Gul Bab

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

/Kashmir 🍁

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

❤️

[Shaykh Azhar Nasser @ShaykhAzhar]

Imam Ali summarizes the entire religion of Islam in one sentence.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@Unseen12422 @rizbrkhan @ahadsoab @RedAlRafidhi @shraakpuchh @Pandaa5r5o @untoldwords_11 "These are my Ahlul Bayt." (Sahih Muslim, Tirmidhi, Musnad Ahmad).
Wives are honored as Ummuhat al-Mu'minin, but Ayat al-Tathir's purified Ahlul Bayt are the People of the Cloak. Context matters but so does the Prophet's own tafsir.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@Unseen12422 @rizbrkhan @ahadsoab @RedAlRafidhi @shraakpuchh @Pandaa5r5o @untoldwords_11 And your own Sunni books narrate Hadith al-Kisa: the Prophet ﷺ gathered Ali, Fatimah, Hasan, and Husayn under the cloak and said,

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan In 33:33 the pronouns move from feminine plural to masculine plural Shia tafsir sees that shift, alongside the Hadith al-Kisa, as indicating Ahl al-Bayt Muhammad (PBUH, Ali, Fatimah, Hasan, and Husayn. Fatimah is included by the Prophet's own designation, not excluded by grammar.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan Our argument isn't that women are excluded from the Qur'an's grammar. It's that Qur'anic Arabic shifts for rhetorical reasons.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan If aid alone ended occupation, Palestine would've been free long ago.

Saudi Arabia 🙄

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan "Laser edits" don't explain why Israel treats Hezbollah, Hamas, and Islamic Jihad as military threats rather than hashtags. Iran's argument has never been that speeches alone liberate Palestine it claims deterrence and armed resistance matter more than normalization.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan As for Syria and Iraq, Iran's position was that Soleimani fought ISIS and defended the Axis of Resistance, not that the conflict was a simple "Sunni vs Shia" war. You can reject Tehran's policies but don't rewrite its stated role in the region.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan Calling Palestine taqiyyah ignores decades of material support to Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Hezbollah, and the Palestinian cause while many governments normalized with Israel.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

and when so much oppression and cruelty were happening on Palestine, where were you then? Now that so much violence is being inflicted upon these Saudi Salafis, these Salafis are burning now.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

Just as they are blowing up these propagandas, and whoever claims to be Salafi saying they are the ones following the religion of Prophet Muhammad they are being shown: what kind of love did you show for Palestine,

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan The Qur'an condemns oppressors; we don't suspend moral judgment when history is this clear. Justice is part of faith.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@rizbrkhan Respectfully, this isn't about calling Yazid a Sahabi or a Prophet. The man who led the state during Karbala bears responsibility for the murder of Imam Husayn (AS), the Prophet's grandson.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@still_light9 Bin jabar lu lu kulu! 🤣

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

When I used to study at SP College, a Salafi friend also studied there with me, and he used to say to me: 'You talk about the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), peace and blessings be upon him and his progeny, Imam Ali, peace be upon him,

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

Imam Hussain, peace be upon him, Imam Hasan Mujtaba, peace be upon him, and this tradition continues all the way up to the twelfth Imam. Tell me this: why don't you talk about Yazid in your Majalis? He also made an Islamic State and worked on an Islamic system.'

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@Unseen12422 The difference is methodological, not a refusal to engage with history.

[Gul Bab @Gulbab1911]

@Unseen12422 So this is not circular reasoning; it is applying the same principle Shi'a scholars use for all narrations: a solitary report, even with respected transmitters, is not accepted if its content conflicts with stronger Qur'anic and established evidence.