We see the veteran benefit abuse discussion come up a couple times a year, and the debate is just too close to home for vets. Almost to the point where it is disqualifying for them to participate in. Like judges that have to recuse themselves in court for conflicts of interest. (I am a vet, not that it matters, but I understand the sacrifice of military service).
What I mostly see are two positions that are pro-ignorance when it comes to VA disability fraud. It's people with bulged disks or serious hearing loss, and they served in rough conditions in the Army or Marines, their body is broken down from being prepared for war. The other is the citizens who think without a $1T military industrial complex in forever wars our nation would crumble.
The former sees the VA disability claim only through their lens or worse, someone hit with an IED and has a TBI or is missing a leg or arm. And if that's all you see or know, then sure, how dare you? Right?
But just like the current Democrat or Republican party is not the party of 94 Clinton or 86 Reagan, the VA disability program is not simply those folks who are being rightly compensated. And unfortunately, because they are being rightly compensated, they can't imagine a world where people are being wrongly compensated, especially because it was so hard for them to get their comp in the first place.
But just as the Army and Marine folk can point to their brothers who deservedly have 50% comp because their body is completely broken down from that meat grinder of service, I can point to shipmates who have 50% comp because of compounding frivolous claims when they were in air conditioned spaces most of their service.
I have a few nagging light health issues from my service that I am told could probably get me 30% disability. Maybe more. I am not interested in it. I didn't sign up for free healthcare or a lifelong paycheck - it is not honorable to demand something I did not earn, ESPECIALLY off the back of my fellow citizens.
That was the whole point of Fenix' reply, which was about carving out special property tax eliminations for vets. We didn't sign up for that. We already have $0 down VA home loans which is an amazing benefit to avoid PMI. We also have the GI bill which I think could be improved to have no sunset and a reduced benefit if unused and passed to a child. But you sign up for that. It's part of your contract. None of us signed up for some veteran welfare grab 15 years later for a property tax relief bill or credit card forgiveness bill or free access to only fans or a lifetime supply of ammo or anything else.
The military is a job, psychologically very difficult to cope with at times - you are dealing with a lot of frustrating people and you have to maintain order among some real fucking idiots. Yes, you who have idiots that you work with out here in the civilian world, they find their way into the military too. And you can't just quit and move on. And sometimes they are in charge. And they make your life hell. And you have to just deal with it. It sucks. Then you are away from family. Eventually you may be in life or death scenarios. Military members, some more than others (Justin's point) are deserving of the accolades of service. But so are people that build a society worth protecting. So is the miner, the lineman, the rig worker, and so many more dirty jobs that make the world go round and round.
Sure, the military and those that serve the system ensure our way of life continues. But what is the way of life we have them there to protect, and who builds it? It's those people also working very dangerous jobs, jobs where more people die than those in the military, jobs where your home doesn't have heat without them, your fridge doesn't have food without them, your car doesn't have gas without them. Those aren't military jobs. Those are civilian jobs. And if they do not exist then we don't need a military because we don't have a life worth preserving because we have nothing anyone would come and take anyhow.
So thank you to the lineman, the oil rig worker, the farmer and rancher, the power plant worker, and so on. You put your life on the line and give us a life worth living, and protecting. And if we are going to carve out special property tax exceptions for every veteran, then maybe we do it for every blue collar worker too. Where does it end? How about with everyone, so that everyone owns their home outright. That makes the most sense to me.
This will probably land me tons of hate but I don't care. I'm a civilian, so I'm gonna talk about civilian things.
The fact of the matter is this: there are tons of professions which are far more dangerous than serving in the US military. Even those actually in combat.
Why should a veteran be "entitled" to anything that a logger, fisherman, or roofer isn't entitled to?
What does our country need more of at the moment? Construction workers and loggers, or killing brown kids on another continent for the benefit of Raytheon's shareholder dividend?
I have more respect for these guys than I do for most "run of the mill" servicemembers.
Some servicemembers did incredibly brave and heroic things far above comprehension. Some of them moved crates between bases "outside the wire" and never saw a single round head their way.
I worked in commercial insurance prior to this industry and saw plenty of permanently disabled and/or killed manufacturing workers over 10 years. Nobody's talking about those guys or their families being exempted from property tax or some other special entitlement.
Can we all just be honest about this?
We see the veteran benefit abuse discussion come up a couple times a year, and the debate is just too close to home for vets. Almost to the point where it is disqualifying for them to participate in. Like judges that have to recuse themselves in court for conflicts of interest. (I am a vet, not that it matters, but I understand the sacrifice of military service).
What I mostly see are two positions that are pro-ignorance when it comes to VA disability fraud. It's people with bulged disks or serious hearing loss, and they served in rough conditions in the Army or Marines, their body is broken down from being prepared for war. The other is the citizens who think without a $1T military industrial complex in forever wars our nation would crumble.
The former sees the VA disability claim only through their lens or worse, someone hit with an IED and has a TBI or is missing a leg or arm. And if that's all you see or know, then sure, how dare you? Right?
But just like the current Democrat or Republican party is not the party of 94 Clinton or 86 Reagan, the VA disability program is not simply those folks who are being rightly compensated. And unfortunately, because they are being rightly compensated, they can't imagine a world where people are being wrongly compensated, especially because it was so hard for them to get their comp in the first place.
But just as the Army and Marine folk can point to their brothers who deservedly have 50% comp because their body is completely broken down from that meat grinder of service, I can point to shipmates who have 50% comp because of compounding frivolous claims when they were in air conditioned spaces most of their service.
I have a few nagging light health issues from my service that I am told could probably get me 30% disability. Maybe more. I am not interested in it. I didn't sign up for free healthcare or a lifelong paycheck - it is not honorable to demand something I did not earn, ESPECIALLY off the back of my fellow citizens.
That was the whole point of Fenix' reply, which was about carving out special property tax eliminations for vets. We didn't sign up for that. We already have $0 down VA home loans which is an amazing benefit to avoid PMI. We also have the GI bill which I think could be improved to have no sunset and a reduced benefit if unused and passed to a child. But you sign up for that. It's part of your contract. None of us signed up for some veteran welfare grab 15 years later for a property tax relief bill or credit card forgiveness bill or free access to only fans or a lifetime supply of ammo or anything else.
The military is a job, psychologically very difficult to cope with at times - you are dealing with a lot of frustrating people and you have to maintain order among some real fucking idiots. Yes, you who have idiots that you work with out here in the civilian world, they find their way into the military too. And you can't just quit and move on. And sometimes they are in charge. And they make your life hell. And you have to just deal with it. It sucks. Then you are away from family. Eventually you may be in life or death scenarios. Military members, some more than others (Justin's point) are deserving of the accolades of service. But so are people that build a society worth protecting. So is the miner, the lineman, the rig worker, and so many more dirty jobs that make the world go round and round.
Sure, the military and those that serve the system ensure our way of life continues. But what is the way of life we have them there to protect, and who builds it? It's those people also working very dangerous jobs, jobs where more people die than those in the military, jobs where your home doesn't have heat without them, your fridge doesn't have food without them, your car doesn't have gas without them. Those aren't military jobs. Those are civilian jobs. And if they do not exist then we don't need a military because we don't have a life worth preserving because we have nothing anyone would come and take anyhow.
So thank you to the lineman, the oil rig worker, the farmer and rancher, the power plant worker, and so on. You put your life on the line and give us a life worth living, and protecting. And if we are going to carve out special property tax exceptions for every veteran, then maybe we do it for every blue collar worker too. Where does it end? How about with everyone, so that everyone owns their home outright. That makes the most sense to me.
This will probably land me tons of hate but I don't care. I'm a civilian, so I'm gonna talk about civilian things.
The fact of the matter is this: there are tons of professions which are far more dangerous than serving in the US military. Even those actually in combat.
Why should a veteran be "entitled" to anything that a logger, fisherman, or roofer isn't entitled to?
What does our country need more of at the moment? Construction workers and loggers, or killing brown kids on another continent for the benefit of Raytheon's shareholder dividend?
I have more respect for these guys than I do for most "run of the mill" servicemembers.
Some servicemembers did incredibly brave and heroic things far above comprehension. Some of them moved crates between bases "outside the wire" and never saw a single round head their way.
I worked in commercial insurance prior to this industry and saw plenty of permanently disabled and/or killed manufacturing workers over 10 years. Nobody's talking about those guys or their families being exempted from property tax or some other special entitlement.
Can we all just be honest about this?
@dale_flail_ The abortion debate has people that consider contraception murder and people that believe abortion at nine months is acceptable.
You're statement is equivalent to one of these.
It's square per round hole. Apparently if you don't like Somalis getting welfare you couldn't take a PPP loan during a mandatory shutdown to ensure you retained employees.
It's leftist thinking and behavior and would never be mentioned if he hadn't made his statement about air conditioned military jobs.
@ToshCooey For sure they do, and CA disability is a valid program that you could call out of pocket self insurance, and it's for service connected injuries.
@FenixAmmunition@GoldieLocks1776@cornmazeinsrgnt It's amazing how much of VA disability fraud support is vetbros pretending not to understand things thus making discourse impossible.
They suddenly behave like DSA members.
They are scoundrels. First they try to shroud the conversation about desk jockeys with 100% disability by conflating them with D Bois and door kickers that everyone respects.
Then they parade in a gold star widow who's misinformed to produce a no win scenario.
They're like Hamas with tunnels under schools and hospitals hiding under the cover of children. Their afraid to debate the very specific thing you're arguing against. You've been quite specific.
@GrySpr If you never served, I have cast a cancellation spell on this self-important vetbro's spell and you are now free to stand. Because you know, that's supposedly what we served for, so people can stand up and speak.
You dumb fucking faggot.
Slipping Jimmies are shitheads we hope lose every attempt at defrauding benefits from employers and insurers. Hard workers get injured at work and deserve their claims.
Slipping Jimmies make it into the military, but because they signed a piece of paper and worked in an air conditioned office for a couple years, that means they deserve their claim and benefits for life unlike their attempt to swindle insurers a few years ago in the civilian world.
If we don't let that happen it lessens the claim of the soldier who carried 100 pound packs and have spinal injuries or missing a leg or a TBI. It's either both are equal or we hate the most honorable service members in our midst.
Make it make sense.