
Azem was the leader of the Albora clan, and Muzaffer was his right-hand man.
Do we ever see Cihan attending important events alone? Almost never. He has his people with him, especially when travelling as the head of the family.
Why should we assume Azem operated differently?
I wouldn't be surprised if Muzaffer accompanied Azem to that wedding and knows something about what happened.
Considering how long he's been part of that household, I find it difficult to believe he knows absolutely nothing.
I could be wrong, tho.
There's also something about Makbule's confession that makes me question Hasan's story. What if Cihan wasn't actually a child with nobody in the world? What if his birth circumstances were different from what Hasan was led to believe?
Because if Makbule really did something terrible TO Cihan, perhaps the question isn't why she gave him to the Alboras, but what, or whom, she took him away from.
And that brings me back to his biological mother.
I genuinely think Hasan has already told us everything he knows. I don't expect the biggest revelation to come from him.
I think the real twist will come from someone closer to the Albora family. Someone who was there, knows what happened that night and has kept that secret for almost four decades.
And if that's the case, we've probably only scratched the surface of Cihan Albora's story.
2/3
“I'm not constantly blaming you, but don't act like you're completely innocent either.”
THIS. Because this is the conversation they've needed to have for so long. Cihan is finally refusing to let the entire breakdown of their relationship be placed on his shoulders, and Alya is refusing to accept that everything that happened afterwards was simply her fault.
Alya reminds him that after the wedding disaster, she came back the very next day. She explained why she had made that decision, apologised, and told him she wanted to stand by him. And she's right about one thing: Cihan was the one who sent her away. He cannot pretend that she never tried to come back or that he gave her an opportunity to repair what had happened.
But I also think there's something missing from Alya's argument. Cihan was heartbroken. He had just discovered that Alya left, and he was already carrying the unbearable grief of losing Şahin. He wasn't in a place where he could simply put all of that aside and receive her apology. His reaction was hurtful, but understanding his pain matters too.
And this is where I keep coming back to the double standard between them. Last season, Alya repeatedly told Cihan to leave, pushed him away and challenged his commitment. Yet he didn't take every word as the final answer. He kept coming back because he understood that sometimes people speak from hurt, fear and pride rather than from what they truly want.
So why should Cihan's “go” automatically be treated as an absolute decision when he was grieving and devastated? Alya didn't have to force herself on him, but she could have recognised that he was hurting and that his words might not reflect everything he felt.
At the same time, Cihan cannot use his pain to erase the fact that she returned, apologised and tried to stand beside him.