@TwinsAlmanac@TownBallTuesday Not sure. But you figure if they follow OBR, MLB, MSHSL guidance. There would nothing wrong with following MABL/MSBL guidance either.
Final results from the poll:
Composite Users: 257 (55%)
Wood Users: 210 (45%)
I think it’s pretty obvious that a full ban of composite bats needs rethinking.
A compromise. MBA could follow MABL/MSBL guidance, which addresses specific illegal bats yearly.
@TwinsAlmanac@TownBallTuesday They used to be when Rookie/Short Season existed. But that is no longer a thing since everything is under AZ/FL complex league now. Baum & DeMarini both couldn’t confirm whether approved or not now. Baum still shows as MLB rookie approved but I have conflicting emails from them.
@TwinsAlmanac@TownBallTuesday Like I had said. They could just follow MABL/MSBL guidance. National league guidance would take the pressure off of the board to handle it.
@TwinsAlmanac MSML/MABL calls out what you can’t use. Makes it simpler and just update it yearly. BUT understanding science of why is nice. I emailed Baum. They said their bats are not MLB approved at any level. Yet their product page says they are MLB Approved for Rookie ball. Which is it?
@TwinsAlmanac Problem is bats keep evolving. Existing approved Demarinis are no longer being made. They moved onto the Woods/Velvet Thunders. Baum does keep changing their makeup as well. Why are Woods, velvet thunder, & Delano illegal? They aren’t different than the currently approved bats.
@TownBallTuesday@voonder9 They did. Rookie/Short Season has been replaced with AZ/FL Complex League but both the Baum and DeMarini bats are approved in AZ/FL Complex Leagues for entry level pros.
@robbgamm@TownBallTuesday “Finalized”. They’ve decided already from what I’ve been told. But hopefully the blow back is big enough to change their minds.
But You’re absolutely right.
This is an extremely poor decision.
@SusannahDunn So much for unleashing the fury! Btw, well done at Baxter, ya'll sure know how to bring in the 3rd period. Minus that god awful hockey song during the intermission. 😆
@TwinsAlmanac@imthe1nonlyD@TBScheduleGuy@MinnBaseball@TalkinTownball@Townball218 I got our team a Demarini 3 years ago. And a new Baum this last year. Each about $250-300. But both last 4+ years with 10-15 guys using all summer. So $500-600 total for 4 years. Or now 3-4 wood bats per player per year at $100 each. So $3000-4500 per season in wood bats min. 🤢
@TownBallTuesday Agreed. Might as well just keep the existing bats legal. I think it’s funny that these previously approved bats are allowed at certain professional levels but heaven forbid unpaid amateur baseball.
@TheRabidOne3@AndrewSCSUHHP Well then just put it behind a pay wall. If people are going to stay home, at least make them pay to watch. 🤷♂️ Gotta make money somehow. Free OTA won't do it.
@MetroKnights@TBScheduleGuy I unfortunately had to miss this meeting (I don’t miss many). I even sent them all the specs of the new “Woods” and “Velvet Thunder” and how the makeup is the same as previously approved Demarini (per Demarini). So just ban them all? Ridiculous! Huge financial impact to teams.