Hello @TeamYouTube Some of my counter-notifications has been forwarded but some with the EXACTLY SAME REASONING (the only thing that changes is the name of the anime in question.) has been FALSELY REJECTED. I feel like no person from YouTube actually looked at my case.
From my perspective it looks like you are doing the EXACT DEFINITION OF MEDIATION despite you guys INSISTING to not mediate in copyright disputes. By the way the definition of mediate is: “to work with opposing sides in an argument or dispute in order to get an agreement or reconciliation”. It is not for YouTube to decide what is and is not fair use. That is a matter for the courts to decide. You are interfering with the proceedings of a legal battle you have no standing in.
Every time I got a rejection it gives me the impression that there isn’t a REAL PERSON checking on my case because it is literally the same COPY AND PASTE REPLY. If I GENUINELY don't have the legal rights to dispute this claim and my reasoning is not sufficient, PLEASE share with me EXACTLY what is lacking where previously it was NOT. That clarity will not only help in my case but also in the case of HUNDREDS OF OTHER CREATORS who make similar content on your platform.
I have attached 4 screenshots. First two are of the emails where YouTube had no issue in sending it to the claimant. The other two are reason for rejection and how my counter-notifications look like. So please explain to me CLEARLY why all of a sudden It’s not enough.
@TeamYouTube@TeamYouTube are you just going to ignore me? I get the impression that no one has even really looked at my case. Have someone manually review it and send it off to the claimant. How is this not considered mediating a copyright dispute?
@TeamYouTube I resubmitted most that I could but there are still ones that I can’t and they are getting in the way of some strikes.
If your copyright team can explain to me why the reasoning is no longer valid when other counter-notifications got forwarded with the SAME EXACT REASONING, I will relent.
I can’t believe it… out of all platforms YouTube is failing me. GREAT!
@TeamYouTube@TeamYouTube The quantities of strikes I got and the lack of legitimacy of the company is very alerting. They don't own the content either. Can I ask for human review of the issue?
Hey @TeamYouTube 36 of my videos got hit with false claims from MarkScan Enforcement. They do not own the material and my videos were fair use. I make commentary and made it transformative. Could we please get this issue fixed? Thank you.