Initial purchase price isn't the main metric. Total cost of ownership over the lifetime of the aircraft is. Lower fuel and maintenance costs could make electric aircraft particularly attractive in low-margin markets.
BETA estimates its electric CX300 costs about $450/hour to operate versus $800โ850/hour for a Cessna Caravan. 45% cheaper. Those are manufacturer estimates of course, but that's a potentially substantial advantage.
Second, how do we define small market? McKinsey estimates 9.3 million regional flights annually and a potential $100B+ market for flights suited to electric aircraft by 2035.
And sure fuel independence is an advantage. But all operators benefit from lower energy costs, maintenance, noise, and potentially making routes economically viable that aren't today.
I agree that the technology still has to prove its economics, aircraft utilization, and acquisition price.
I agree that current batteries and speeds aren't yet suitable for replacing conventional aircraft on three-hour flights. I'm talking about short-distance aviation.
Even accepting your 250 km practical range, that leaves potential applications on routes of 50โ150 km.
The relevant question isn't whether an electric aircraft can replace a jet on a three-hour flight. It's whether it can carry a useful payload safely and economically on short routes. the evidence overwhelmingly says yes there are tons of useful and economical routes that electric aircraft could cover much more cheaply than conventional.
If electric propulsion reduces operating costs enough to make those routes viable, that's a meaningful application even if it never replaces long-haul aviation.
And we already have examples of electric aircraft designed for substantially more than 250 km with payload.
BETA's ALIA CX300 is flying today and is designed for 398 km missions carrying passengers or cargo. It has already completed passenger-carrying demonstration flights.
VรRIDION's nine-passenger Microliner is designed for 400 km with all nine passengers plus commercial IFR reserves, although it's still in development.
These aren't demonstrations of full commercial viability yet, but they show why judging all electric aviation by one aircraft's empty range misses the point. Short-haul aviation is a different use case from three-hour airline flights.
Worldwide, 26.7% of scheduled airline flights are under 500 km, and 54.5% are under 1,000 km. Older OAG data shows 14% are under 322 km.
And in private aviation, 18.9% of flights are under 200 km and 47.4% are under 500 km.
Electric aviation doesn't have to replace every aircraft or every route. If it becomes economically competitive on even a subset of short-distance flights, that's a substantial opportunity.
I have very little faith the government can spend and allocate dollars more effectively than motivated private citizens, in personal areas.
Yes dams and other large projects are sometimes (often times) effective programs but asking the government to know what doctor to see about a problem only I have feels difficult at best.
Ok has anyone found a good branching AI interface?
I get 6 issues back from a code review. I want to talk about each one, but that means spinning up 6 convos or doing it one by one in the main thread.
@samiralibabic@jordwalke not too late. We have the solutions, we are implementing them.
Just not fast enough but the answer when you are in a hole is not 'just keep digging'
@SoniaBaschez Moving ages is just rearranging deck chairs and changing who is paying for it.
We need to make healthcare actually cheaper. Lots of ways to do it.