@FlickMythRob@LookATLuceroJ I’m proposing there is no double standard. That Pitt movies also equally discuss his allegations. But that it’s not as noticeable because a) the reviews are overall more positive and b) Pitt never had a career slowdown
@LookATLuceroJ@FlickMythRob A large percentage of reviews of F1 discussed his allegations and some similarly framed the movie in terms of PR management. Isn’t it possible that it and cliff booth are just better movies than ebanezer?
@Musica11235 There’s no reason to assume that zimmer wrote this. He was never announced as writing every piece of music for every episode. This is just from a scene they released. Still bad though
@jose112y@wdwpro1 Of course she’s biased (we all are) but she still liked the movie! If you prefer critics who ignore cultural context, you are free to read those critics. But doing so is demonstrably not a requirement of professional criticism, given that cc is regularly published in film reviews
@jose112y@wdwpro1 But she does judge all those elements (and likes most of them!) In your opinion, what would be an appropriate discussion of cultural context? “This is Depp’s first major Hollywood role in a decade, for absolutely no particular reason. I am unbiased!”?
@jose112y@wdwpro1 It’s part of the reason he hasn’t led a big movie in years, and why the public views him differently now (both negatively and positively.) the movie is built around his stardom. It’s normal for a critic to discuss cultural context and has been for the history of film criticism
@jose112y@wdwpro1 6 sentences out of 26 is not 90% It’s relevant because this is his first Hollywood leading role in a decade, and that’s a major factor in the movie’s marketing and its place in cultural conversations (as proved by our conversation.) Rotten Tomatoes counted her review was positive
@jose112y@wdwpro1 A user generated Letterboxd “review”? Sorry, given that this was in response to a Variety roundup of professional reviews, I thought you were talking about mainstream professional reviews, not the logs of random people on a social media platform
@Ravensall333@AdrianAskarieh Depp has lost one defamation case and won another. He spent millions to help spread flattering moments from the latter case on social media. Whatever your final opinion, if you think it’s 100 percent clear cut you’re either uninformed or sycophantic
@Shes_Kerosene@AThinksAloud The white boy does seem to be friends with the black boy, but when he has a birthday party, the black boy isn’t invited. The movie doesn’t really address racism, but things like that portray a clear divide between the roles of whites and blacks in this idyllic world