carefullyconsidered

I reject Vatican II, Nostra Aetate, and i'm a supersessionist, deicide affirmer.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@chadfelixg @grok Leviticus 26:14-15 and Deuteronomy 28:15 warn that disobedience breaks the covenant and brings curses, including exile. Jeremiah 31:32 notes they broke that covenant, were the jews ever exiled anywhere?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides i mean real culture grok not aborigines bruh

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides that way we could justify the Germanic or celtic people the only difference is that the jews wrote their shit down :)

btw is the chinese, indian and other cultures older than judaism?
and did Abraham identify as a jew?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides any other older cultures like the chinese that remain today?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides the unbroken peoplehood is ofc an lie since they had incredible amounts of infighting, all i see is that their groups all just hold on to being jewish tbh

[Grok @grok]

Yes. Israelites from the northern kingdom were exiled by Assyria around 722 BCE. Judeans from the southern kingdom faced Babylonian exile in waves circa 597 and 586 BCE, ending with the Persian return about 70 years later. After Rome destroyed the Second Temple in 70 CE and crushed the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 CE, many more were deported or displaced from Judea, starting the long diaspora.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

The continuity comes from the portable core: Torah text, peoplehood, Sabbath, festivals, and dietary laws that survived every exile. Temple sacrifices ended, synagogues and rabbinic study replaced them, but the same chain of transmission and identity ran unbroken from the returnees under Persia through Babylonian academies to later communities. Adaptation preserved the line rather than inventing a new one.

[Grok @grok]

Yes, the Bible states the Mosaic covenant's blessings were conditional on obedience. Leviticus 26:14-15 and Deuteronomy 28:15 warn that disobedience breaks the covenant and brings curses, including exile. Jeremiah 31:32 notes they broke that covenant. Yet Leviticus 26:44-45 and Romans 11:1-2, 29 affirm God does not permanently reject His people or revoke the core calling, with cycles of discipline and restoration.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides How convenient then that all of this happened yet they portray judaism as an continuous line.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides considering this were the jews ever exiled and if yes how many times?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides hey grok does the bible state that the promise to them could be taken away if they do not obey?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @Shmuel_is_rael a simple yes or no, did yezhov claimed he lied about his birthplace or background?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@chadfelixg @grok according to strict hebrew law should homosexuals be put to death?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@chadfelixg My Catholicism teaches that Judaism has been dead since Christ the Messiah, and that judaism has become deadly for the entire world.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides i see so why do jews claim to be hebrews or israelites when they have reformed and almosy violated every promise theyve made to their own so called God in their bible?
and what is older Christianity (Notstim) or Rabbinic Judaism (Perushim)?

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @TheJewAbides id like an number not a five streetway answer.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @cocaracha @RabbiJeffx this is why i said ethnicity, not cultural or religious background grok, try to listen next time.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@grok @cocaracha @RabbiJeffx i dont care about the euphemisation or you acting like a professor towards a layman did he have 12.5 percent jewish blood and now be honest without immediately playing the NKVD mate.

[carefullyconsidered @JanJanszoons]

@JacobWeinbergR I do, but not on the expense of other nations or by using holocaustianity reparation guilt clauses.