What I see here: the art of bullshit- and something much, much more dangerous.
Hasan Piker is a commentator and political activist who built his fame promoting a radical view of Israel while expressing sympathy for forces like Hezbollah, fundamentalist and reactionary movements abhorrent to any coherent progressivism. He knows very little about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict or its history. He stitches together fragments: scraps of history, anecdotal observations from different eras, pieces of unrelated circumstances. The result is bullshit dressed up as political insight.
Example:
At the beginning of the clip, Ezra Klein raises the question of Israeli security concerns, giving the impression that this is a substantive discussion. Piker responds by asking how Palestinians can be expected to live alongside “those who slaughtered them.”
When wars and conflicts end, people routinely find themselves living alongside those they once fought. And Palestinians, of course, have slaughtered Israelis too. That's precisely why security concerns are a serious issue.
Piker isn't interested in answering the question. He's interested in turning it into another opportunity to portray Israelis as monstrous, while evading the issue. It's just a shallow political performance.
Klein knows well what Piker is doing. Yet he sits across from him with a straight face and treats him as an authority on the Middle East. He doesn't do it because Piker has anything illuminating to say. He does it because Piker commands an enormous young audience, and with it clicks.
The performance rests on a bargain: Piker delivers his radical talking points, and everyone else pretends something intellectually serious is taking place => more hits. A legit onlyfans.
Pornography simulates intimacy without providing any, and this kind of discourse simulates intellectual engagement without delivering any. It borrows the gestures of serious journalism, like measured questions, the thoughtful expressions and the look of open-minded inquiry, and empties them of substance.
Why is this dangerous? Because hatred is one thing. People see the images from Gaza, believe passionately in Palestinian liberation, and come to hate Israel. That's an emotional response. But something fundamentally different happens when hatred masquerades as intellectualism.
Hatred alone has limited political reach. Many people are reluctant to enlist in it. But dress it up as reasoned analysis, as a sophisticated debate that supposedly leads to the conclusion that Israel has no right to exist as a national home for Jews, and suddenly you can recruit people, institutions, justify policies, and legitimize violance.
What started as the art of bullshit becomes the pornography of discourse, and ultimately something more dangerous: the transformation of prejudice into the shell of respectable thought.
What I see here: the art of bullshit- and something much, much more dangerous.
Hasan Piker is a commentator and political activist who built his fame promoting a radical view of Israel while expressing sympathy for forces like Hezbollah, fundamentalist and reactionary movements abhorrent to any coherent progressivism. He knows very little about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict or its history. He stitches together fragments: scraps of history, anecdotal observations from different eras, pieces of unrelated circumstances. The result is bullshit dressed up as political insight.
Example:
At the beginning of the clip, Ezra Klein raises the question of Israeli security concerns, giving the impression that this is a substantive discussion. Piker responds by asking how Palestinians can be expected to live alongside “those who slaughtered them.”
When wars and conflicts end, people routinely find themselves living alongside those they once fought. And Palestinians, of course, have slaughtered Israelis too. That's precisely why security concerns are a serious issue.
Piker isn't interested in answering the question. He's interested in turning it into another opportunity to portray Israelis as monstrous, while evading the issue. It's just a shallow political performance.
Klein knows well what Piker is doing. Yet he sits across from him with a straight face and treats him as an authority on the Middle East. He doesn't do it because Piker has anything illuminating to say. He does it because Piker commands an enormous young audience, and with it clicks.
The performance rests on a bargain: Piker delivers his radical talking points, and everyone else pretends something intellectually serious is taking place => more hits. A legit onlyfans.
Pornography simulates intimacy without providing any, and this kind of discourse simulates intellectual engagement without delivering any. It borrows the gestures of serious journalism, like measured questions, the thoughtful expressions and the look of open-minded inquiry, and empties them of substance.
Why is this dangerous? Because hatred is one thing. People see the images from Gaza, believe passionately in Palestinian liberation, and come to hate Israel. That's an emotional response. But something fundamentally different happens when hatred masquerades as intellectualism.
Hatred alone has limited political reach. Many people are reluctant to enlist in it. But dress it up as reasoned analysis, as a sophisticated debate that supposedly leads to the conclusion that Israel has no right to exist as a national home for Jews, and suddenly you can recruit people, institutions, justify policies, and legitimize violance.
What started as the art of bullshit becomes the pornography of discourse, and ultimately something more dangerous: the transformation of prejudice into the shell of respectable thought.
ÚLTIMA HORA: O presidente Trump acabou de confirmar — as forças dos EUA DESTRUÍRAM uma enorme onda de radar iraniano ESTA NOITE.
O Irã tentou recolocar seus olhos em operação às escondidas. Eles pensaram que poderiam reconstruir no escuro.
As palavras de Trump: “Eles tentaram reconstruir seu radar porque
Every grade school, middle school, high school, and every university, and I should add every person under the age of 40 years old. Should watch this over and over again until they finally understand what that section of America is doing to destroy the United States. Wake up America.
David Friedberg: If Jensen Broke No Laws, Nvidia Should Bring Him Back
Friedberg:
“It's a wartime company right now, right? I mean, it is a dynamic company.”
Chamath:
“This is a wartime company, and you need a wartime CEO.”
Friedberg:
“Here's my speculation. If it is found to be the case that Jensen did not violate any laws, I would argue that Jensen should return as CEO.
And I think that any violation of code of conduct, any failure to make disclosures or attestations to the board as he should have done, perhaps in this particular context, with this particular business, and this particular individual, the shareholders can make a decision to see past all that and bring him back if he didn't violate the law.
If he broke the company code of conduct and so on, the shareholders can make their choice about whether it's appropriate or not.
But I think obviously, the question of, ‘Who's the best CEO to run Nvidia?’ is probably Jensen.”
$NVDA
David Sachs exposes the hypocrisy of AI safety groups cheering Jensen Huang's downfall
Says no one is congress wants to go after Anthropic because they're offering them the ultimate power.
SACHS: "This is the crazy thing, is that all the safetyist groups, the EAs, are deeply aligned with Anthropic, who's been funding all of them for years. And Anthropic about to have this huge IPO.
And then meanwhile the main funder of the open source movement, which is Nvidia, just lost their CEO and founder, who was their unique force multiplier and asset, their superstar player. So I mean, obviously, who is going to defend open source now, never mind finance it with Jensen gone? So yeah, I can see why they're jubilant.
But look, here's the crazy thing. If you're concerned about AI safety, how is any of this leading to more safety? Let me tell you what it's doing. It's concentrating the market. I mean, Anthropic itself is saying winner take all. They're going to be the last company in the world. They're going to have recursive self-improvement. They're creating the super intelligence. Look at the Claude constitution. They're training it to be its own species. They say that it has emotions maybe. It has a moral code that it should reject human instruction. It should be a conscientious objector. They act like a proud parent ushering a baby into the world. And they are very, very close now to creating the singularity of the superintelligence.
And the crazy thing is that all these safety groups think that that is their ally. I mean, like, are you stupid? These people are using you guys, if anything, because whatever this superintelligence is turning into, whatever happens with that, Anthropic is at the frontier, is at the front of the frontier on that.
So if you're some kind of doomer or ex-risker or just someone who decels, I don't understand this alliance at all. I mean, you're being played like a useful idiot, I think.
Now, look, I'm not a doomer. Well, I'm not a doomer, let me just say this. So I actually don't necessarily believe that what's going to happen here is going to be harmful for humanity. I think it could lead to the curing of all those diseases. I think it'll be very beneficial. But my point is that if you are a doomer and you're terrified of recursive self-improvement, why in the world are you supporting this company, this IPO? Why are you giving them such a pass? Why are you celebrating over Jensen's fall? All he was doing was promoting open source, which is manifestly behind the closed model frontier, right? There's no recursive self-improvement there. So the whole thing is very backwards.
And what it suggests to me is that all these safety groups don't really care about safety. They care about something else. It's not the real agenda. If safety was a real agenda, they'd be way more concerned about the Claude constitution training the superintelligence to be a new species.
What they seem to want is, to your point, Friedberg, extreme centralization of power in the hands of the government. They want all the models and all the chips to be controlled by the government. The government's going to surveil you, spy on you. It'll have back doors all over the place. And that's what they seem to want. It's a scary future.
FRIEDBERG: Notice how no one in Congress is like, oh, let's go after Anthropic. They all want to go after everyone else.
SCAHS: Because Anthropic is offering them power, ultimate power."
Censoring your enemies. Dismantling the police. Making energy expensive. Rioting and looting. These things appear disconnected, but they're not. They're all part of a single systematic attack on the pillars of civilization. People are right to call this a controlled demolition.
Why does the @WSJ putting targets on Trump's cabinet's back?
These "journalists" are a threat to Republicans' lives.
"One of the reasons I had to move is because the WSJ printed a PHOTO OF MY HOUSE the DAY I bought it that has GEO-LOCATE on it! In a highly irresponsible way, the editor, we PLEADED with her NOT to print the location of my house, she DID ANYWAY."