Okay, so I’ve spoken to @FabrizioRomano.
It looks as though Chelsea have agreed Ahanor’s signing as a deferred transfer for the 27/28 season, while this season he’ll join Palace on loan from Atalanta.
Ergo, no rule break with Disasi.
Fab told me: “I can only guarantee to you that this season he plays at Palace and next season he plays at Chelsea.”
#CFC
🚨🔵🔴 Crystal Palace agree deal to sign Honest Ahanor on loan from Chelsea, here we go!
Verbal agreement done as Honest Ahanor joins Chelsea from Atalanta for £40m and then joins #CPFC on loan.
Medical booked on Monday.
I'm sorry, but assuming Mudryk's story is true, what exactly was he supposed to do?
Someone appointed by the national team specifically to advise him on nutrition gives him tablets to take.
What's he meant to do? Take them home and analyse them with a science kit? Ask what's in them and automatically assume he's being lied to?
By that logic, why would any athlete ever trust anything they're given?
The person handing him those tablets is supposed to be the expert. That's literally why they're employed.
Of course athletes have a responsibility, but if they're expected to independently verify absolutely everything their own qualified medical and nutritional staff give them, what exactly is the point of employing those professionals?
You can't expect athletes to trust the experts appointed to look after them, then call them idiots for doing that.
If Mudryk's account is true, surely the people responsible for advising him deserve scrutiny? #CFC #THFC #Mudryk
😡 "He's a fool!"
🤦♂️ "What you put in your mouth, as an athlete, you are responsible for!"
Simon Jordan is not having Mykhailo Mudryk blaming the Ukrainian national team for failing a drug's test in 2024! 😤
Yes, they should ask questions. But assuming Mudryk's account is true, what happens when the qualified professional employed by the national team tells him something is safe to take?
If an airline pilot is told by the airline's own certified engineers that a plane is safe to fly, do we expect him to dismantle the engine to check they're telling the truth?
Of course the pilot has a responsibility for safety, but there's a reason airlines employ specialist engineers.
Being responsible doesn't mean you can personally verify absolutely everything you're told by the people employed to advise you.
That's not how anti-doping rules work.
A substance can be perfectly legal in one country and still be banned by WADA worldwide.
Also, why would every other player automatically test positive? That assumes they all took the exact same substance, at the same dose, and were all tested while it was detectable.
None of those things has been established.
I'm not saying Mudryk's account is proven, but those arguments don't disprove it either.
@CFCSandeep@AirVonte8 In their own cup. They don't all have one cup with one pill in that they all take at the same time. One Flinstones Vitamin C tablet.
He wasn't taking it from Dave the dodgy guy who hangs around outside the training ground was he though? That's my point.
One player testing positive doesn't mean every player was given the same thing. How does anyone else's test result prove what Mudryk did or didn't take?
They don't all get one of the same cup. One Flinstones Vitamin C tablet that they all take together at the same table.
@CFCSandeep@John_Deegoat Your original point was that other people should have been banned, but that doesn't hold up. Have you heard of Hanlon's Razor? I I expect that explains it.
That's not how anti-doping rules work.
A substance can be perfectly legal in one country and still be banned by WADA worldwide.
Also, why would every other player automatically test positive? That assumes they all took the exact same substance, at the same dose, and were all tested while it was detectable.
None of those things has been established.
I'm not saying Mudryk's account is proven, but those arguments don't disprove it either.
@kelvinbossman Yeah, I'm always cracking open my paracetamol and checking it's made of a chemical compound with the molecular formula C₈H₉NO₂ (N-(4-hydroxyphenyl)acetamide or N-(4-hydroxyphenyl)ethanamide). Those doctors won't get me...
I'm not sure, and it's a fair question.
I know legal action against the Ukrainian FA has previously been discussed, but I've not seen confirmation Chelsea have pursued it.
That doesn't necessarily mean they haven't investigated privately, or that Mudryk's account is false.
Ultimately, any compensation claim would depend on establishing who was legally responsible and what losses they caused. I'm guessing that's a tough process.
@injectcopiumman Yeah 100%. It's interesting nonetheless, even if I don't agree with the methodology. Honestly, just fascinated I'm being used as a subject in a University Dissertation!
A university dissertation concluded my football transfer reporting had a 7.6% accuracy rate.
Then I discovered how'd they'd calculated it, and it's nothing short of both fascinating and hilarious.
This is a completely true story.
Somebody at Trinity College, Dublin wrote an entire university dissertation analysing the accuracy of football transfer accounts on Twitter, including mine.
Apparently, my transfer reporting had a 7.6% accuracy rate.
Except the guy who wrote the article openly admits that if I tweeted something like "Source - Sky Sports" or "According to The Guardian", they just chucked that into my numbers.
Me reporting what another journalist had said was apparently the same as me saying it was done. No aggregators allowed.
I spent years pointing out that news was attributed to a source only to discover that someone used that against me in a university dissertation. I made it very clear when I had some news, which was few and far between, but did happen, that news was genuinely very reliable, hence the follower gain.
The irony, of course, is that if he'd taken two seconds to do some due diligence, I'd have happily explained that reporting someone else's claims doesn't mean I'm endorsing them. Something I'd even made clear in my bio for years. My DMs are open, I check them often.
Here’s the best bit. The researcher acknowledges this exact problem in the limitations of his OWN dissertation, admitting that distinguishing between quoting another account and making the claim yourself was something a future system should address.
This was submitted as a Master's dissertation in Computer Science…
So, to recap, I was given a 7.6% accuracy rating in a dissertation because the methodology couldn't distinguish between making a claim and quoting somebody else's. The researcher even acknowledged the flaw. I spent years citing sources, only to discover that was being used as evidence against me. In a university dissertation. About accuracy.
You genuinely couldn't make it up.
I think we're talking about two different things. I'm not disputing that false rumours generate engagement or that building the language model is technically impressive. I've spoken about the false rumours thing adnausem in the past. As long as you don't care about the negative pushback there really is very little negative to doing it as long as you gain traction from it and then do what you will with that.
My issue is with the underlying logic. A model being 97% confident in identifying transfer rumours doesn't establish that the methodology used to evaluate those rumours is sound.
You can build a system that performs its intended task extremely well, but if the logic applied before the system is created is flawed, the sophistication doesn't correct that.
That's a fair point, and I'm not dismissing the technical achievement. My counter would be that the system appears to be built on flawed logic that could be corrected without needing an advanced language model.
I don't know if this is a flawed analogy, but if you're building a house with a thousand bricks and one piece of slate, you don't need a sophisticated system to recognise that the slate doesn't belong in the brickwork. Is it similar? Sure. Does it belong with the bricks? Nope.
Sometimes a simple set of rules is more effective than an unnecessarily complicated solution.
Of course! Here you go:
https://t.co/Xd9E6BLjEj
Page 81 is the relevant bit. I appreciate he acknowledged the limitation, and I've no issue with the research itself. I just think it's an important distinction when presenting someone's reporting accuracy especially at dissertation level for a University that calls itself the Harvard of Dublin!
I'm not arguing that aggregators should be excluded. They can spread inaccurate stories too, and that's worth measuring.
However, measuring how often information someone shares turns out to be correct isn't the same as measuring the accuracy of their own original reporting.
That's the distinction I'm making.
That's not what I was debating though.
I agree that removing me wouldn't change Ornstein's accuracy.
You can measure how often the stories I share turn out to be true, but that's fundamentally different from measuring my accuracy as an original source.
My issue isn't Ornstein's score. It's presenting those two things as comparable when they're not.