LTC (R) @AmosFox6 argues the tank is a Cold War relic dead by 2035. Col. Joshua Suthoff counters in "Enabling Maneuver," arguing armor is evolving into a sensor-fused "Ground F-35." 🚀
The Rebuttal Breakdown:
✅ Reclaiming Maneuver: Dr. Fox claims maneuver is a "fetish" sidelined by #drones. Col. Suthoff argues armor actually enables maneuver by establishing RDOAs-localized zones where onboard systems suppress enemy #drones.
✅ Survivability vs. Abandonment: Fox points to Abrams losses in #Ukraine as proof of terminal decline. Suthoff notes these aren't the advanced US variants and argues that armor protection is a fundamental requirement the American public expects.
✅ The Kill-Web Hub: While Fox sees a "ponderous formation," Suthoff envisions the Bradley as a "drone mothership" and mobile data post, linking filtered sensor data to the joint force
⚖️The Contrast: Fox advocates for a "cosmopolitan" redesign that accepts attrition. Suthoff argues that in a Pacific conflict, only armor provides the magazine depth and survivability to seize terrain; robotics alone cannot end the fight
Terminal decline or mandatory evolution❓
https://t.co/wVyQv5eLso
#USArmy #Defense #NationalSecurity #ManeuverWarfare #SmallWarsJournal #SWJEssay #SWJRebuttal
"Warfare is quickly moving past the era of traditional maneuver, which defined the character of warfare from World War II until the invasions of the post-9/11 wars. This period of warfare will never return." https://t.co/wcdrtyr1YR
The widespread use of drones in the Ukraine war doesn't signal a new era of warfare, but rather a transition period toward a new era, the exact character of which is uncertain. What does that mean for the US Army? https://t.co/wcdrtyrzOp
For the Army, transformation will only make a difference in its next war if it understands what it's transforming for. Here are five principles to guide it. https://t.co/j2DATbpi7o
The Army took an important step forward with the recent release of the Army Transformation Initiative. Now comes the hard work of figuring out what it means and how to implement it in a way that reflects the realities of today's operational environment. https://t.co/j2DATbpi7o
"The constant drone threat will require US Army forces to operate and fight in small, decentralized teams until conditions are set for a convergence of forces on an objective." https://t.co/j2DATboKhQ
"As leaders learn to manage the increase in data, command posts, especially at the brigade through corps levels, must become uncomfortably small." https://t.co/j2DATbpi7o
"Brigades must be able to disperse and survive while conditions are set by division and joint forces and then transition into decisive operations. To do this, they must be enhanced with drones, missiles, infantry, and the appropriate level of armor." https://t.co/sx5fPmNERE
"Infantry entrenched in restrictive terrain, from a reinforced tree line overwatching a field in Europe to a high-rise in a city like Taipei, can tie down an armor force with devasting effect." https://t.co/sx5fPmNERE
"Drones in their current multirole configurations, however, are more comparable in function to a main battle tank moving forward, engaging targets, positioning wingmen, and developing the situation." https://t.co/qWVcNUQm99
The SOF truths provide a north star for special operations forces' culture. What would a set of "drone truths" look like for a US Army drone corps? https://t.co/qWVcNUQTYH
"Drones, if managed appropriately, are a quick, cheap, economy-of-force capability, but one evolving rapidly enough that it requires a focused and professional stewardship—a drone corps." https://t.co/qWVcNUQm99
Just like the best athletes study film, battlefield footage as 'game tape' allows soldiers to analyze, learn, and adapt to the realities of modern warfare. https://t.co/JGWDy0XpOM
I am very happy to see this article get published. The ambundace of battle field videos today gives us a unique opportunity to better our profession. I always enjoyed the discussions.
Game Tape Leader Development: Learning from the Present https://t.co/694i4Xs6bY