Full text of article:
Jay Bhattacharya, head of the National Institutes of Health, has written to Nature Medicine journal demanding a “formal, independent investigation” into why a key scientific paper misled the world about the virus causing Covid, and concealed the contributions made by three senior scientists to commissioning, reviewing and editing the paper.
In a career as a science writer that spans more than four decades, I have never seen an alleged case of scientific malpractice as influential. Like many others I have called for the paper to be retracted. Twice, the editor of the journal, Joao Monteiro, has been sent letters from numerous leading scientists demanding an investigation or retraction of the misleading paper. He has ignored us.
I know the paper entitled “Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” was misleading because I was among those misled. At the time I sat on the science and technology select committee of the House of Lords and we were conducting an inquiry to try to understand this new virus threatening all our lives. The possibility that it had been accidentally released from a laboratory, if true, would have significant implications for the public-health response: a virus marinaded in human tissues in a laboratory for weeks would be far more infectious than one newly arrived from bats.
Parliamentary colleagues were asking me what I thought. To my shame, I told them a lab leak could be ruled out. I did so based almost entirely on the authority of this one paper. That very phrase “ruled out” appeared in the press announcement of the paper from the institution where the lead author, Kristian Andersen, worked. The article itself left no room for doubt: “we do not believe that any type of laboratory based scenario is plausible… our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct.”
That these words appeared in Nature Medicine gave them a stamp of authority, or so I believed. The paper was subsequently viewed millions of times and cited in thousands of academic papers. The journal and the authors of the paper therefore had a special responsibility not to allow themselves to be misled. Yet we now know that Proximal Origin’s arguments were flawed and released Slack messages and emails show several of its authors were expressing exactly the opposite opinion in private both before, during and after publication. They still thought a lab leak was “friggin likely”, in the words of Andersen.
Worse than all that, congressional investigations have uncovered records strongly indicating that three of the most senior medical scientists in the world, Francis Collins (Bhattacharya’s predecessor as head of the National Institutes of Health), Anthony Fauci (head of National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and Jeremy Farrar (head of the Wellcome Trust) had not only seen the paper before publication, but – according to a House Select Subcommittee report – had prompted its authors to write it in the first place, had reviewed it and even suggested alterations in wording. Fauci referred to the paper from the White House podium, giving no hint of his own role in it.
These men were heads of the bodies that funded the scientists’ work, yet they were not listed as co authors or acknowledged in the paper, despite the journal’s stated policy that authors disclose any funder’s “involvement in the conceptualisation, design, data collection, analysis, and preparation of the paper”. Farrar even suggested a change of wording to strengthen its conclusion: from “unlikely” to “improbable”. Why was he not acknowledged? Robert Garry, one of the authors, wrote to his colleagues: “Jeremy has been an amazing leader – should be author.”
Ed Holmes, another author, replied: “I agree, and I offered, but he wants to remain independent.” As we wrote to the journal editor in 2024: “This omission of a significant role played by the head of a funding agency, allegedly to maintain his ‘independence’, represents a serious breach of publishing ethics that completely undermines the credibility of the journal and calls into question the motivation behind the paper.” Answer came there none.
It should infuriate the journal’s editor that the paper appears to have been commissioned, designed and intended to shut down all debate about a possible laboratory origin of the most destructive pandemic in a century despite going directly against its authors’ own opinions. For the sake of science’s integrity the journal must act on Dr Bhattacharya’s letter.
MMR vaccine uptake decreased under Biden/Becerra from 95.2 when Biden took office to 92.7% when he left office. 80% of measles cases are in people over 5 years old. Below chart based on CDC numbers. In Jan. 2025 RFK Jr put out a missive encouraging MMR vaccinations and outlined a program to bring up vaccination rates. https://t.co/AarUrVJA2s
80% of the measles cases are people over 5 years of age well before RFK became HHS Secretary. It’s a global outbreak. UK, Canada and Spain lost their measles elimination status. Vaccine uptake declined during Biden/Becerra, from 95.2% To 92.7 when Biden left office. Is Becerra to blame for the drop? USA still has among the highest percentage of citizens vaccinated against measles. In 2025 RFK encouraged MMR vaccinations. https://t.co/AarUrVJA2s
ABC News executed a coordinated political hit job disguised as journalism. By posting an error-laden October 7 article about a venture capital firm tied to Donald Trump Jr. ABC’s newsroom abandoned basic standards of verification, fairness, and editorial integrity simply to manufacture a smear against Donald Trump Jr.
Such reckless reporting represents an institutional failure from top to bottom. Somebody pitched the story, somebody wrote the script, and senior executives at ABC News signed off on broadcasting falsehoods to millions of Americans.
ABC News owes Donald Trump Jr. and the American public an immediate, on-air apology and a full retraction. Furthermore, every producer, editor, and news executive who approved the story must be held fully accountable, starting with immediate disciplinary action. Until networks face real consequences for weaponizing their so-called “news,” trust in corporate media will remain dead on arrival.
How does that solve the “affordability crisis?” Attacking someone because they don’t vote as you do is a kind of bigotry called Political Sectarianism or Affective Polarization. We’ve come to the point where certain factions treat political identity much as racial, religious and sexual identity was once treated by the worst among us—as a reason to demean, other, moralize against, even hate. Just as we rightly should not hate those who don’t look, love or worship as we do, neither should we discriminate against those who merely don’t vote as we do. https://t.co/rmtKJxG3Nm
There was a brief moment in which good people were divided: Was Russell Brand a rapist finally brought to justice, or a political prisoner whose grotesque behavior made him hard to defend?
The absurd and despicable attempt to silence Brand's wife should remove any remaining doubt. The Brands--now both of them--are being silenced, for a reason. And you and I are the ultimate target. There are voices we aren't going to be allowed to hear.
In the West, we don't punish wives for the sins of their husbands, or for standing by them. We don't stop people from asserting they have been falsely convicted. We don't selectively prosecute.
We are witnessing the evolution of "cancelation" in the West, when it stops being about being ejected from venues and platforms, is no longer about demonitization, or even debanking. Russell Brand's liberty has now been canceled. Think about that.
We must Restore Britain, Rescue the Republic and Defend the West. There is no alternative. Failure is not an option.
https://t.co/rYEGRQPpri You give RFK waaay too much credit. He’s not that powerful. Not swallowing his opinions whole. Some I agree with and some I don’t. That he single-handedly caused a global measles outbreak is laughable. There were multiple reasons. Is RFK responsible for Canada,UK and Spain losing their measles eradication status? Multiple reasons: Migration into country of unvaccinated. Local communities who choose not to vaccinate. Babies who skipped immunization during Covid. As I said vaccinate uptake went down under Biden first.
This seems as clear a statement from HHS and CDC as anyone could ask for. But it will not be enough for the Kennedy-haters.
The false narrative that he is responsible for US measles outbreaks is easily falsified by the following facts:
1. Outbreaks are an international phenomenon. Larger outbreaks per capita occurred in UK and Europe in 2024 and Canada in 2025. Several nations lost measles elimination status before the US.
2. US measles vaccination rates increased through the 2010s and only started to fall in 2020, when the pandemic debacle disrupted routine vaccination patterns and dishonesty and bad policy around the covid shots weakened public confidence in other vax recommendations.
3. The US still has close to the highest measles vaccination rates in the world. If Kennedy's intent has been to discourage it, he has been spectacularly unsuccessful.
Meanwhile, the public health establishment has reverted to its familiar pattern of catastrophizing, scolding, and scapegoating. They have learned nothing from the covid disaster.
@Scott259275895@DebraBr81576310@RealCrookedNews 🎯 In journalism school, I was trained to be skeptical of experts, corporations, government officials, academia, institutions. Also taught to explore and discover the complexities and layers there are in most complicated issues. Rarely is it a single cause or one individual.
I was explaining why trust in vaccines and public health have fallen nationally. It’s not all RFK, but many factors. Holding that opinion doesn’t make me a crackpot. It means I want all the layers and complexities of the mistrust explored. Trust in public health is low. We need to correct that. One way is to explore why it’s low. In the USA we are allowed to question experts. I would add that the fact we couldn’t debate Approved Narratives that then proved untrue lessened trust. (Example: if you get the vaccine, you won’t get Covid. But millions got Covid after vaccination. Another example: told it was “perfectly safe” but then found out can cause rare case of myocarditis.)
Dr. Andrew is citing her political opinion. We don’t have to take everything she says as the gospel.
To cite the CDC, vaccination rates for MMR began to decline in 2020 under Biden-Becerra, from 95.2 in 2019 to 92.4 in 2025. (Read the article.) Must of the cases today are in children over 5 who were NOT vaccinated at one year during Biden’s tenure. Much of this is attributable to overall mistrust in the CDC from Covid miscommunications.
When trust in Public Health falls, so does trust in vaccines and the medical community. Blaming RFK as the sole reason is not accurate. Bringing up these facts does not make one a crackpot. I notice you merely name call without citing any proof. Anyone with merely a different viewpoint you label as an idiot or a crackpot without presenting counter arguments. https://t.co/UIXJQw7y9X
@jeffreytucker@grok Isn't the uptick in cases in the late 80s and early 1990s the result of two things—more unvaxxed kids in pre school and only one shot? Once the change was made to two doses there has been very few cases of measles. That said 2026 number of cases is much smaller number.
Don't miss Generation COVID currently streaming on Salem Now. Hollywood should have made this, but of course, they never would. https://t.co/c8yh06zk4h
Here is a free PDF of the short story that @mtaibbi & I will discuss on Friday's edition of the new (& possibly improved) America This Week.
The Veldt by Ray Bradbury.
You'll know when you read it why we chose to debut with it.
Mind pleasure awaits!
https://t.co/rZ5E4KRjmx
I won’t believe they were punished until I see proof. No reporter to my knowledge was fired for spreading the lie that the fake “Steele dossier” was “largely validated” when it wasn’t. No reporter was fired for unfairly smearing @RealSLokhova or Carter Page. No reporter was fired for cherry-picking “very fine people” comments. No reporter was fired for telling us BLM riots were mostly peaceful with fire and arson attacks in the background. No reporter was fired for labeling Catholic kids racist because they wore red hats and smiled.
I don’t like that a termination letter was obtained and published. Did the reporter provide it? The company should never disclose private personnel matters. But if a reporter disparaged people based on skin color and sex, received numerous warnings to stop and did not, then termination is appropriate.
As a former Affirmative Action/EEOC Officer I found many people are under the impression that Title VII of the Equal Rights Act applies only to women and certain minority groups. But that is wrong thinking. If, for example, a hospital decided to only employ female nurses, male applicants could sue for discrimination and likely win.
@sayerjigmi I’m old enough to remember when anyone having Covid but died because of a motorcycle wreck, a drowning, a heart attack, a stroke, or other factors was recorded as a Covid death. It helps inflate numbers to gin up fear. Is measles a serious disease? Yes. Should we panic? No.
I know this is not what people want to hear, and I want to add the caveat that I don’t have any inside information.
But I think it’s always important in these situations to offer some perspective for people to consider.
The frequency illusion is real.
Last week, two major outages affecting the FAA’s air traffic systems and Microsoft Outlook caused substantial disruption and impacted many people.
After two outages on that scale, we’re primed to notice other outages we might otherwise overlook.
That’s where the frequency illusion can come in.
And news organizations and reporters are more likely to cover outages that otherwise might attract little attention.
Hundreds of network outages occur worldwide each week, many without attracting widespread attention.
When they follow two major outages with significant consequences — especially when one of those consequences is the longest nationwide ground stop since 9/11 — they become much more noticeable.
For all I know, we could learn tomorrow that a foreign adversary has launched a cyberattack, but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with pausing for a second and putting everything into context.