The Inclusive Framework has just released Administrative Guidance with respect to the GloBE Rules (Pillar 2). The AG includes rules to prevent the use of Hybrid Arbitrage Arrangements to artificially qualify for the Transitional CbCR Safe Harbour.
(https://t.co/9ON6qPDey8).
@goodtaxtakes Is that surprising? Isn’t the logic that if the government is paying the amount regardless of the tax position then it’s a lot like a grant and less like a tax incentive - but if it’s ‘less secure’ in the sense of dependent on tax position, it’s more like a tax cut.
The AG was released only two days ago. Accordingly, this analysis is preliminary and does not purport to be comprehensive.
As always, any comments/corrections would be gratefully received.
Two days ago, the Inclusive Framework released Administrative Guidance (AG) on the GloBE Rules. I have released a preliminary analysis addressing the impact of the AG with respect to the QDMTT and the treatment of GILTI under the GloBE Rules.
https://t.co/qP2Fhiaps5.
There are three appendices that show:
1) the priority rule order between taxes under the GloBE Rules;
2) a step-by-step worked example of the interaction between GILTI and the GloBE Rules; and
3) an example showing the incentives on states adopting the QDMTT
Letter to the Editor: @Heydonwb explains how the essence of the UTPR is broad recognition by a critical mass of states in the international community through their lawmaking institutions. https://t.co/nCHYvLG3BR
Up to date and in depth analysis of the OECD’s Two Pillar Solution proposals from leading experts with editorial by John Vella - US perspective from @InternationlTax; EU (Ana Paula Dourado); Bezan Salehy; @Heydonwb ; Chris Noonan and Victoria Plekhanova. On Westlaw now.
For those following Pillar 2, I have released a new @OxfordTax working paper - ‘State Strategic Responses to the GloBE Rules’.
https://t.co/sOIOOwPgBF 1/n
The paper goes on to consider what responses to the above strategies could be considered either multilaterally (through the Inclusive Framework) or through the unilateral adoption of strategic countermeasures. 7/n
@taxleonard@JulianFeiner@ajayrotti@DanNeidle That could be a very large shelter. Also Re: simplicity, important to recall that we’re only dealing with entities in scope for P1. We should have different complexity concerns for MNEs with more than €20B turnover as opposed to €750m turnover.
@taxleonard@JulianFeiner@ajayrotti@DanNeidle Not sure if it says anywhere (so I don’t know). My concern with the method you mention is that it would blend high tax market jurisdiction taxes with low tax ceding jurisdiction taxes. Maintains an incentive for low taxes in ceding jurisdictions. Others may not think this is bad!
@delaFeriaR Or are they saying, we predict £X more investment in the UK as a result of reduced tax competition and that will result in £Y more regular corporation tax. (Obviously timing is important here).
@delaFeriaR Thanks Rita! This is very helpful. I’m still not quite sure what it means (particularly with the first sentence reference to a ‘static costing’). For instance, are they just taking into account behavioural changes in terms of how much IIR/QDMTT is raised?