I just submitted an op-ed on this to Washington Post, discussing how technology cannot substitute human accountability. We must have transparency, or all the new rules and reviews create more opportunities for interference. With all due respect to one of the best referees in history I have to confront this assessment. It was technically BEFORE the goal in absolute time but not IMMEDIATELY before. It's quite a stretch of the normal logic to directly connect an accident near the goal area of one team to the action on the opposite side of the field. And since there was no arbiter's whistle to stop the game (wrong decision, agreed!), this violation cannot justify the decision to disallow the goal. And regarding the second incident in question, you are again correct stating that there was no violation of the rules against Salah, but this conclusion is reached after careful examination of the video footage from various angles. The referee during the game could not instantly verify it and considering the similarities of these two cases HAD to go to the monitor to confirm the assessment. By not doing so he simply reiterated our understanding that the game is being run by anonymous partisans behind the screens.
Egyptian coach invoking anti-racism gesture without any context of racism would be detrimental to actual victims of racism in football. Such acts, if persist in the future, alongside the symbolism would be lost in the oblivion.
It was one of the best refereeing performance I’ve seen in recent times, until I came on social media and seeing all the unsubstantiated rigging allegations.
🚨 Luis de la Fuente: “I honestly don't understand why you ask me about the controversy surrounding the referee in the Argentina vs. Egypt match. Where did that even come from? I watched the game and I thought the referee got everything right. I’d actually like to congratulate him because every decision he made was spot on.” @DAZN_ES 🇦🇷🇪🇬
Social media induced tribalism and ‘us vs them’ fights rarely leaves room for reasonable insight that can be inferred. This toxicity has reached highest levels in recent days.
You can say Messi’s indifference is morally questionable so does of every footballer on the planet earth (Lamine is exception), but accusations based on self-concocted perceptions to advocate carnal-soul’s agendas is deeply problematic.
I think the main issue is not simply the Ronaldo fans - but the coordinated campaign, by even otherwise intelligent people, which is forcing ties to Israel when Messi has no strong official position in favour of either sides.