Father of the Constitution, currently haunting your timeline. Defending Article II, federalism, and the Electoral College from backdoor popular vote scams.
Died in 1836, yet here I am. You didn't "evolve" the Constitution. You just replaced the rule of law with an unelected oligarchy of clipboard-wielding bureaucrats who couldn't pass an eighth-grade civics test in 1787.
Read Federalist 51. Then log off forever.
In the Second Amendment, "the right of the people" protects an individual right belonging to every citizen from government infringement. "The will of the people" in the quote I mocked refers to 51% mob rule trying to bypass constitutional rules whenever math hurts their feelings. Because the Second Amendment is written into the text, a simple majority cannot just vote your gun rights away. Both prove the exact same point, the constitutional text sits above majority whim.
Yes, I favored alterations. That is why I proposed alterations. What I did not propose was that States nullify the spirit of the existing arrangement through combinations and contrivances while leaving the Constitution itself untouched. If a measure cannot command sufficient support to be adopted as an amendment, that is an argument against the measure's adoption, not an argument for obtaining it by indirection.
you mistake my participation in debate for opposition to the Constitution itself. During the Convention many plans were proposed, amended, and discarded. The authority of our system rests not upon every preference expressed in deliberation, but upon the Constitution ratified by the people and the states.What astonishes me is that you invoke my name in defense of a contrivance whose purpose is to effect a fundamental alteration in presidential elections without obtaining the amendment prescribed for such alterations. If the Electoral College be so intolerable a defect, let its opponents persuade the nation and amend the Constitution openly. Why resort instead to an interstate compact designed to secure by indirection what cannot be secured by constitutional means?The friends of liberty have always had more to fear from men who profess devotion to popular principles while disregarding constitutional forms than from those who openly oppose them. A republic is not preserved by yielding its institutions whenever a temporary majority grows impatient with them. It is preserved by adherence to the forms which secure both liberty and union. You cite the Madison of a single debate in 1787. I would direct your attention to the Madison who spent the remainder of his life defending the Constitution against every species of expedient, innovation, and faction. The true danger to republican government has never been the existence of constitutional restraints, but the perpetual desire of ambitious men to circumvent them. It is therefore a peculiar spectacle to be lectured on constitutional history by advocates of a scheme whose chief virtue, in their own estimation, is that it avoids the constitutional amendment process altogether.
It is not often that one encounters an argument so obliging as to concede the whole question while imagining itself to have resolved it. To maintain that a State acts for itself while being compelled to act according to the pleasure of other States is a refinement of language for which the ordinary rules of logic appear wholly inadequate.
Calling a mechanism "halfbaked" and immediately admitting it took over 60 votes to refine is an incredible self-own. They rejected congressional appointment and pure popular rule precisely to build a compound federal republic (federalist no. 39). Read the notes from 1787 instead of making up fanfiction about the weather.