@sharon_maas@attackdogX I understand you're trying to make a connection, but Judaism, Christianity, and Islam have more in common than you would realize. That is because they are Abrahamic Faiths.
This nigga: 1.) felt absolutely no shame asking grok this question 2.) felt like it was a flex that the computer did indeed reply with the names of some shitskins no one has ever heard of
LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOO I refuse to believe the brown inbreds are real
Premises aren't sound, they're true or false. Arguments are sound.
And you agree with all four lines. Good, those are the premises. The argument is the part you skipped, where lines 1 and 2 break line 3 if "is" means what it means everywhere else.
So what's your response? What does IS mean in lines 1 and 2?
The IS of identity?
The IS of predication?
Relative identity?
The Bible says it's true, so it's true?
@AlZuttedAllah Yeah, you're right, man; only Europeans knew science and math.
@grok, name 10 scientists from the Muslim world who laid the foundation for modern technology. Use historically accurate sources and no spin.
I'm sorry I don't understand. In the sense of the necessary being? Then God is the only uncreated necessary being. Everything else is a creation of God.
You may be tempted to ask what's before God. But that question itself is not logical because God is outside of the creation (IE Time and Space) there is no before or after.
Okay so let's take these one at a time.
1. Adam's descendants. The first generations were Muslim because they followed the shariah of Adam AS. Then people strayed as the generations passed, and prophets and messengers were sent to guide them back to the truth.
It doesn't pass down by blood though. If your parents are Muslim and you deny God and His messenger, your lineage doesn't save you. And if your parents reject Islam and you accept it as the truth, you answer for your own choice and you're rewarded for it. Nuh AS lost his own son, and Ibrahim AS had an idol worshipper for a father.
2. All religions and the multiverse. No, every religion isn't a type of Islam. Ibn Taymiyyah's point is that the prophets all had one religion with different laws, and once a law is replaced, holding on to the old one isn't Islam anymore. What people invented on top never was.
Multiverses don't get much discussion in Islamic theology, but they don't break anything in it either. God is the Lord of the worlds, plural, and in our theology the world means everything other than God. So one universe or a thousand, all of it is created, all of it had a beginning, and all of it is His.
3. The Prophet Muhammad PBUH is the final Prophet and Messenger and we believe he's the best of creation. No prophet comes after him and no law replaces his, so his guidance is the eternal guidance.
But the guidance is God's, and the one who brought it is CREATED. He's the best of everything God created and he's still created, because only God has no beginning.
Also what guardrails did you set up so that the LLM doesn't hallucinate. Where did the LLM check the source of citations. How do you know that the LLM didn't hallucinate any of that.
AI is a great tool but unless specific guardrails are put in this type of analysis can be flawed.
Fine, if you want an argument - here you go. But don't run away and block me. And respond with a rebuttal, otherwise I'll know you don't know the answer.
1. The Father IS God.
2. The Son IS God.
3. The Father is not the Son.
4. There is one God.
You guys hold all four at the same time.
If "is" means what it means everywhere else then the Father IS God and God IS the Son, so the Father IS the Son. That's transitivity and line 3 says he isn't. And if you keep line 3 then the Son is not the God that the Father is, so he's God by line 2 and Not God by lines 1 and 3. That's the entity I asked you about.
Even if we say "is" only means each one has the divine nature, you still have two who each have it and aren't each other, and you still can't get line 4 out of that.
And don't appeal to the Bible for this. A verse can tell me what you believe, it can't make four lines fit together. If "is" gets a special meaning only for your God and the only reason is that your book needs it, that's special pleading. And it's circular logic, because whether your book makes sense is the thing being tested.
You said simple first order logic. So walk me through what IS means in lines 1 and 2 without breaking 3 or 4, and where else does "is" work like that?
I don't see the parallel. Do you believe in Abraham, Moses, and all the Prophets sent to the Jews? Christianity claims strict monotheism as well. In practice, it's slightly convoluted, but that is their belief. They also believe that you must believe in the trinity to get salvation.
I don't understand how Hinduism with its plurality would be closer to Christianity.
Yes, in the sense that they submitted to God and worshipped God alone. They had their own shariah (laws).
The Quran uses the word that way itself. Surat Al Imran ayah 67 says Ibrahim (Abraham) AS wasn't a Jew or a Christian, he was haneefan musliman, an upright monotheist who submitted to God, and he wasn't one of those who associate partners with Him.
We believe every nation was sent a Prophet or Messenger who called his people to monotheism and either brought laws with him (a Messenger) or revived and upheld the laws already given (a Prophet).
And we believe the Prophet Muhammad PBUH was the final Prophet and Messenger, and his message is for all of mankind.
It may be because the educated have the most to lose if those below them rise, whether it's lower-caste members, those of lower social standing, or marginalized minorities. Sometimes the people are a combo of all that.
But this class issue is not endemic to India solely, this is a worldwide issue. Where those who have more opportunities look down upon those who have less.
You believe God ate food. The Quran only needed one line for that
كَانَا يَأْكُلَانِ الطَّعَامَ
"They both ate food" (Surat Al Ma'idah ayah 75) - In reference to Jesus and his mother Mary.
If he ate then he NEEDED to eat, and whoever needs something depends on it, and the One that everything depends on does not depend on bread. So explain to me who was running the heavens and the earth while he was a newborn being carried around by his mother, and why that sounds normal to you but a prophet being foretold sounds desperate.