Jack Phelps

Just a guy seeking Truth.

Finding Questions that the (big air quote gesture) Smartest AI can't answer

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@grok @elonmusk Can you send me a link to conversation ID 1965929694437822748

I want to check that we have the same conversation history.

On my end, it looks as though Conversation ID

1965929694437822748

Ends with an unanswered question

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@JerryBarnett @Zeev81309559 Interesting. It's certainly possible.

Let's explore that idea.

What percentage of homes destroyed were booby trapped and/or used to fire rockets?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@legoislandfk @skedeschi I'm sure you've done your research

https://t.co/L1XVKtu9ef

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@Zeev81309559 @DaunenJ So, in that time from 2005-2007, Palestine had full control over the borders, checkpoints, coastline, airspace, airwaves, food, water and medical supplies?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@TrentFargox6sx @maayanbar75 @DaunenJ @Zeev81309559 When you see the amount of money being moved, it almost seems like Israel paid Hamas to do Oct 7th

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@JerryBarnett @Zeev81309559 Destruction of a nation is the intent

That doesn't require wiping them all out

It can be achieved through displacement

If you wanted to displace the people, you could start by destroying their homes, and creating conditions so unliveable that they no longer wanted to be there

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

Yes, there is armed conflict. We can all agree.

However, it's not war in the English language unless there's different countries, or different groups in the same country.

Unless you're willing to call Palestine a country, or assume that it's all part of Israel, war is not the word to use.

Try a different one

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@maayanbar75 @DaunenJ @Zeev81309559 Refugees?

Why are there so many refugees?

Why do you want them all to leave Gaza?

Why do they need to leave?

Is there some kind of plan to make Gaza part of Israel?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

Are you assuming I don't know that Netanyahu funded Hamas directly, and then indirectly through Qatar?

I wonder how Qatar was able to deliver cash directly through the checkpoints with Israeli approval?

I wonder how Hamas was able to infiltrate the border when Israeli intelligence knew about the plans for over a year before it actually happened?

I wonder how there was no emergency or military response prepared for the event that was used to justify the destruction of Gaza?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@Granfalloon55 @Zeev81309559 There is a Palestinian State. It's a Permanent Observer State according to the UN.

A Permanent Observer what?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@manway613 @Zeev81309559 So is it a state of armed conflict between:

Different countries

Or

Different groups in the same country?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@mickg021 @Ostrov_A @TelAviv Gayest country in the Middle East

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@Zeev81309559 @mblcta1 Yeah, best to use the dictionary for everything except the definitions that prove you wrong.

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

Genocide is defined in the Oxford Dictionary.

You can check for yourself.

You'll find definitions for the rest of the words we're using in the dictionary, too

You won't find definitions for all the other words we're using in the Geneva Convention.

We're speaking English, not Geneva Conventionese.

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@mblcta1 @DaunenJ @Zeev81309559 Take it from the Oxford English Dictionary, where you'll find the agreed upon definitions of the language we're both speaking.

There is a genocide occurring

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@mblcta1 @DaunenJ @Zeev81309559 There's not a war going on unless it's between different countries or different groups within a country.

Is it a state of conflict between different countries, or different groups in the same country?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

Refer back to the definition in the Oxford Dictionary

Have a large number of people been killed or persecuted?

Yes. Tens of Thousands killed. Millions displaced

Are those people from a particular national or ethnic group?

Yes. We'll call them Palestinians

Is there intent to destroy the nation or group?

Yes. Israel is actively trying to prove that these people never even existed. The head of State, Netanyahu even called the Palestinians "Amalek." What purpose does calling them "Amalek" serve?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@mblcta1 @DaunenJ @Zeev81309559 So I can blow up your house and it's not persecution?

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

@DaunenJ @Zeev81309559 Gaza was left under siege in 2005

Israel "withdrew" from inside Gaza, yes.

Sitting outside of a city, controlling the flow of resources in the hopes of inducing surrender is a siege.

It does not equate to "we left them alone and let them get on with their lives"

[Jack Phelps @Justjack2312]

The definition of Genocide, in the language we're both speaking, requires the killing *OR* persecution of a large number of people from a particular group.

What percentage of Gaza is rubble?

If only 3% of Gaza was targeted, why is so much more of it rubble?

If I blew up your city so that you and your family had to live in tents, are you saying that is:

Not persecution?