@ESPNCFB@espn@MarcRyanOnAir@QualkTalk@TheColeBryson@CamSmith38
With the Conference Championship games disappearing. Something I’ve been saying is coming for YEARS, how far away is a 50-60 team Super Conference(s)?
Gotta play 10 P4, ND should be forced to join.
@espn@NCAA@QualkTalk@MarcRyanOnAir@CamSmith38
If I’m coaching D1 college football this week, I’m having all my DB’s chase the WR OB and knock the ball out of his hands. Who cares if he’s OB, it’s allowed now and should be an incomplete pass, right?
The rule you circled is the general catch definition. Case Book ruling 34 (and its Note) specifically addresses the upright end-zone situation:
> “If the receiver remains upright with the ball and maintains control long enough to perform an act common to the game, the ball is dead in Team B’s end zone and is a touchdown. If he then goes to the ground as the result of a second occurrence, it remains a touchdown. If he goes to the ground during the process of the catch and loses the ball… then the pass is incomplete.”
Lofton remained upright, got both feet down inbounds in the end zone, and subsequently then stepped out of bounds and the ball was punched out thereafter. He maintained control in the air, landing on both feet and control until he stepped out of bounds at which point the play becomes dead.
Once the catch elements under Rule 2-4-3 are satisfied while Lofton is upright and inbounds in the end zone, he is a ball carrier in possession. At that moment:
The ball is already dead by Rule 4-1-3c because a touchdown has occurred (Rule 8-2-1).
Even without the touchdown, the instant any part of his body touches out of bounds while he has possession, the ball is dead under Rule 4-1-3a.
We ALL can agree Lofton secured the ball in the air. Landed with not one but two feet in bounds in the endzone with control of the ball. Momentum carries him out of bounds where he plants a foot out of bounds with the ball secured up unto the point of his foot touching out of bounds to which thereafter the ball is punched out...
@MarcRyanOnAir Only thing that counts after touching OB, are penalties. In Miami case both players are OB before the ball is knocked out of possession. I played Corner! Since when can I knock the ball away, OB? That’s the key. In the field of play it’s an incomplete pass.
@MarcRyanOnAir Both were TD’s.
I understand the rule, inside the field of play. However, since when does “touching” OUT OF BOUNDS
not matter? JMO, people who defend this rule probably never played organized football.
@ESPNCFB@MarcRyanOnAir@TheColeBryson@CamSmith38
College football needs to really look at this Completed catch rule, on Out Of Bounds plays.
Being OB used to mean something. Apparently now when catching a pass being OB means nothing.
@MarcRyanOnAir Marc, you know some teams claim Natties but they didn’t actually win it!? Why don’t WMU just post their record at 2-0? Who’s going to make them change it?
@ClemsonFB@MarcRyanOnAir @QuakTalk @CamSmith38@PatMcAfeeShow@TheFanUpstate
Real question,
Is Clemson behind on NIL funds and can’t afford to pay 4.5 million for a QB.
OR
Could Clemson afford to pay certain players more depending on talent and position, Dabo just won’t?
@CamSmith38@ClemsonFB@MarcRyanOnAir@PatMcAfeeShow@TheFanUpstate If that’s true and NIL funds are available, Dabo just refuses to pay certain key positions the current rate of NIL, then Dabo needs to be fired. Pay him the 57 million over the next 5 years and move on. Move on to who though?
@ExcessDepth@theACC Is this is what you wanted?
That terrible GOR & TV contract that you are so desperately holding on to, keeping teams who are traditionally good at football crippled with lack of NIL funds.