AI Will Never Replace the Gray-Haired Mentor on Your Shop Floor
And Here’s Why…
By: Bill May
AI can crunch a million data points in seconds. It still can’t tell a junior tech why a 0.003″ tolerance drift killed last quarter’s margins.
The interaction between AI, Knowledge, Wisdom and Mentoring are subjects worthy of additional analysis.
Intelligence-Knowledge-Wisdom
AI and its impact on everything seem to have an omnipresence in media today. Data Centers, education, training, employment levels, competitiveness, GDP and human psychological stability all seem to be impacted by Artificial Intelligence (AI).
It is imperative that we take a step back, analyze what is happening and take some of the anxiety out of this subject.
Utilizing some AI myself, let’s start with this:
Intelligence, Knowledge, and Wisdom: These three concepts are often discussed together but represent distinct aspects of human cognition and capability.
Intelligence:
The ability to learn, reason, solve problems, adapt to new situations, and process information quickly and effectively. It’s raw cognitive horsepower.
The engine of a car (power and speed).
Knowledge:
The accumulation of facts, information, theories, and experiences. It’s what you know.
The fuel in the tank (what powers action).
Wisdom:
The application of knowledge with insight, judgment, ethics, and foresight. It’s knowing when and how to use what you know.
The driver (who steers toward the right destination).
Why AI Can’t Do Wisdom
It is likely that Artificial Intelligence can and will lead to Artificial Knowledge, but highly unlikely, I would say impossible, to lead to Artificial Wisdom. As a matter of fact, if you search for “Artificial Wisdom” on an AI platform, this is a typical result:
Artificial Intelligence (AI) cannot equate to wisdom—not in the full human sense—and likely never will, even with unbounded scaling of intelligence or knowledge.
Yudkowsky’s breakdown of why, structured around the core components of wisdom and AI’s fundamental limits.
These five limits explain why AI alone leaves money on the table in manufacturing.
Wisdom Requires Lived Experience & Subjective Consciousness
Wisdom Involves Ethical Judgment Beyond Optimization
Wisdom Transcends Knowledge & Intelligence
Can AI Ever “Grow” Wisdom?
Even if AI simulates aging, relationships, or “regret” in a virtual world, it remains performance, not experience.
(Originates from a post on X (formerly Twitter) by user @ESYudkowsky)
So what does this all mean?
In simple terms, for Artificial Intelligence to be useful it must be coupled with Human Wisdom. AI can allow us to process data and information quicker but in itself cannot provide wisdom. No machine has provided wisdom yet—because wisdom still travels mouth-to-ear on the shop floor.
Mentoring = Wisdom Transmission
Mentoring is a developmental relationship in which a more experienced or knowledgeable individual (the mentor) provides guidance, support, advice, and feedback to a less experienced person (the mentee) to help them grow personally and professionally.
So how does someone transmit “wisdom” to another person? In my experience in the manufacturing world it is via Mentoring.
How HVM Does It
Our mission since our founding nearly 15 years ago has been to provide highly-experienced consultancy services focused on delivering profitable manufacturing performance based on quality products, improved throughput, and cost-effective operations. Mentoring is one of those skill sets.
The operative phrase in our mission, as with wisdom, is highly-experienced.
The transition from Intelligence to Knowledge to Wisdom is through human experience.
When you work with our contractors you will find is an abundance of human manufacturing wisdom…..that is why AI does not frighten us. It is merely another tool in our very large toolbox. Our 11+1 Quality Management Strategies utilized numerous times to resolve quality and throughput issues with our clients is an example.
Likewise, at HVM we have the necessary skill sets to mentor your less experienced employees. That in essence is how AI will help your organization; when you find a means to convert AI into applicable Wisdom. In the end, AI accelerates intelligence and knowledge, but mentoring unlocks wisdom. At HVM, we’re bridging that gap—turning your data into profitable decisions.
What’s one way you’re blending AI insights with mentor guidance?
Reply below or email.
Let’s chat: [email protected]
Did you enjoy this blog? Search our blog library for other topics of interest: https://t.co/bbtAoBjrzV
Does your manufacturing organization have the “critical mass” to grow?
As the manufacturing sector recovers, the challenge is growing the workforce, especially the leadership team.
**Issue: Vacancies or Inexperience**
Many manufacturing plants face a shortage of skilled employees in Operations, Engineering, Quality, and Supply Chain. The leadership team’s “critical mass” often hinders plant operations while hiring and training new staff. Even filled positions may lack capability due to inexperience, leading to performance issues in daily operations and new product launches.
HVM has helped clients by temporarily filling leadership roles (for 6 months or less), identifying permanent replacements, and mentoring new hires. HVM provides experienced Manufacturing Engineers and Managers to support daily operations. With 25+ years of experience, HVM’s contractors can replace, mentor, and train 5–7 new graduates or less-experienced employees.
**Hands-On Impact / Mentorship**
HVM contractors perform daily functions of unfilled positions, mentor less-experienced staff, and support hiring by interviewing and vetting candidates. After onboarding, they provide on-the-job training (OJT) for new hires. Specific tasks include:
1. Perform duties for open Operations, Production Control, Logistics, Engineering, Quality, Facilities, and Maintenance roles.
2. Collaborate with Plant Leadership to prioritize tasks.
3. Address gaps in engineering, scheduling, and maintenance to improve throughput.
4. Enhance manufacturing process capability and quality to boost daily output.
5. Execute a six-step process:
- Perform duties of open positions.
- Mentor existing staff.
- Develop/verify job descriptions and skill requirements.
- Vet and interview candidates.
- Mentor and train new employees.
- Document and institutionalize processes.
- Provide monthly mentoring check-ups (2 days/month).
Let HVM address your operational challenges.
There are several indicators of U.S. manufacturing resurgence. Optimism is emerging for a potential recovery. Yet, a key challenge remains in growing and equipping the workforce. Here's our take: https://t.co/0S64oogqPm
Most of us small business owners do not have a difficult time realizing that we need to improve our business.
Typically, we can easily identify when our profit margins are insufficient; we can sense from negative feedback when ou…https://t.co/KAaJuBiwG8 https://t.co/Zl2sAyMvpp
I just returned from another insightful event sponsored by the Association for Corporate Growth: 2023 Mid-South Capital Connections in Louisville, KY. I was asked: What is a manufacturing company doing HERE?
It has been a common q…https://t.co/5wwxAqTvty https://t.co/aNH0hporV3
My experience in the manufacturing industry has taken me into plants all over the world: Automotive plants, Aerospace plants, Defense industry plants, Home Appliance manufacturing plants, consumer products plants, and many others.…https://t.co/Hm0zbbSWTd https://t.co/IHDQcwubnk
It is common that a business owner’s valuation of his own company may be higher than that of a prospective buyer. The phrase “mind the gap” offers a unique warning for those of us who have bought or sold businesses, as well as for…https://t.co/VsieMN5kV2 https://t.co/JA4Uw2iWHv
"Improving supply chain resiliency and having more control over the value stream to better manage the inbound material flow and traceability" are primary reasons for in-sourcing. #sourcing#onshoring#supplychain https://t.co/xB8JoODzYK
A great summary of what makes a good manufacturing team. Check out HVMC's Quick Value Tool (QVT) to assess where your manufacturing plant compares to the best plants in North America. #manufacturing#continuousimprovementculture https://t.co/4zoVhx6Ux8
Very informative article on Plant Construction speed. Also need quick process development, process validation and production launch to complete the cycle for timely implementation.
#construction#manufacturing#onshoring https://t.co/o2H5JXTFmc
A manufacturer cannot simply ignore negative supplier relationships, especially when they impede production. Rather than fearfully “whistling past the graveyard” and ignoring dysfunction, our experienced team recommends implementin…https://t.co/1a0L5WKwj4 https://t.co/5zQlW9exP6
Mr. Moser is right on point. My clients in the Manufacturing sector are positioning themselves for the renewal ahead. #manufacturing#onshoring https://t.co/qJwtJpmH8c
Proud to share a client testimonial that tells the story of our Win-Win approach.
HVM recently heard from a client one year after our engagement to perform an operational assessment and recommend performance improvements for a str…https://t.co/e4eD0G0vFT https://t.co/oCgQxW2XY1