No matter what MMT tries to claim the real tax is paid when gov spends, by transfer of goods and service from private to public.
The rest is just funding.
If gov issue money and the money gets its value from taxation then its the tax payer.
If the issue more, then devaluation.
Cullen Roche blows up the Neo Soviet #MMT political movement masquerading as economics, claiming that the Gov "funds you" if only you vote for the right politicians who will enrich us all with endless gov debt.
There is no Moscow Money Tree that will give you a free lunch!
It used to be ultimate settlement in gold. They defaulted on that and nothing changed.
The usefulness of bank deposits is that others accept them for payment, not that they can be exchanged for Fed reserves.
And banks can settle without reserves being involved at all.
After all, banks have settled between themselves since long beforehand Fed existed. And most settlement is still outside reserves.
Modern Monetary Theory is wrong and does not grasp the difference between fiscal policy and monetary policy. In consequence it misleads those who follow MMT.
The Central Bank’s MONETARY POLICY manages the quantity of money in the economy through Open Market Operations. This is buying debt which adds new money and selling back debt which withdraws money from the economy. QE and QT are transparent versions of this process. This quantity of money can be managed irrespective of whether the government spends more, less or even nothing at all.
The government’s FISCAL POLICY is how it finances its spending and whether it budgets for a deficit, surplus or balances its budget has no effect on the quantity of money in the economy except under one special case.
If the government overspends its budget and cannot sell all of its debt then some is left unsold at the Central Bank. The money is spent and claims are settled by the Central Bank printing new money to the value of that debt.
The main pillar of Modern Monetary Theory is that government spending creates new money and taxation destroys it. This is totally wrong as this process just redistributes money that is already in circulation.
Please pass this on to MMT and all its followers.
Private economic power is constantly challenged by competition.
The average time a company remains in the S&P 500 has fallen from around 33 years in 1965 to just 15 years today.
Established companies are constantly being challenged and displaced by newcomers. This is Schumpeter’s creative destruction.
Unlike governments, companies cannot simply legislate away their competitors or compel customers to buy their products.
The real danger is when political power protects private interests from competition.
Banks create deposits in more ways than only loans.
A medium of exchange and a claim are not mutually exclusive.
Money functions as a medium of exchange precisely because it gives its holder purchasing power over goods and services produced by others.
It is a financial claim on real wealth, not real wealth itself. Issuing more claims does not automatically create more wealth.
@BJChippindale Money is issued by banks and is used as claims on goods and services.
The more you issue, the more claims for the same goods and services.
This is the factual reality.
@TyKeynes Not to mention manufacturers of tractors. They have obliterated work in agriculture. Used to employ 97% of workers.
Eliminated their salaries and then offered them carrots and potatoes all year round. Horrible.
Ban tractors.
@NewnhamTony@IsabellaMWeber Democracy means citizens control their government, not that government controls every economic decision.
Private property, free markets and individual economic freedom are not threats to democracy.
Concentrating economic and political power in the state is a far greater threat.
@FrenchTwist4@00592c@MMTmacrotrader For thousands of years it has been known that governments can print money to pay their debt.
History is filled with examples.
Not a MMT discovery.
@MMTUK_PRG UK has all time high government spending, all time high deficit, all time high taxation, all time high government debt.
So anyone who wanted more government can be happy
As explained, banks could settle everything without reserves if they so desire.
Fedwire, the Fed’s gross settlement system for reserves, processes about 217 million transfers a year. The U.S. economy makes over 236 billion card, ACH and check payments a year. That’s roughly 1,000 deposit payments for every reserve transfer. ONE THOUSAND TO ONE.