@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra 6/6
Are artists scared? Its complicated. AI could be an awesome tool in the right context. Its the profiteering, lack of ethical considerations and undermining of real people’s ability to support themselves thats the issue.
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra There’s a big difference between an artist doing a study and some random company taking work, bunging it in a program then charging others for the privilege of typing in a prompt.
Studies are a tool for learning a craft and developing your own skills.
(You bed theres more:)
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra 5/? Art is a learned skill, the only barrier to entry is the time and effort someone is willing or able to put into learning and practicing.
So it can’t even realistically be argued that artists are gatekeeping the ability to produce art because we’re really not.
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra (3/?) and take on any given technique or subject.
The issue with using artists names and recreating their style is that it then creates ‘brand’ confusion and artists having to compete with something assumed to be their work. And that’s just plain shitty.
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra But its also unethical for a learning artist to then turn around and claim a study as their own original work. That shit doesn’t fly either.
No one exists in a vacuum, and there will always be influence from existing work but an artist brings their own interpretations (2/?)
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra 4/4 all that isn’t even touching on the dishonesty of trying to pass off AI as your own work and selling it. There are way to use AI images to get ideas and inspo but just typing in a prompt then printing it isn’t remotely the same thing as art.
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra The issue isn’t the tech itself, it’s the lack of ethics in how it’s trained. The data sets they use contain millions of pieces of work that they don’t have permission to use and the original artists have no say in the matter and aren’t compensated in any way.
1/?
@ecutruin@head_plank@duffy_colt3250@JonLamArt@Comic_Con@WGAWest@sagaftra 2/? The ‘opt out’ system is a joke too, you can’t un-train the program once the data is in there.
Artists also have their names used as prompts to deliberately imitate their work, this can create confusion and has been used maliciously against artists like @samdoesarts etc
Whoops… I keep forgetting this hellhole exists. Have some Seele :D love my girl who carried me through HI3 but dang her colour palette is an odd one to work with.
#HonkaiStarRail#HSRFanart#seele#honkaistarrailfanart
The Secret Invasion Intro’s Ai tech they hired has a large body of Stable Diffusion work. If they used SD on the intro it traces back to the Laion Database. The Laion that is being sued by a photographer that wanted to opt out. Also SD being sued by Getty and a Class action.