Hi guys!
As I already mentioned in previous posts, I'm leaving for a business trip to Japan tomorrow.
Unfortunately, four banners are dropping between November 11th and 12th:
Aha for HSR
Severian for ZZZ
Elyms for NTE
Lily for Wuwa (on the 12th)
Since I'll be flying, I'm not sure whether I'll be able to collect all the data needed for my usual Day 1 Revenue Performance posts.
Peak rankings in Japan and China shouldn't be an issue, but rankings in other regions might be difficult to track if I can't use my tracker.
Of course, if I manage to collect all the necessary data, the posts will be released as usual, although probably a bit later than normal since I'll be very busy over the next few days.
If I don't, I'll try the best with the data I can collect afterwards.
I'll also make a 10 Day Revenue Performance post for Aha, since she's a main push character.
This won't have any issue.
That's it! I just wanted to let you know in advance in case some posts end up being delayed or have some missing/different data.
Thank you for reading, and sorry for the inconvenience 🫤
Hi
I am generally against making distinction between male and female banners anyway and banner performance has a lot of variables other than the gender of the unit.
I am not responsible for tribalism outside of my account, I just don't have the time to even read about it.
I can comment on an info, analysis or comment if I directly get asked to give an opinion about a certain topic or data.
Fighting over this stuff is childish in my personal opinion.
Severian - ZZZ Day 1 Revenue Performance!
Hi guys!
I finally managed to find a bit of free time to dedicate to the profile.
I'll start with Severian's post, followed by Elyms and Lily.
As for Aha, I'll skip the usual Day 1 post and focus entirely on her 10 day performance instead, since I think there's much more to discuss there compared to a normal Day 1 analysis.
A few disclaimers before we begin:
Unfortunately, I wasn't able to track the peak rankings for most regions, which means I'll be using the daily rankings saved on Qimai for those countries.
CN and JP will still use peak rankings because I can track CN using Qimai, and my tracker can recover JP rankings up to a month ago.
STEAM data will also be unavailable for these posts.
Sorry about that.
Well, anyway, let's begin with Severian, ZZZ 3.3's second half unit!
iOS RANKINGS:
Severian peaked at 31st in JP and 105th in CN.
These rankings follow the recent trend of ZZZ's 2nd half units performing significantly worse than 1st half units.
At the same time, however, he managed to rank higher in both CN and JP compared to Roxy (60th in JP, 114th in CN) and Billy (43rd in JP, 108th in CN).
This puts Severian somewhere between 2nd half units like Norma (23rd in JP, 85th in CN) or Cissia (20th in JP, 74th in CN) and the worst performing 2nd half units like Billy and Roxy.
Cloud wise, he ranked 161st in CN, higher than Roxy, Norma and Banyue.
On JP Cloud, he ranked 116th, higher than Roxy, Billy and Cissia, but still quite a bit lower than Norma (85th).
He also ranked (midnight rankings), 51st in Hong Kong, 70th in South Korea and 108th in Singapore
Overall, Severian managed to avoid the title of "lowest performing banner" by a fairly comfortable margin, ranking somewhere between the weakest banners in ZZZ's recent history and the more "normal" second half units.
We'll see later in the Qimai section whether the revenue estimates confirm what the rankings suggest.
APPMAGIC:
On AppMagic, Severian came extremely close to making it into the Top 100.
He ranked immediately below Top Lords in the games ranking, which itself ranked 96th in the overall ranking.
This means Severian was probably somewhere around 101st–105th in AppMagic's overall ranking.
Unfortunate.
Still, this is a considerably better performance than Roxy and Billy, and not by a small margin either, considering that both were dozens of positions below the lowest ranked game shown when their banners released.
Once again, this supports what the iOS rankings suggested: a performance somewhere between the "normal" 2nd half banners and the particularly weak ones.
QIMAI:
According to Qimai (CN iOS only), Severian is estimated to have generated $208,000 in his first three days, combining the main app and Cloud app.
This puts him above Roxy ($141,000) and Billy ($155,000)
But below Norma ($226,000) and Banyue ($241,000).
Overall, Qimai once again confirms what the rankings suggested.
Severian performed noticeably better than the weakest 2nd half banners, but still fell short of the more average ones.
FINAL CONCLUSIONS:
Overall, Severian performed somewhere between a "normal" second half banner in ZZZ and the worst performing banners, such as Roxy and Billy.
Considering the, let's say, interesting position he found himself in (between the strongest DPS units in the game and the upcoming Sunbringer and HSR collaboration), I'd say that managing to outperform both Roxy and Billy is a decent result.
That said, none of this changes the objective fact that Severian's banner is the third worst performing banner in ZZZ's recent history in terms of Day 1 performance.
He can have all the excuses in the world, but that fact remains.
In the end though, he will probably end up performing much closer to normal 2nd half units rather than Roxy and Billy because of the usual boost in revenue that banners before void hunters gets, when livestream airs and the week before the new patch.
So don't be surprised if he ends up with a better performance than expected by the end of his banner run.
Well, that's it!
Sorry again for the late (and honestly somewhat barebones) posts, but I really don't have much free time right now.
Once I'm back from my business trip, the usual posting schedule should resume.
The next posts, covering Elyms and Lily, should come out over the next few days.
And as mentioned earlier, I'll also be making a 10 day performance post for Aha, which will include all the available data on her performance, including Day 1.
Thanks for reading!
Check out Derkein’s tracker if you want to follow his performance over time: https://t.co/Zv8j6ZrrmB
He has updated the site with new features like JPY to USD conversion for game.i numbers to make it easier to read, and more, so give it a look.
And as always, remember to be respectful.
#ZZZ
Hi, none of the metrics that I keep track of have him at ZZZ all time low.
That's all I can say for now, the rest is in my analysis post, I really don't have much to say.
If you see people comparing day 1 revenue with full banner revenue, ignore them or try to explain them that these games have a stable flux of income even after the first days.
Which means day 1 is just a part of the full revenue.
He will prob end up above those 2 banners by a decent margin in the tracked metrics.
@Chibi_Jane Hi, sure.
The objective of this account is to compare performance between banners of the same game in set environments.
It doesn't try to give an absolute number to the overall performance.
Just compare him with other bsnners using the same metrics used for the other banners.
Hi, Europe and America have some issues
Europe is really fragmented, making hard to track the performance of the banners.
Us is better.
The other thing is that they are all a minority spending wise.
For example the US is usally the 3rd/4th biggest market for gacha games on mobile, usually competing with South Korea, and even there it usually struggles to surpass 10% of total mobile revenue.
The fact that the games also often rank "low" in the US store makes it harder to evaluate since the games in it fluctuate a lot, compared to Asian markets where the top apps are very consistent.
Since I would have to track much more countries that aren't even that impactful alone (ofc taken together they are), I use the AppMagic ranking for a general evaluation of the overall global performance.
AppMagic contains all the regions and mobile platforms (android and iOS), except CN android.
This makes it useful for global performance evaluation.
If you see a low AppMagic ranking with a decent Asian performance, you can deduce the western markets likely underperformed, and so on.
Argent Flow - Arknights Endfield Day 1 Revenue Performance!
Hi guys, sorry for the late post, but I’ve been very busy over the last few days.
Endfield’s 1.6 2nd half banner was released a few days ago, so let’s see how he performed.
iOS RANKINGS:
Argent Flow ranked 60th in JP and 43rd in CN.
These are unfortunately the lowest rankings for a new unit since the game’s release, below Liino, who ranked 26th in JP and 34th in CN.
Since some people will probably ask, Camille ranked 24th in JP and 31st in CN.
However, the CN Cloud app wasn’t available during his banner, which means that both Liino’s and Argent Flow’s main app rankings are probably a few places lower than they would have been without it.
The drop is especially large in Japan, while in CN, as we’ll see later with Qimai, the difference compared to previous phase 2 banners isn’t very big.
Cloud wise, he ranked 131st in CN, above Liino (145th) and Arcane (133rd).
The Cloud app launched with Arcane, so I’d leave that ranking out of the comparison.
Overall, this isn’t a bad Cloud ranking, considering he ranked above Liino, but we need at least one more phase 2 unit to compare him with.
He also ranked 50th in Taiwan, 62nd in Hong Kong, and 120th in South Korea.
The rankings in Taiwan and Hong Kong are more or less consistent with his CN performance, while South Korea shows a larger drop, similar to JP.
Overall, Argent Flow has the lowest rankings for a new banner since the game’s release.
In CN, however, the drop is fairly small, and, as we’ll see later, his estimated revenue is almost identical to that of recent phase 2 banners. In JP and South Korea, the drop is much larger.
APPMAGIC:
Argent Flow did not enter AppMagic’s overall top 100 on his release day. In the games only chart, Endfield was nine places below the game ranked 99th overall, which, ironically, was the original Arknights.
He probably wasn’t too far from 100th place, since nine games isn’t a huge gap, but he is Endfield’s first new banner to miss AppMagic’s top 100.
The drop in JP probably played a big role here.
QIMAI:
Before discussing Qimai, I want to clarify how I’m attributing the revenue.
Argent Flow is running alongside a Tangtang rerun banner that started before his release.
This means that on some sites, such as game-i, and on the tracker, you’ll see part of the revenue during Argent Flow’s banner attributed to Tangtang.
I generally dislike this approach to overlapping rerun banners because it can attribute revenue to the rerun that it didn’t actually generate. I’m not against splitting revenue when the overlapping banner is substantial and clearly affects the new banner’s day 1 performance and legs, such as a VH running throughout an full ZZZ patch, or an HSR main push etc.
And even then, I tend to not make the split for day 1 performances.
In this case, I don’t think Tangtang’s banner contributed meaningfully to Argent Flow’s performance, and the available data also suggests so.
The game was already below 200th place in all regions when Argent Flow was released.
For this reason, I’ll attribute the full revenue estimated by Qimai over Argent Flow’s first three days to his banner.
If you prefer the split figures, you can find them on the tracker for both Qimai and game-i.
On Qimai (CN iOS only), Argent Flow is estimated to have earned $498,000 over his first three days, combining the main app and Cloud app.
This is again the lowest estimate for a new banner, but it’s fairly close to other recent phase 2 banners: Camille ($507,000) and Liino ($555,000).
Making his performance in CN fairly close to that of previous phase 2 banners.
STEAM:
On Steam, he ranked 66th, below Si’s peak of 60th.
However, Endfield only recently launched on Steam, so we currently have just these two banners to compare him to.
I also wouldn’t put too much weight on Si’s ranking, since launch banners on Steam rarely perform particularly well immediately.
FINAL CONCLUSIONS:
Overall, Argent Flow is shaping up to be Endfield’s weakest performing new banner since launch.
While his CN performance isn’t very different from that of recent 2nd half units, the drop in JP and some other regions is much larger, contributing to him not to entering AppMagic’s top 100.
I don’t expect particularly strong banner legs either, even compared with other 2nd half banners.
That’s it!
Thank you for reading!
Some people have asked why I only report Qimai estimates in my day 1 posts and don’t include game-i.
The answer is that I trust Qimai much more as a source.
I find game-i useful for tracking trends and overall banner performance, which is why I include it in my 10 day analyses, but i don't like its method of estimating daily revenue for day 1 comparisons.
So yes, that’s my choice.
Sorry again for the late post, but I’ve been really busy over the last few days.
Check out Derkein’s tracker if you want to follow his performance over time: https://t.co/Zv8j6ZqTx3
And as always, remember to be respectful.
#ArknightsEndfield
I think male banners are neat.
In the end, it's just a way to make the cast have more variety.
I see no issues with having 1 or 2 once in a while.
Without them I wouldn't have my favourite ZZZ unit (Banyue).
And mind you, I have M6 remielle, it's not like I don't like female banners ahahaha.
Hi! It's a timezone issue related to your device.
Qimai usually updates its estimated revenue for the previous day around two hours after midnight in China.
However, if your timezone is behind China's (which it probably is) and you are a day behind, Qimai may display that revenue under the previous date on the chart.
For example, when I open Qimai on my device, I see a first spike on November 4th, followed by the main spike on November 5th, and so on.
However, that first spike on the 4th actually represents the revenue for November 5th, while the second spike represents November 6th.
The revenue on the 5th is lower than on the 6th because Qimai also takes into account how many hours an app remains at the top of the rankings, among other factors.
This happens with all games. Sometimes Qimai also shifts revenue estimates to the following day, but that doesn't change the overall total.
You can verify this by checking the downloadable CSV file containing the revenue data for that period. The $86,188 shown on November 4th in the chart is actually recorded as November 5th's revenue in the CSV.
This means I used the revenue from November 5th, 6th, and 7th, not November 4th, 5th, and 6th.
The third image is a screen I took on Qimai using my phone after changing the timezone to CST.
As you can see the 4th became 5th.
Mitya - Genshin Impact Day 1 Revenue Performance!
Hi guys!
Genshin 7.2 released a few days ago, so let’s see how the newest banner, Mitya, performed.
Just as a disclaimer, I'm currently only using data from version 6.0 onwards in my comparisons, I'll try to add more data in the future.
iOS RANKINGS:
Mitya ranked 6th in CN and 12th in Japan.
While in CN that's a pretty good ranking, on par with the average Genshin banner in China, in Japan it's fairly low, tying Flins as the lowest ranking banner in Japan since 6.0.
This may sound like a huge deal, but we're talking about differences of just 1/2 ranks, so nothing particularly significant. For example, Linnea ranked 11th, while Zhibai and Odette ranked 10th.
Cloud wise, he ranked 41st, which is pretty high for Genshin, with Mitya managing to rank above most 6.x units except Columbina, Sandrone, and Nicole. However, he remains below the other two 7.x units released so far (Odette ranked 37th and V&V ranked 28th).
He also ranked 8th in Hong Kong, 9th in Singapore, and 12th in the Philippines.
Overall, pretty average rankings for Mitya, with Japan being the weakest market (of course relative to other releases performances in Japan).
Even there, though, it's not like his ranking was abysmally low, just slightly below average.
As for CN, the changes to the ranking algorithm could have impacted his placement a bit, so we'll see in the Qimai section how he is estimated to have actually performed over there.
APPMAGIC:
On AppMagic, he ranked 13th, which is, again, pretty average.
He lands right among the other units that neither outperformed nor underperformed.
For comparison, he ranked one position higher than Linnea (14th) and one lower than Varka (12th). And as I always say, such small differences in rankings don't really tell us much.
The lowest ranking units since 6.0 are Lauma (22nd), Flins (20th), and Lohen (20th).
QIMAI:
On Qimai (CN iOS only), Mitya is estimated to have earned $3,357,000 over his first three days (main app + cloud app).
For Genshin units, this is, again, pretty average, placing him between Lauma ($3,100,000) and Nicole ($3,646,000).
However, for first half units, it's actually kinda low, with only Lauma and Durin performing worse than him (all the other units below him are second half units), and honestly I don't see his banner legs be very good in the future.
FINAL CONCLUSIONS:
Overall, Mitya's performance was pretty average, maybe slightly below (compared to other 1st half units) for Genshin across almost all the metrics we can track, with Japan being the only market where he performed clearly below average.
I really don't have much more to say.
Genshin remains pretty consistent in terms of recent performance, with only Lohen standing out as a recent "bad" performance (and even he is on par with the 6.0 units).
We'll see how Anastasya performs in 7.3. I'm very interested in seeing her results.
And as I said at the start, I'll also try to put together more past data for Genshin (maybe I'll add 4.x and 5.x too) when I have some time before 7.3 drops.
That should help make future Genshin analyses more interesting and complete.
Thanks for reading!
I'll post Argent Flow's analysis tomorrow.
Check out Derkein’s tracker if you want to follow his performance over time:
https://t.co/Zv8j6ZrrmB
And as always, remember to be respectful.
#GenshinImpact
@JDS_games Unfortunately I just can't know how many players changed spending habits, I woulx love to.
I'll probably keep comparing Genshin banners with others at max 2 cycles of diff (6.x-7.x) etc
I'll put a disclaimer about JP rankings again, like I usually did.
Fist half units in Genshin have a very stable level of performance thanks to monthlies abd BPs resets.
Being one influences the performance by a non negligible amount.
It is like this for a lot of games, almost all of them.
As for the comparison with Chasca, unfortunately I don't have pre 6.0 data ready yet, and that is my fault.
As I say multiple times in the post, I'll add at least 4.x and 5.x data soon.
Hi.
Flins had a slightly below average day 1 but pretty good banner lega making him probably more or less on par with banners that released with him.
Game-i also suggests so.
As for the ownership rates.
1) Ownership =/= revenue, I don't I need to explain why is that so.
Ofc most of the time they follow a similar trend but sometimes they aren't.
2) I can't use ownership rates on a third party app as a mean of revenue estimation because I just can't.
Lack of information about accounts, where they are taken from and from what region.
Ofc if Hoyo, or any company with games that I cover on this account, ever releases official ownership stats I would add that data immediately
@hudartss I kinda expected him to be on this level, especially considering Genshin extremely high base level for 1st half units thanks to the BPs and monthlies.
If I had more data I would have done a comparison with past "pre archon" units but unforrunately I just don't have it ready.
To be fair, patch before is different compared to banner before.
I generally put a disclaimer if a banner is the one before a main push unit ot if it's between 2 very hype units.
I didn't consider V&V ones but if you do or if it's the general consensus to, sure.
And I dont like making distinctions/different standards between male and female banners.
I also have a bit too little data for Genshin unfortunately right now (only 6.0 onwards) but I'll try to fix that soon.
In the end, his performance is kinda average in almost all the metrics so I think it's fair to say he performed average for recent Genshin banners.