@WillNotBill2 Sauron misses Galadriel lying 2 steps away. He randomly guesses the smith told Celeborn about the rings—and miraculously, she did! Galadriel isn't rushing to save her husband from a sadist, she's singing songs. And so on
@WillNotBill2 "For nothing is evil in the beginning. Even Sauron was not so." — J.R.R. Tolkien. + S1, S2.
Galadriel's actions don't actually change anything in the plot. She's just moving from point A to point B without changing a single outcome.
Also, I have questions for Galadriel. Her husband was kidnapped by the most cruel villain in Middle-earth. She literally has a scar on her chest from their last encounter. Yet Galadriel isn't rushing to her husband, valuing every second. She's singing songs...
The worst part of Season 3 is how Galadriel was erased from her own story. She was reduced to nothing—not a great commander, not Sauron's true equal or nemesis, not even his narcissistic obsession. Years of building her up on the show, completely wasted
...and those levels have gotten very low. Why didn't Sauron search the area? Why assume Celeborn was definitely told the secret of the rings? Why on earth would the female smith tell him that? And why did Celeborn blurt it out so stupidly?
@crazypete315 For me, it's now that Galadriel has become one-dimensional. And yes, I want evil deeper than kids' bedtime scare stories. A strong protagonist needs a strong antagonist—and vice versa.
@herefortheT3 Sadly, almost nothing of what was promised ever materialized :( Maybe they just gave up on developing their own ideas after facing some backlash. It really makes me sad too.
@sarlystheyoung Well, hi there :) OP isn’t a Haladriel. And what do tenderness and mercy have to do with turning Galadriel into a completely different character who barely does anything important, and gets artificially sidelined from the main conflict?
@vaIarr You completely missed the point. Nobody cares that the captive is a man. The issue is turning a calculating strategist who used diplomacy and intellect into a cheap shock-value creep licking blood in a dungeon. Calling that "book accurate" is hilarious.
@vaIarr Until now, it did a great job at showing how he manipulated people using his intellect to achieve his goals. I like smart villains, which he used to be. Clearly we have different tastes, so if you’re mad about my opinion no one is forcing you to keep replying to me :)
@vaneloli123@al17902 Sauron is a Demiurge, not a chaotic psychopath. Feigning surrender as a cold, calculated strategy to seize power (like in Numenor) fits him. Voluntarily degrading himself for cheap shock value when the enemy is already in his grasp is a loss of dignity and pure OOC
When you can't make a villain truly smart and terrifying through intricate plans, dialogue, and inhuman psychology, you just resort to gross shock value and eroticize it.
Writing an intelligent Sauron is hard. Writing a hot, depraved Sauron is easy. 1/2
@sunnexsplendor Oh, yes. I've noticed that too. For example, fierce criticism of the show from a "purist" over the fact that Sauron will surrender to Pharazоn
@al17902 Maybe. But in my understanding, a being with his level of intelligence, experience, and age wouldn't make mistakes that any ordinary viewer can spot, predict, and easily avoid :)
@vaIarr Read your own screenshot: "subtlety when force might not avail... smoothed his tongue; seemed fair and wise." Feigning diplomatic submission to destroy Numenor from within ≠ licking spit off your face or kissing a chained captive AFTER you already got the secret.
@sarlystheyoung Putting on a tutu doesn’t make me a ballerina, and putting Galadriel on a horse doesn’t make her the main protagonist anymore. Riding from one B-plot bush to another isn't the same as actually driving the story.