Shiva Preetham Sharma

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai And why don't you have the balls to respond to me by explaining how AIT is accurate and valid? Maybe because you do not possess the intellectual capacity to do so.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai I could level the same allegations against the sources that claim AIT is true, accusing them of being Hinduphobic and of subscribing to the "white man's burden" narrative. The foundation of AIT was laid by a literal colonialist, Max Müller. Grow up.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai I could level the same allegations against the sources that claim AIT is true, accusing them of being Hinduphobic and of subscribing to the "white man's burden" narrative. The foundation of AIT was laid by a literal colonialist, Max Müller. Grow up.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai There are many historians who have debunked AIT with equal fervour. Read the works of Shiv Shastry, B. B. Lal, Michel Danino, Koenraad Elst, and Shrikant G. Talageri. Are you going to dismiss all of these works as those of "Sanghis"? Brainless clown.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai There are many historians who have debunked AIT with equal fervour. Read the works of Shiv Shastry, B. B. Lal, Michel Danino, Koenraad Elst, and Shrikant G. Talageri. Are you going to dismiss all of these works as those of "Sanghis"? Brainless clown.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai What exactly do you mean by "accepted by linguists and historians"? Explain what is accepted and on what basis. Have you ever researched AIT? Do you even understand how to research a topic and arrive at a conclusion? Explain AIT to me in a nutshell using undisputed facts.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@rickpunchman @239undefined @BabonesBhai What exactly do you mean by "accepted by linguists and historians"? Explain what is accepted and on what basis. Have you ever researched AIT? Do you even understand how to research a topic and arrive at a conclusion? Explain AIT to me in a nutshell using undisputed facts.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@Iam4awareness @BabonesBhai @grok "If everyone is doing it, it can't be wrong."

There are many works that debunk AIT. Read the works of B. B. Lal, Shiv Shastry, and Michel Danino (The Lost River), all of which are extensively researched and scientifically backed. Understand that AIT is a colonial construct.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@239undefined @BabonesBhai You illiterate idiot.

Geology, history, genetics, linguistic history, and colonial constructs are studied through hard evidence, not by arguing that milk intolerance proves AIT. Do you understand what this means? Argue with facts and hard evidence.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@239undefined @BabonesBhai You illiterate idiot.

Geology, history, genetics, linguistic history, and colonial constructs are studied through hard evidence, not by arguing that milk intolerance proves AIT. Do you understand what this means? Argue with facts and hard evidence.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@Iam4awareness @BabonesBhai Of course, it is when dumbfounded individuals like you lack the requisite knowledge or humility to admit that you do not possess sufficient subject knowledge that you divert the discussion. Stick to the point. We can debate the above issues when they are being discussed.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@Iam4awareness @BabonesBhai Of course, it is when dumbfounded individuals like you lack the requisite knowledge or humility to admit that you do not possess sufficient subject knowledge that you divert the discussion. Stick to the point. We can debate the above issues when they are being discussed.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@Iam4awareness @BabonesBhai @grok "If everyone is doing it, it can't be wrong."

There are many works that debunk AIT. Read the works of B. B. Lal, Shiv Shastry, and Michel Danino (The Lost River), all of which are extensively researched and scientifically backed. Understand that AIT is a colonial construct.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

Many Indians(many on the right) want to see @ShashiTharoor as EAM. His policies, rooted in ideological fallacies, are dangerous. His recent views on diplomacy with Pakistan and his position on the Ukraine proxy war reveal his idealistic view of the world (there are many such eg).

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

Many Indians(many on the right) want to see @ShashiTharoor as EAM. His policies, rooted in ideological fallacies, are dangerous. His recent views on diplomacy with Pakistan and his position on the Ukraine proxy war reveal his idealistic view of the world (there are many such eg).

[Kanwal Sibal @KanwalSibal]

Arguing that India should accept dual nationality, citing numerous cases of Bollywood actors carrying foreign passports, his own son and
actor Imran Khan’s case is a superficial view as it
overlooks serious issues

That the heart of these individuals and the diaspora bats for India is questionable and if in many cases they carry foreign passports for convenience of travel etc. that says it all about their mentality.

Here are the serious issues involved:,

Article of the Indian Constitution explicitly forbids holding Indian and foreign citizenship at the same time. A Constitutional revision will be required.

Section 9 of The Citizenship Act, 1955enforces this constitutional rule.

Post partition there was need to establish clear, undivided national boundaries and prevent ambiguity over who belonged to India versus newly formed Pakistan.

Also preventing divided allegiance and to ensure that citizens—and especially future political leaders—did not hold competing allegiances to former colonial powers or neighboring states.

That concern remains. 

National Security and Governance Concerns are real.

There are intelligence and espionage risks. Dual nationality complicates background checks and counter-intelligence. Allowing individuals with foreign state loyalties to hold sensitive government jobs, military positions, or public office presents major security risks.

Dual citizenship can create legal loopholes for individuals accused of financial fraud or criminal offences to evade Indian law enforcement.

Managing tax obligations, property ownership laws, and foreign exchange rules for millions of dual citizens would create severe administrative friction. Dual status could be exploited to bypass domestic financial restrictions or create tax loopholes.

India has one of the largest overseas diasporas in the world. Granting full voting rights and domestic political influence to tens of millions of non-resident dual citizens could drastically skew local elections .

Managing dual nationals requires intricate legal coordination regarding taxation, military conscription, and diplomatic protection. Current administrative systems are not designed to track dual legal obligations for millions of diaspora members. @ShashiTharoor

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@Iam4awareness @BabonesBhai You are a prime example of how India's education system has failed to foster logical reasoning and first-principles thinking. Go ahead and cite the scientific studies that substantiate your claim or STFU.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@Iam4awareness @BabonesBhai You are a prime example of how India's education system has failed to foster logical reasoning and first-principles thinking. Go ahead and cite the scientific studies that substantiate your claim or STFU.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@BabonesBhai There’s ample archaeological evidence of horses in Bharat well before 1500 BC, such as the prehistoric Bhimbetka cave horse (look into this). There’s also geological and historical evidence of the Saraswati river in her prime about 3000 BC. Study AIT carefully before commenting.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@BabonesBhai There’s ample archaeological evidence of horses in Bharat well before 1500 BC, such as the prehistoric Bhimbetka cave horse (look into this). There’s also geological and historical evidence of the Saraswati river in her prime about 3000 BC. Study AIT carefully before commenting.

[Shiva Preetham Sharma @ICON3C]

@BabonesBhai Which independent and unbiased DNA studies are you referring to when you claim there was ‘no genetic mixing’? Or have you conducted such studies yourself? If so, what were your findings? Release them.