Yeah, Ocarina of Time Remake is definitely GOTY. And at this rate it might actually have a chance to win the award for GOTY with how much flak GTA 6 is receiving. Most people seem to dislike it, or at least not LOVE it, saying it falls short & flat with various issues.🤷🏻♂️
As promised. The pushback on my post compelled me to do a full analysis of the GTA VI biased reviews. (Long post)
First, the first sources I based my post, the written reviews of: IGN, The guardian, Gamerant, and GamesRadar.
Now the good stuff, I got curious and pulled 72 full reviews in a markdown file and asked an LLM for summarizations, every claim was then reviewed by me entering the site and checking by myself.
GTA is a good game, I'm not trying to fight that, but its not flawless and from what I notice :
- 50 of 72 outlets mention the game has performance issues, 20 fps recorded as the lowest on PS5. This happens not only on busy areas.
- Many mention criticism about the story(40) and pacing(25), Jason is openly called dull, the story has a very slow beginning, sags at the middle and rushes the end. Many also mention how predictable is the story and the grind you need to do sometimes in terms of money or reputation
- 25 complained about the movement and combat, they say movement feels clunky, combat is button smashing and some said the controls were inconsistent, triggering actions different than intended.
- A group complained because you can't own properties or businesses, also the lack of minigames in casinos, rampage, tennis. Missions aren't replayable.
- A minor (15) group commented negatively about the game's difficulty and how easy it is sometimes, allowing the player to skip missions if you die too many times.
- Another minor group noted how bonus content and locations are gated behind the ultimate edition.
Every other complaint was about small cosmetic bugs, and other dumb stuff. Still, it's a lot of complaints for a 99 game isn't it? So let's name and shame!
I'll put the name and the score in parentheses, and a quote from the review:
- The guardian (5/5): "This can be a frustrating game at times: unpredictable, laborious, unwieldy and, occasionally, unfair."
- HobbyConsolas (100/100): "Even with aspects that have not convinced me 100%, such as certain ups and downs in the plot, some stock missions..."
- SirusGaming (10/10): "Rockstar has retained some of the clunky and stiff controls... There are moments when the controls seem to work against you." "The frame rate dropped as low as 26 FPS."
- GamingBolt (10/10): "They still feel a little clunky... those guns still don't feel great to control as they lack a sense of weight." "Something so glaringly wrong in an otherwise picture perfect experience."
- CD-Action (10/10): "I also had glitches like a levitating object or strangely behaving shadows." "No version has a performance mode." On base PS5 it "doesn't always maintain 30 fps."
- MMORPG dot com (10/10): "Long stretches of in-game time between when critical path missions become available sometimes felt a bit too long."
- GamesRadar (10/10): The heat system "can fluctuate between being a little frustrating... and utterly thrilling"; "Core mission design is still cinematic and largely linear by design."
After getting frustrated again reviewing that, I created the following weighted list:
Core gameplay: 1.5
Bugs, severe: 1.5
Performance: 1.2
Story and writing: 1.2
Pacing and gating: 1.0
Difficulty and AI: 0.8
Realism friction: 0.7
Missing features: 0.6
Iteration, not innovation: 0.6
Monetization and price: 0.6
Bugs, cosmetic: 0.5
Tone and content: 0.5
Localization and accessibility: 0.5
And with that I calculated how a theoretical, more unbiased score would be, the result?
92.8, compared to a published average of 98.6
So hey, still pretty good! As I said at the beginning, it might be a good game, it'll be a great game for many. And I applaud rockstar for being this consistent on releasing good experiences.
My problem is how this is not a new conversation, this industry has been strong-arming an already precarious journalism environment in pro of pushing fake metrics, a problem I think people are getting as accepting of as companies want, calm, and consuming.
One should be allowed to have objective, unbiased opinions, and still love something. Hell one of my favorite games ever is Ys8 and I still consider it an 7/10 because my personal experience with a game should not reflect on a number.
You can have 10/10 opinion, just keep them between friends and outside newspapers.
Alright lunch break is over, bye.
@NathanJ2408 Idk that there necessarily was a monetary element to it (for legality reasons, as you'd have to disclose such info) BUT, I do believe at least SOME reviewers probably feared being blacklisted, while others are probably just biased & inconsistent with their standards😅
@PaulTassi No one said it is. This is beyond just not having zero flaws. There are multiple issues, bugs, fps dips, multiple outlets had various gripes (not just one or 2 small things) and still all gave it perfect 10. It might be great, but it obviously isn't a perfect 10. Double standards
As promised. The pushback on my post compelled me to do a full analysis of the GTA VI biased reviews. (Long post)
First, the first sources I based my post, the written reviews of: IGN, The guardian, Gamerant, and GamesRadar.
Now the good stuff, I got curious and pulled 72 full reviews in a markdown file and asked an LLM for summarizations, every claim was then reviewed by me entering the site and checking by myself.
GTA is a good game, I'm not trying to fight that, but its not flawless and from what I notice :
- 50 of 72 outlets mention the game has performance issues, 20 fps recorded as the lowest on PS5. This happens not only on busy areas.
- Many mention criticism about the story(40) and pacing(25), Jason is openly called dull, the story has a very slow beginning, sags at the middle and rushes the end. Many also mention how predictable is the story and the grind you need to do sometimes in terms of money or reputation
- 25 complained about the movement and combat, they say movement feels clunky, combat is button smashing and some said the controls were inconsistent, triggering actions different than intended.
- A group complained because you can't own properties or businesses, also the lack of minigames in casinos, rampage, tennis. Missions aren't replayable.
- A minor (15) group commented negatively about the game's difficulty and how easy it is sometimes, allowing the player to skip missions if you die too many times.
- Another minor group noted how bonus content and locations are gated behind the ultimate edition.
Every other complaint was about small cosmetic bugs, and other dumb stuff. Still, it's a lot of complaints for a 99 game isn't it? So let's name and shame!
I'll put the name and the score in parentheses, and a quote from the review:
- The guardian (5/5): "This can be a frustrating game at times: unpredictable, laborious, unwieldy and, occasionally, unfair."
- HobbyConsolas (100/100): "Even with aspects that have not convinced me 100%, such as certain ups and downs in the plot, some stock missions..."
- SirusGaming (10/10): "Rockstar has retained some of the clunky and stiff controls... There are moments when the controls seem to work against you." "The frame rate dropped as low as 26 FPS."
- GamingBolt (10/10): "They still feel a little clunky... those guns still don't feel great to control as they lack a sense of weight." "Something so glaringly wrong in an otherwise picture perfect experience."
- CD-Action (10/10): "I also had glitches like a levitating object or strangely behaving shadows." "No version has a performance mode." On base PS5 it "doesn't always maintain 30 fps."
- MMORPG dot com (10/10): "Long stretches of in-game time between when critical path missions become available sometimes felt a bit too long."
- GamesRadar (10/10): The heat system "can fluctuate between being a little frustrating... and utterly thrilling"; "Core mission design is still cinematic and largely linear by design."
After getting frustrated again reviewing that, I created the following weighted list:
Core gameplay: 1.5
Bugs, severe: 1.5
Performance: 1.2
Story and writing: 1.2
Pacing and gating: 1.0
Difficulty and AI: 0.8
Realism friction: 0.7
Missing features: 0.6
Iteration, not innovation: 0.6
Monetization and price: 0.6
Bugs, cosmetic: 0.5
Tone and content: 0.5
Localization and accessibility: 0.5
And with that I calculated how a theoretical, more unbiased score would be, the result?
92.8, compared to a published average of 98.6
So hey, still pretty good! As I said at the beginning, it might be a good game, it'll be a great game for many. And I applaud rockstar for being this consistent on releasing good experiences.
My problem is how this is not a new conversation, this industry has been strong-arming an already precarious journalism environment in pro of pushing fake metrics, a problem I think people are getting as accepting of as companies want, calm, and consuming.
One should be allowed to have objective, unbiased opinions, and still love something. Hell one of my favorite games ever is Ys8 and I still consider it an 7/10 because my personal experience with a game should not reflect on a number.
You can have 10/10 opinion, just keep them between friends and outside newspapers.
Alright lunch break is over, bye.
Great new set for this next month or so!
Really wish there were physical cards for all of these haha Digital is fun (especially with the quizzes), but where's the physical cards at?😅
The Legend of Zelda Collectible Cards in Nintendo Today! have changed over to the Ocarina of Time (Nintendo Switch 2) pack. Each card includes a quiz to test your knowledge!
@TheRareJer Bro it's WILDDDDDDD LOL Like Cyberpunk launched with bugs and fps issues and got rightfully slammed for it. But it's GTA so...it's the golden goose...like as if it is untouchable. I dislike double standards like that😅
@TheRareJer 100% bro. Double standards without a doubt. Ppl have such tunnel vision bias with GTA it's wild. Not saying the game isn't huge & ambitious and whatnot, but it is evidently NOT a 10/10 almost across the board. It's super sus that most outlets are barely saying ANYTHING negative.
The fact this game barely holds 30fps unless you are on PS5 PRO, and is 1440p (or 720p on Series S), and yet people are giving it perfect scores, proves the tunnel vision GTA bias. Any other game would get its score affected by such performance, despite how good it otherwise is.
Grand Theft Auto VI looks ‘substantially’ better on PS5 Pro compared to base PS5 or Xbox
GTA 6 on PS5 Pro is able to use PSSR to upscale to a almost native-looking 4K
PS5 Pro maintains consistent 30FPS, compared to base consoles seeing FPS dips into mid 20FPS
What is truly crazy/sad...is that Andrew Garfield can realize & acknowledge that something like that HAS to come from outside the natural into the supernatural (has to be God Himself), & yet Andrew still holds back from acknowledging God & casting himself at the cross of Christ.
Andrew Garfield says he realized Hacksaw Ridge’s 75-man rescue was impossible after failing to drag one guy on set
"What he literally did is humanly, physically impossible"
"I was on set and I'm like, I'm going to do all the picking up and the dragging. All 75 guys, chuck them on me"
"I try and drag one guy who's smaller than me, and I'm like, put him on a wire and drag him, and I'll pretend"