Rosenthal: "San Francisco would want a 'very strong return' for Webb ... And while a number of clubs are desperate to add starting pitching, some rival executives are skeptical the Giants will get their price."
To that degree, that's why the gap between "listening" to offers and "engaging" with offers is the biggest gap to overcome.
Think about how long Sandy Alcántara or Joe Ryan have reportedly been drawing interest. These teams aren't the Brewers with dev infrastructure to lean on.
% of Giants SP fWAR that came from Logan Webb
2026: 32.9%
2025: 45.0%
2024: 46.8%
2023: 52.1%
2022: 24.2%
Trading him would be a fundamentally franchise-altering decision. An interested team would really have to grab their attention. Can't be less than the Crochet package
I'd imagine they want someone who can be in the rotation in 2027. If they go for a young and controllable arm, that's the lone headliner. If it's an upper minors prospect, then we're talking about one or two other top 10 org prospects being in the trade.
@ImNotHuman123 What in your opinion would be exceptional and at least somewhat plausible? Don’t think top pitching prospects currently lineup so would have to be for someone who has already debuted and someone who could use Webb. Idk, Cubs, White Sox, Braves, Jays make sense?
Atlanta has perhaps the most plentiful options. They have three 20 year olds at the top of their farm, all of whom have gotten to AA. One of them, Owen Murphy/Luke Sinnard, and a couple org 20-35 toss ins. That's the sort of package a rebuilding team would want to get
The only prospect I would want from the Cubs is Cade Townsend, but going after recently drafted players is always risky business. Nationals thought they landed a good one in Gavin Fien last offseason and he went on to post a 98 wRC+
Like the reports of them listening on Devers, etc. at the deadline, this can probably be filed under "due diligence"
The market for a high level SP with 2 years of control left might be very good pre-lockout, when teams are hesitant to move rentals. It might not be.
Jimmy Herget: Journeyman RHP, spinny stuff from a funky release (4º arm angle), good 2025 then poor 2026. Added cutter as most used pitch this year
Gabriel Arias: Still-young strong defensive SS, big whiffs but minor pop, reverse splits, sprint speed down to 33rd percentile
Non-tenders that fit SF needs 🧵
Davis Schneider: 27 y/o, $1.3MM arb projection, RHH OF, decent enough LF defender, career 13.6% BB% and 13.1% barrel% on heavy lift+pull tendancies, reverse splits, K problems
Noah Murdock: RH reliever, 94-95 SI, 85 MPH slurve, has flashed 87 MPH CH with -1.7" vert, throws a lot of meh cutters, 10%+ BB rates
Leo Balcazar: 22 y/o MINF has not debuted, 83 wRC+ btwn AA/AAA in 2026, 2 options remaining, scouts like his defense, 40-45 hit/power tools