For a man who rails against trickle down economics, what is life like in the most deprived area of Greater Manchester?
Over the last month @SamCoatesSky and I have been taking a deep dive on Manchester.
Watch here: https://t.co/5eplutAlfO
Milburn tells the Times some young people should be taken off the main sickness & disability benefits…
As we reported this week, the flipside of the Dutch approach - that has inspired much of the UK overhaul - is that a decade or so ago the Netherlands also significantly tightened access to benefits for young people.
But that’s mentioned a lot less when ministers talk about how they do things in the Netherlands.
For example, one rule sees younger people having to spend four weeks looking for work or training before being paid welfare.
There’s also a higher requirement for those who can physically work to engage with support to help them into training or a job if they want to get access to benefits.
The Netherlands has a third of the NEET rate we do, so something is working.
But I also spoke to people who were quite critical of the country’s approach to welfare saying it can cut off support to some vulnerable young people.
One worry was about those with severe mental health conditions who genuinely can’t work but are still put in with other more moderate cases that are assumed by the state to be capable of work.
Another concern is that the four week wait for access to welfare had led to some young people taking on more debt and potentially even increased homelessness.
In fact, central govt there has recently given more flex to municipalities over the four week wait & allowed them to lower it for extreme cases.
In short, my sense was yes, the mix of tightening welfare and upping support can genuinely help young people with mild to moderate conditions who could work but need the help and a bigger incentive to. The risk is around those with more severe conditions who could get help pulled from them.
A big takeaway from our trip to the Netherlands was that the angle the govt had focussed on when it talked about the Dutch approach of more devolution and the proactive state was never the full story.
There’s a firmness running through the way they do things in the Netherlands that reaches into increased conditionality and tighter access requirements.
Can the UK recreate that and sell it to MPs and the country? I guess we’re about to find out.
Watch our full report with @JackParkr here 👇🏻
https://t.co/1kfIvBU3N5
🚨 South Yorkshire mayors have just signed off on the deal to buy Doncaster-Sheffield Airport at a board meeting. The price is confidential for now, but likely in the hundreds of millions.
Watch our film to find out what's at stake https://t.co/dFXbU3VUao
Other comments include
"Saying sorry no longer good enough"
"As a tax payer I'm not happy that almost £3bn has been wasted on this re-organisation."
Plus criticism of @YvetteCooperMP for not being on the call...
🧐NEW: In a surprise move, the Home Office is tonight having to have to re-issue its migration reform document because of how critical numbers are presented.
In the "Government Response to the Consultation" Annex A suggests that the forecast for number of people who will settle under the new plan is now 1.9 million (compared to 1.6 million in the equivalent doc a year ago). This is the only place in the document where the 1.9 million figure appears.
But I've been told this 1.9 million is a new +forecast+, but pre-changes. The Home Office says the fresh forecast combined with the impact of today's proposed changes is 500,000 lower - so 1.4 million.
The Home Office say it's confusingly written and that is why they are reissuing the document.
EXC: In an interview with @skynews tonight, Shabana Mahmood tells me:
🧐 The whole cabinet agrees with her ILR changes : "There is only one government position, and that is what all government ministers are required to abide by."
😱 Wont deny she's still uncomfortable with the numbers who can claim settlement
COATES: “But a bit of you must be uncomfortable with over half a million people gaining the right to settlement in just 1 year?”
MAHMOOD: “Well, look, I mean, that's the legacy of the last Conservative government.”
And in her first TV interview since the PM opened the free movement debate:
😬 Says she isn't going to repeat what she thinks about free movement in public. "What I am keen on is abiding by our manifesto" ... "I have views are a matter of public record and you're an enterprising journalist Sam, you can go and read and have trawl through what I think..."
🥵 Says there are other ways of restoring migration control without restoring free movement
COATES: “Do you agree with Andy Burnham's suggestion that you would have more control of migration if we had freedom of movement with the EU?"
MAHMOOD: “I think what what are the, the Prime Minister has been talking about is obviously, once we came out of the European Union, we, of course, lost access, to, databases that were EU wide, that helped you work out a person's movement throughout the European Union. And when you lose access to that, it does. Actually, it's had a very significant impact on us and our ability to manage migration into this country. I've obviously been in negotiations with my EU counterparts to think about how we might collaborate on migration policy, and data sharing is absolutely critical to that. So losing access to data has had an impact."
Shabana Mahmood makes clear Angela Rayner - who designed retrospective ILR changes as un-British - now agrees with the policy. WATCH
A @JoeCookJ production:
Shabana Mahmood has outlined new immigration rules, but just how much has the home secretary rolled back on her initial plans?
Sky's @SamCoatesSky explains what the migration changes mean for millions of people
as someone who works in the software industry in britain, i can't believe there are contracts and estimates like this.
it seems getting these government contracts is incredibly lucrative in the uk, because the amounts are absolutely insane. £1.7bn to £4.4bn for hmrc's customer system? pre ai that's a crazy number. post ai it's still crazy.
for a fraction of the cost you could hire britain's top 50 engineers and pay them £300k a year. over 15 years that's £225m. it would cost less and be way better than what will come out of this.
put the rest into an ai lab and you'd have one of the best funded in europe. but no, it's an hmrc crm system lol.
'The minister has very bravely offered to go through some of the charts from the budget'
@dantomlinsonmp joins @EdConwaySky at the screen to talk through the numbers behind today's announcement
https://t.co/UbdOIQ4Qqg
📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602
Two key snap charts on the Budget...
1) in sheer numbers of policies, it's the "busiest" Budget in modern history. 98 different scorecard measures(!)
2) BUT the average VALUE of those measures was the smallest on record.
Every little helps? Or too much fiddling? Views may differ
In the Budget, John Healey just backed the massive mayoral project by the South Yorkshire Combined Authority which we investigated this week - announcing funds "in my home region, (for) the reopening of Doncaster Airport, led by the Mayor of South Yorkshire"
Watch why it's important - a @JoeCookJ film
https://t.co/qYYLItwlK4
It’s the devolution budget! What will be announced - well I’d bet this project gets a mention, the biggest gamble by a mayor since Andy Burnham became PM
But we investigate the pros and cons.
Do watch this @JoeCookJ film
https://t.co/DhHCGYHNk4
Want to understand what devolution - the theme of tomorrow's budget - really means in practice.
Watch our piece. Film by @JoeCookJ
https://t.co/BQ7RllkOO2
🚨 South Yorkshire mayors have just signed off on the deal to buy Doncaster-Sheffield Airport at a board meeting. The price is confidential for now, but likely in the hundreds of millions.
Watch our film to find out what's at stake https://t.co/dFXbU3VUao
BREAK ✈️: Mayor Oliver Coppard, Mayor Ros Jones and other South Yorkshire leaders have approved the proposed purchase of Doncaster Sheffield Airport from Peel