@JarrodPike@TomFornelli Other teams losing shouldn’t impact two teams who have nothing to do with them. That’s the point. If OSU was the same pod as Iowa all along they should have been over them last week. Committee fucked up and now they caused this uproar
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli You’re retarded. The point is the committee makes up shit week to week which is why people are upset. Rank OSU ahead of Iowa all along if they’re similar. We had the same shitty wins and bad loss to MN last week. Nothing changed between this week and last week to merit the jump.
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli Who is better? I don’t know. The issue I have is that they said Iowa was better last week, then made up new logic to move OSU and Oregon up when OSU has been less than inspiring since Sayin went down
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli I’m saying the logic is flawed and changes week to week. What they did this week contradicts what they did last week. I believe OSU’s a worse team with Fahey and therefore does not deserve the bump they got when nothing happened to improve their resume over Iowa’s from last week
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli And don’t give me the bullshit about they were always viewed similar because clearly they were not based on last week’s rankings.
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli So how does that mean Iowa and OSU are viewed similar now? If those teams were considered better than OSU, and Iowa was the same or better than them, how is OSU all the sudden the same as Iowa when nothing happened in Iowa or OSUs games last week to make either resume better?
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli It’s disingenuous to use those data points when OSU is down a top 3 QB in the nation and he isn’t coming back. They aren’t the same team as those metrics say. I’d be very interested to see the data once Fahey took over
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli And if they were viewed the same, and SC, Ole Miss, USC are considered better than OSU, put OSU at 19 and Iowa at 20 last week. It doesn’t make sense no matter how you twist it
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli Even if Iowa was considered similar to USC, SC, Ole Miss and not above, that still means they weren’t viewed similarly if OSU was considered below them.
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli None of those games had any impact on Iowa or OSU’s (besides USC loss getting slightly worse). Feels wrong that other teams losing can somehow make you lose a spot to someone behind you. OSU should have been above Iowa last week if you are gonna put them over this week
@JarrodPike@TomFornelli You get to join the pod above you just because teams in front of you lost? If they weren’t in the pod the week before and nothing happens to bolster your resume, you automatically jump into it if teams above you lose? So OSU would be behind Iowa if USC, SC, Ole Miss win last week
@LetCounty@ChadLeistikow Not saying Bama should be behind them all but acting like they aren’t getting special treatment is lying to yourself. If their name was Vanderbilt they’re ranked behind Texas and Tennessee
@LetCounty@ChadLeistikow “Aren’t close enough” TX and Tenn both have better wins than Bama. UCLA has 2 less losses and a better win. Notre Dame has 1 less loss and a better win. Indiana has 1 less loss and their best win is 2 spots lower than Bama’s. How is Bama not close enough to make a pod w them?
@KSckamm@SharpSquare13@nopasanada_bruh Dante Moore isn’t coming back this season so that’s irrelevant. The committee set a precedent of evaluating teams based on their current roster when they snubbed FSU years ago.
@Silverbullets97@ethan_petrik What’s the definition of blown out? Bama lost by 16 (1 of 2 Ls) to Tenn and is 3. KY was 6 and above undefeated UCLA in the initial CFP with a loss to Bama by 28. Clearly the committee has lots of leeway in making these games vs good teams risk free. Losses don’t matter anymore
@Silverbullets97@ethan_petrik This isn’t OSU specific. Bama is the beneficiary of this more than anyone (theirs are conference games tho). It doesn’t matter if they lose but if they win they get a huge bump. Obviously OSU doesn’t have to schedule TX and there should be some reward, but it can’t be risk free.
@Silverbullets97@ethan_petrik The issue is that you can’t treat it as a risk free game. If a loss to Texas doesn’t count against you but a win vs them is able to greatly improve your resume (the committee has shown they value big wins over almost everything), then you essentially have a risk free game.