@jessica_313_ These things are nuanced its not black or white. By that logic because people are opressed it means Allah swt is unjust. Every living thing rich/poor, healthy/disabled already has its rizk ordained by Allah.
“We will not be questioned” is a remarkable opening from someone demanding accountability from everyone else.
The subject was whether the platforms you defend promote anti-Muslim prejudice. Your response was to point at Iran. Address the accusation. Your opponent’s position on Tehran does not establish your innocence on an entirely different question.
Your account of Syria also leaves out inconvenient facts. Reuters documented Hezbollah and Syrian troops fighting ISIS on the Lebanese–Syrian border, and Hezbollah fighting Nusra Front militants. Barzani publicly confirmed Iranian weapons support for Iraqi Kurdish forces fighting ISIS.
Those organisations were real. Their victims were real. Describing the conflict simply as Shia forces slaughtering Sunnis obscures the distinction between civilians and armed jihadists. Sunni civilians deserve justice; ISIS and al-Qaeda cannot be treated as representatives of Sunni Muslims.
Then there is your standard: killing Muslims supposedly discredits Tehran, while you celebrate Riyadh without addressing the Saudi-led coalition’s record in Yemen. UN investigators documented coalition attacks that may amount to war crimes. How does your stated principle apply there?
Apply the same standard. A victim’s worth does not depend on whether acknowledging their suffering embarrasses your preferred government. Neither Saudi nor Iranian wrongdoing excuses the other.
And your alleged Iranian–Israeli “dialectical dance”? Produce evidence of coordination. Governments exploiting a conflict politically does not prove they jointly engineered it. Elaborate vocabulary cannot do the work of evidence.
The Mecca defence pact establishes a military alliance. It does not establish moral superiority, answer the original accusation, or make you the spokesman for “most Muslims.”
You have offered a change of subject, a selective account of the battlefield, and an unsupported theory of coordination—then announced that you will not be questioned.
You do not get to declare yourself beyond scrutiny while demanding it of everyone else.
@BalaamAndDonkey You retard they weren’t ‘saudi’, Saud is a family. In fact, the Saud family usurped those lands from the descendants of the Prophet s.a.w.w
Yes. Historical accounts confirm Wahhabi-Saudi forces in the First Saudi State conducted raids in Hijaz massacring civilians in homes, markets and mosques, accusing them of shirk for practices like tomb veneration. They massacred hundreds in Taif in 1802-3. Blockades caused starvation in Makka and Madina (residents ate dogs). In 1924-25 they overthrew Hashemite Sharifs (Prophet's Sayyid descendants ruling Hijaz for centuries), driving them out for Najdi rule.