Owner/Station Manager of The Pure Pop Pub, a free online power pop/indie pop radio station on the Live365 platform.
Free spirit. Free speech. Free thinker.
You can also find The Pure Pop Pub on the Live365 App! Download it wherever you get your apps and you will have access to a ton of great Internet Radio. #powerpop#indiepop#britpop#americana
@OnlyCardsFans How? I can see the results from other leagues. You are convinced that cannot happen in baseball. Why not? The only players I see "losing" are the $700M contracts that fans loathe.
"They're lying" isn't an answer. It's a knee jerk reflex.
@OnlyCardsFans What also annoys me is the current "split" isn't really a split because all it sets is the luxury tax threshold which no team HAS to exceed. They literally are not losing anything tangible. We are setting a new baseline in a new system.
@OnlyCardsFans And I'm saying the owner proposal can be negotiated to address concerns with how the split is accounted., just like in other pro sports. Why exactly should baseball be different anyway?
@Nina_Power_ I do like the post apocalyptic vision of streams of refugees crowding the roads north in an attempt to reach the fabled land of Liverpool.
@OnlyCardsFans Your scenario is MLB revenue declining 15% every year? Post COVID the NBA contracts paid 92 to 98 percent, and the NHL from 96 to 106%. Sure bargain over the revenue accounting for the split, but your scenarios seem rather unlikely.
Yeah, but raising the MLB minimum, making free agency kick in a year earlier, AND making all teams spend to the floor will all be things that would help the median player. Those are all in the Owners proposal.
I asked GROK a simple "what trends can we see in MLB free agency signings over the last five years" and it responded:
The clearest trend over the last ~5 years (roughly the 2021-22 through 2025-26 offseasons) has been a sharp escalation at the very top of the free-agent market: longer contracts, higher total values, and higher average annual values (AAVs) for elite players, alongside a widening gap between stars and everyone else.
Key Trends
Record-breaking total values and AAVs for stars: The biggest deals have grown dramatically. Examples include:Shohei Ohtani: 10 years, $700 million (Dodgers, 2023-24 offseason; effective AAV lower due to massive deferrals).
Juan Soto: 15 years, $765 million (Mets, 2024-25 offseason).
Aaron Judge: 9 years, $360 million (Yankees).
Corey Seager: 10 years, $325 million (Rangers).
Yoshinobu Yamamoto: 12 years, $325 million (Dodgers). Earlier standouts like Gerrit Cole (9/$324M) or Max Scherzer’s short high-AAV deal set the stage, but the last few years pushed total guarantees and top AAVs into new territory (Soto at $51M AAV, Judge at $40M, Ohtani’s effective numbers among the highest).
Longer contracts for top talent: Decade-plus deals have become far more common for young/elite free agents (Soto 15 years, Ohtani 10, Yamamoto 12, Trea Turner 11, Xander Bogaerts 11, etc.). Teams often stretch length to lower the AAV (which matters for luxury-tax calculations) while securing the player long-term. This accelerated notably in the early 2020s.
Bifurcation of the market: Analysis of dollars-per-projected-WAR shows top free agents (roughly 2+ WAR) receiving relatively higher pay compared to mid- and lower-tier players in recent years. The premium for stars has increased, while average free agents have seen more modest deals. One FanGraphs breakdown of recent offseasons highlights this widening gap between the top tier and everyone else.
Spending concentration: A small group of clubs (especially the Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, and more recently the Blue Jays) account for a large share of free-agent dollars. This has widened the competitive-balance discussion heading into CBA negotiations. Total free-agent guarantees have frequently reached or exceeded $3 billion in stronger offseasons, driven heavily by the mega-deals.
Structural variety: Alongside the ultra-long deals, some players (particularly pitchers or those seeking flexibility) have taken shorter, high-AAV contracts with opt-outs. Deferrals have also become more prominent in the largest deals to manage cash flow and tax implications.
Overall, free agency has become even more top-heavy: a handful of superstars command unprecedented money and length, while the broader market is less generous to average players and spending remains concentrated among a few high-revenue teams. These patterns have been consistent drivers of the market from the post-lockout period onward.
Me again: I will highlight the last point. That situation is AWFUL for fans, if you happen to live in Flyover country. If teams are constrained in what they can pay the elite two things will happen: A. More teams will be in the running to SIGN superstar players, and B. 2nd and 3rd tier free agents will have more of a market for their services.
50% of players make $1.5M or less. That hasn't changed during the course of the latest CBA. (That percentage will likely increase if the players get the rosters expanded to 28.) 24 of the 30 teams have had payroll under the proposed floor during the last 5 season. Because a cap system will limit contracts that cause the right-skewing the median player's salary HAS to increase because you cannot have differences in payroll between teams of almost $300M anymore. (Not to mention the "deferred" shenanigans that players fight for that let the ACTUAL difference get to $400M+.) This is entirely driven by superstar salaries/contract. This is not caused by regular veteran players.
This is idiotic. A YouTube channel isn't addressing the public. So, you wouldn't allow any convict to write a letter to the editor?
"Free expression rights do not automatically end with a criminal conviction in Western legal systems. While a conviction—and subsequent imprisonment or supervision—can allow narrower restrictions tied to security or penological needs, people retain core free expression rights during and after punishment."
Stop being an idiot.
It is statistics, not my opinion. The distribution of player salaries is severely right-skewed, far more than we see in other pro sports. The players position only makes sense if we assume all teams have limitless pots of money. They don't. They have budgets. I'm tired of the yearly migration of superstars to New York and LA just because they enjoy larger budgets. Is a cap and floor system the only answer? I don't know. What I do know is I despise the current system, I hate it with the burning passion of a thousand suns. Good riddance to bad rubbish.
@spillygoat19 Yes. I saw the results in the NHL. They no longer have "haves & have nots." And players were not pauperized. Polls have shown this consistently. Fans don't like the status quo.
@OnlyCardsFans No, because I truly believe the outcome will be a better game for fans. I also believe it will benefit the median MLB player who won't have their pay artificially lowered by superstars getting ludicrous contracts.
@OnlyCardsFans No, they haven't made ANY meaningful offers at all. (No, I do not count gutting the current luxury tax to insignificance as a serious proposal. It was more of a middle finger to ownership, and they know it.)
@OnlyCardsFans "Owner imposed"? It has been known for five years. It was part of the CBA players voted for. True they have extended previous ones when ironing out details, but the players will not listen to ANY meaningful change to the status quo. They literally have offered NOTHING.
@OnlyCardsFans It's also mendacious because we know there will be a lockout. The players haven't even bothered to send a counter proposal and don't seem likely to.