@asleepv_v@CoreyWriting That's fine! It doesn't matter how many black doctors are there. As long as every person, regardless of color gets a fair chance at it and the outcome is: the most qualified/competent ones get it, then the system is fair and great! The percentages of skin colors is irrelevant.
@xwanyex I mean, the so called Prof. Gary Francione does appear to be a radical activist - based on his profile. I wouldn't expect him to be an avid consumer of evidence based epistemology.
I think the original poster meant to say that since males are overepresented at the bottom, you'd expect more of them in the lower IQ part (where Down Syndrome sufferers fall).
As an analogy: if you take the average IQ of convicts, the male average will be lower than the female average.
@LoinDuTribu Keep looking for Cofnas' support for concentration camps, invading Poland, made up "Aryan races" theories, living space for the "master races", national socialism, censorship, suppression of individual rights and so on. Not yet found it, would you care to share it?
Only if you are indoctrinated into thinking tribalistically. Every "race" has a distribution of people some smart, some dumb. The division is not racial, it's between smart and not smart people.
Equally, how does pointing oit differences in group IQs - which don't actually influence the group IQs - change this?
A great essay! And a well enunciated, rational position. There is one small issue, the assumption that "globalism has failed" - that is blatantly wrong. It's stronger now, at least as far as the Western world is concerned, than it has ever been. Western governments bow down to internationalism much harder now than at any point in history. The marxist-postmodern-globalist (whichever way you want to define it) momentum seems to only accelerate and regardless of how people vote, it does not appear to have any resemblance of braking. It appears that no one in power really wants this change, the temptation to just repoint the monster in the opposite direction is too strong!
We've stated the problem. The king is naked.
Now the real question: what comes next? Because tearing down a lie is not a plan.
Here is how the West rebounds after the failure of globalism.
First: go back to our roots.
Globalism promised a world without borders, without history, without memory. A civilization reduced to a market of interchangeable consumers, governed from nowhere. It failed. A tree without roots doesn't grow. It falls.
Our roots are known. Athens, Rome, Jerusalem.
Athens gave us reason. Socrates questioning everything in the agora. The idea that truth is reached through argument, not decreed by authority.
Rome gave us law. The res publica, citizenship, the idea that rules apply to everyone, including those who write them.
Jerusalem gave us the dignity of the person. Every human being, rich or poor, powerful or forgotten, carries a worth that no state, no majority and no ideology can take away.
Everything great the West ever built, science, the rule of law, human rights, free markets, flowed from those three sources. Every time we cut ourselves off from them, we sank.
Second: rebuild the system with the lessons of the past.
The 20th century taught us two lessons, at an enormous price.
The first: the majority must never persecute minorities. Tocqueville warned against the tyranny of the majority back in 1835. History showed us the cost.
The second, the one we forgot: minorities must never impose their worldview on the majority. Not activist minorities. Not ideological minorities. Not an elite of a few thousand people deciding for hundreds of millions.
Equal rights for all. Privileges for none.
Nobody crushed. Nobody imposing. That's the pact. It's the only one that holds over time.
Third: put the search for truth back at the center.
For fifty years, school taught us to recite. To find the expected answer. To bow to consensus.
We need the opposite. Education systems built to produce people who question permanently, who reason from first principles, who say "show me the evidence" no matter who is speaking. Socrates said the unexamined life is not worth living. A civilization that stops examining itself isn't either.
In the age of AI, this isn't a luxury. When machines can produce any answer, the only thing that still matters is asking the right questions and telling the true from the false.
Fourth: design systems that protect freedom, and make corruption structurally impossible.
Individual liberty. Consent. Free markets. These shouldn't be slogans. They should be taught, explained, hammered home until they're as obvious as the alphabet.
Then comes the most important lesson, the one Lord Acton gave us in 1887: power tends to corrupt. You don't fight corruption by hoping for more virtuous officials. You fight it by design. The less the state controls, the less there is to buy. Less state means less corruption. Mechanically.
Fifth: point AI in the right direction.
For the first time in history, we have a tool that can track every dollar of public money, every contract, every subsidy, every conflict of interest. In real time.
Corruption has always needed one thing: darkness. If you know that everything you sign is visible, you don't steal.
Brussels spent years trying to scan its citizens' private messages. We have to do the exact opposite: use AI to watch power, not people. Bentham dreamed of a panopticon to watch prisoners. We'll build one pointed at those who govern.
A transparent state. Free citizens. That's the deal.
Athens to question. Rome to build. Jerusalem to remember that every human being counts. AI so that power can never hide again.
Globalism wanted a civilization without memory.
The next one will have its memory back, and the most powerful tools ever built.
The West isn't dying. It's remembering who it is.
A great essay! And a well eninciated, rational position. There is one small issue, your assumption that "globalism has failed" - that is blatantly wrong. It's stronger now, at least as far as the Western world is concerned, than it has ever been. Western governments bow down to internationalism much harder now than at any point in history. The marxist-postmodern-globalist (whichever way you want to define it) momentum seems to only accelerate and regardless of how people vote, it does not appear to have any resemblance of braking.
@BretWeinstein True, both can be true at once. Brand is, probably, a sexual predator, certainly not a "good guy". At the same time, he is now being unjustly politically persecuted. There's only two wrongs in here and they don't make a right.
@Tomberry0@tomhfh Well it evidently is now, since if the definition of abortion is widened to include fully formed healthy babies, then we are clearly pardoning blatant murder. This isn't some case where someone had a 2.5 month geststion abortion - where the debate usually resides.