Typical Gamer would NOT have gotten the Pirate Token if he had stayed in that match. His teammates wouldn't have gotten it either.
Fortnite Butterfly effect is REAL! The token is not just sitting in a chest waiting for you to open it. It's all RNG. One tiny change would have led to a completely different outcome. Him leaving is what led to his teammates getting the token. If he would have stayed NO ONE would have gotten it.
So @TypicalGamer please don't feel bad for not getting it last night. In fact your teammates owe you dinner or something because you LITERALLY caused the perfect circumstance for them to get it.